General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsTrump Admin Tries Revoking Child's Citizenship Because of Gay Dads
The State Department under the Trump Administration is stopping the baby of a married gay couple from coming home with his parents from Canada. They are challenging the longstanding court decision that says that if a childs parent is an American citizen, then so is that child.
Ethan Dvash-Banks was born in Canada, and one of his fathers, Andrew Dvash-Banks, has dual citizenship in the United States and Canada. Ethan was born in Toronto via a surrogate in 2016. Andrews sperm was used ... When the couple tried to move to the United States, they found that the State Department was blocking them.
Trumps State Department is trying to appeal a ruling that forces the government to treat gay and straight married couples alike.
A federal judge already ruled that the State Departments actions in this case were wrong, writing that they were only doing this because of its strained interpretation of immigration law.
Andrew C. Morris, who is the Executive Director of Immigration Equality, echoed the judges sentiments, saying:
Once again, the State Department is refusing to recognize Andrew and Elads rights as a married couple. The governments decision is unconstitutional, discriminatory, and morally reprehensible.
https://hillreporter.com/trump-admin-tries-revoking-childs-citizenship-because-of-gay-dads-35273
tblue37
(65,218 posts)secondwind
(16,903 posts)Initech
(100,036 posts)Docreed2003
(16,850 posts)Freethinker65
(9,999 posts)House of Roberts
(5,162 posts)and they want to move HERE?
The reason must be a humdinger.
Solly Mack
(90,758 posts)Cruel, sick fucks.
iluvtennis
(19,833 posts)SammyWinstonJack
(44,129 posts)walkingman
(7,578 posts)IronLionZion
(45,380 posts)since this administration is going to be spiteful and vindictive to people
JI7
(89,239 posts)because they are typically selfish and/or fearful folks who only care about their own bank account.
ck4829
(35,038 posts)John Fante
(3,479 posts)struggle4progress
(118,224 posts)met Elad ... Andrew i.. and Elad chose to move to Canada, where they were able to legally marry ... There, they had twin sons, Ethan and Aiden, through surrogacy ... Because one son was conceived with the sperm of one father and the other son with the sperm of the other .. one of these .. twins is .. treated .. as a U.S. citizen while the other was forced to enter the U.S. on a tourist visa ...
Meet the Dvash-Banks Family
https://www.immigrationequality.org/dvashbanks/#.XNjtDiMrK-U
struggle4progress
(118,224 posts)By Meagan Flynn February 22
... when the dads and their sons moved from Canada to Los Angeles months after the boys were born, the twins came across the border differently ...
... the U.S. Consulate in Toronto didnt treat the twins the same, because it treated their parents differently: Andrew is a U.S. citizen, but Elad is an Israeli national. Under birthright citizenship laws, children born abroad to one American parent can typically qualify as a citizen. But not in this case. The Consulate wanted Andrew and Elad to submit to DNA testing seeking proof of Andrews blood relationship to their children ...
... after a stressful and uncertain couple of years for the parents and 2-year-old twins, a federal judge ruled that Ethan should have been granted citizenship from birth and that there was nothing in federal citizenship law to support the State Departments policy for resorting to DNA testing ...
U.S. District Judge John F. Walter ... cited three .. court cases between 2000 and 2018 involving married heterosexual couples whose children were initially denied citizenship because the American parent lacked a biological connection to the child. The government lost all three times ...
https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/02/22/one-twin-was-citizen-other-undocumented-victory-court-their-same-sex-parents-rebukes-state-dept/?utm_term=.295f5dd60def
mountain grammy
(26,598 posts)ck4829
(35,038 posts)Totally Tunsie
(10,885 posts)can get no worse, tRump and his minions prove you wrong again. This is beyond absurd, and is indescribably shameful.
I weep for what this nation is becoming under tRump. Despicable.
johannsyah
(58 posts)struggle4progress
(118,224 posts)May 7, 2019, 3:18 PM EDT
By Tim Fitzsimons
Once again, the State Department is refusing to recognize Andrew and Elads rights as a married couple," said Aaron Morris, executive director of Immigration Equality ...
Morris noted that this is settled law in the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, which "has already established that citizenship may pass from a married parent to a child regardless of whether or not they have a biological relationship.
Morris noted that the underlying constitutional principle at stake is: Do you have the right to have your marriage recognized as a same-sex couple, just like all other couples?
That was a question answered by Windsor and Obergefell since 2015, that there is a constitutional right to marriage and to have that right recognized regardless of the gender of the person you marry, Morris said ...
https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/u-s-appeals-ruling-granted-gay-couple-s-son-citizenship-n1002916
struggle4progress
(118,224 posts)By John Riley on May 8, 2019
... the State Department appealed that decision ...
... guidance on its website states that it interprets the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 as providing that a child born abroad must be biologically related to a U.S. citizen parent
in order for the child to acquire U.S. citizenship at birth.
In his earlier decision, Walter called that interpretation strained, noting that such a requirement was neither approved by Congress, nor did it come about through the normal rule-making process requiring public notice and comment ...
https://www.metroweekly.com/2019/05/state-department-appeals-decision-granting-citizenship-to-gay-binational-couples-son/
TruckFump
(5,812 posts)...have no biological relationship to the adopted child, then the child is NOT a U.S. citizen? That would be the "logical" result of the bullshit they are arguing.
What total bullshit. Every state law I know of treats adopted and bio children totally the same under the law. The Feddies, as usual, are full of crap.
I practiced family law for many, many years and I can and will verify that the govt's position is laughable and sick...both at the same time.
Thanks for letting us know the "logic" behind their position. FFS.
Ligyron
(7,616 posts)I'd love to move to Canada at that point!