General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNew Yorker article: How Voting-Machine Errors Reflect a Wider Crisis for American Democracy
By Sue Halpern October 31, 2018
https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/how-voting-machine-errors-reflect-a-wider-crisis-for-american-democracy
When reports began circulating last week that voting machines in Texas were flipping ballots cast for Beto ORourke over to Ted Cruz, and machines in Georgia were changing votes for the Democratic gubernatorial candidate Stacey Abrams to those for her Republican opponent, Brian Kemp, it would not have been unreasonable to suppose that those machines had been hacked. After all, their vulnerabilities have been known for nearly two decades. In September, J. Alex Halderman, a computer-science professor at the University of Michigan, demonstrated to members of Congress precisely how easy it is to surreptitiously manipulate the AccuVote TS, a variant of the direct-recording electronic (D.R.E.) voting machines used in Georgia. In addition, Halderman noted, it is impossible to verify that the votes cast were not the votes intended, since the AccuVote does not provide a physical record of the transaction.
Election-security experts, meanwhile, used the opportunity to remind the publicyet againhow susceptible touch-screen voting machines are to error, especially because they often rely on outdated and unsupported software. As the Brennan Center for Justice cautioned back in 2008, typically machines flip votes because they arent properly calibrated. This can happen, and does happen, to candidates from any party. But none of that was what we were hearing from election officials themselves. The machines do not have glitches, Stan Stanart, the county clerk in Harris County, Texas, which uses a system called the Hart InterCivic eSlate, told a local television station. He blamed mistakes on the voters themselves.
The irony here is that these particular vote-flipping machines were deployed across the country in response to the monumental failure of punch-card voting machines during the 2000 Presidential election, when so-called hanging chads very likely resulted in the wrong man winning. The crisis that ensued inspired a bipartisan Congress, in 2002, to pass the Help America Vote Act (HAVA). Among other things, HAVA created the Election Assistance Commission, which it then deputized to test and certify voting machines. The act also allocated millions of dollars for election-infrastructure upgrades, much of which was used to replace traditional voting machines with computerized machines like eSlate and the AccuVoteTS. Georgia, in fact, was the first state to adopt D.R.E. touch screens statewide.
SNIP
benld74
(9,901 posts)The same scrutinity
As
Vegas Slot machines
This country would be
Much better off
If Vegas Slot machines received the same
Scrutiny as
Voting machines
Vegas would be gone
In less than 1 years time
targetpractice
(4,919 posts)diva77
(7,629 posts)Not a good fit for voting!!!
Real elections need to be transparent - done using paper ballots, hand-counted at the precinct level with public oversight.
benld74
(9,901 posts)Vegas Casino Commission? Not sure if name
But theyre tested, to ensure nothing crooked about them. Cant be hacked for instance
diva77
(7,629 posts)If a machine has malicious code to change votes, the only total the machine can be tested for is that the number of voters in equals the number of voters out. And sometimes elections officials fail to acknowledge total voter discrepancies as well.
The "voting" machines do not meet the burden of proof that votes will be counted as cast.
Botany
(70,447 posts)Ever since HAVA we have seen a red state shift in voting that does not match
the changes in demographics or the will of the American people.
lostnfound
(16,162 posts)And patterns exist which vary by type of machine / software version, from what I could see
diva77
(7,629 posts)I wish journalists would reconsider the inaccurate and common use of the phrase "voting-machine errors" and replace it with "possible tampering with election equipment"
gratuitous
(82,849 posts)Those errors all seem to be happening in one direction. If Republican votes were being changed to Democratic, those machines would be out of service yesterday.