General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsObjectively False that Trump Provided Unprecedented Cooperation; Stop Parroting Rudy Claiming He Did
It Is Objectively False that Trump Provided Unprecedented Cooperation; Stop Parroting Rudy Claiming He Did
https://www.emptywheel.net/2018/11/21/it-is-objectively-false-that-trump-provided-unprecedented-cooperation-stop-parroting-rudy-claiming-he-did/
If a President makes an expansive new claim to Executive Privilege and the press reports the opposite, did it really happen?
Thats a question presented by the coverage of yesterdays news that after a year of resistance, President Trump finally provided the answers to his open book test to Mueller. Thats because a slew of journalists repeated Rudy Giulianis claim, made in his official statement, that Trump has provided unprecedented cooperation with Muellers team, without noting that the claim is objectively false.
I showed back in February when the press first started parroting this claim credulously, which was first made by John Dowd that it was not true.
<<snip>>
And yet, because Rudy included the claim in the statement he released to the press, many news outlets are repeating that false claim, uncontested. The outlets that subscribe to the AP feed are propagating false claim today, because Eric Tucker repeated that line from Rudys statement with no correction to it. Unsurprisingly, Fox News parroted Rudy. But so did some more credible outlets, like NBC, ABC, CNN, and Reuters. Even the WaPos otherwise superb report from Carol Leonnig and Robert Costa repeated the claim in the last line of their story.
NYTs Maggie and Mike, incidentally, avoided repeating Rudys claim, choosing to include the part of his statement that provided quasi-factual numbers, but leaving out the superlative claim.
Its bad enough that most of the press has repeated Rudy and Dowds claim uncritically since January. But for yesterdays stories, it is all the more important to get it right. Thats because Trump is not just refusing to answer questions on Muellers obstruction investigation, hes also refusing to answer questions about the transition period, before any claim of Executive Privilege should kick in. While thats consistent with what Trump did with Hope Hicks and Corey Lewandowskis testimony to the House Intelligence Committee, it nevertheless represents an expansion of accepted claims to executive power.
The emphasis, here, should be on Trumps claim to be above the law even before he took an oath to protect and defend the Constitution.
Instead, a bunch of copy and paste journalism has made it the opposite.
Thomas Hurt
(13,903 posts)I doubt he told the truth in his written responses.