Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Dennis Donovan

(18,770 posts)
Sun Jul 28, 2019, 06:40 AM Jul 2019

74 Years Ago Today; USAAF B-25 Mitchell crashes into the Empire State Building - 14 dead

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1945_Empire_State_Building_B-25_crash


The Empire State Building on fire following the crash

The Empire State Building B-25 crash was a 1945 aircraft accident in which a B-25 Mitchell bomber, piloted in thick fog over New York City, crashed into the Empire State Building. The accident did not compromise the building's structural integrity, but it did cause fourteen deaths (three crewmen and eleven people in the building) and damage estimated at US$1 million (equivalent to $13,917,000 in 2018).

Details


The plane embedded in the side of the building, 1945

On Saturday, July 28, 1945, Lieut. Col. William F. Smith Jr. was piloting a B-25 Mitchell bomber on a routine personnel transport mission from Bedford Army Air Field to Newark Airport. Smith asked for clearance to land, but he was advised of zero visibility. Proceeding anyway, he became disoriented by the fog and started turning right instead of left after passing the Chrysler Building.

At 9:40 a.m., the aircraft crashed into the north side of the Empire State Building, between the 78th and 80th floors, carving an 18-by-20-foot (5.5 m × 6.1 m) hole in the building where the offices of the National Catholic Welfare Council were located. One engine shot through the South side opposite the impact and flew as far as the next block, dropping 900 feet (270 m) and landing on the roof of a nearby building and starting a fire that destroyed a penthouse art studio. The other engine and part of the landing gear plummeted down an elevator shaft. The resulting fire was extinguished in 40 minutes. It is still the only significant fire at such a height to be brought under control.

Fourteen people were killed: Smith, two enlisted men aboard the bomber (Staff Sergeant Christopher Domitrovich and Albert Perna, a Navy Aviation Machinist's Mate, hitching a ride), and eleven people in the building. The remains of Navy hitchhiker Albert Perna were not found until two days later, when search crews discovered that his body had gone through an elevator shaft and fallen to the bottom. The other two crewmen were burned beyond recognition. Elevator operator Betty Lou Oliver was injured when the cables supporting her elevator sheared and the elevator fell 75 stories, ending up in the basement. Oliver survived the fall, and rescuers found her amongst the rubble. This still stands as the Guinness World Record for the longest survived elevator fall.

Between 50 and 60 sightseers were on the 86th floor observation deck when the crash happened. Three crew members were killed upon impact. The victims were named as Paul Dearing, Lt. Co. William F. Smith, St. Sgt. Christopher S. Demitrovich, Jean Sozzi, Margaret Mullen, Mary Kedzierska, Betty Lou Oliver, Anna Gerlach, Joseph “Joe” C. Fountain, and Albert Perna. The others missing and suspected to be decease are: Lucille Bath, Anne Gerlach, Patricia O’Connor, Maureen McGuire, Mary Taylor, John A. Judge. Clairissa appeared on the tv show "The Ghost Inside My Child" and claimed to be reincarnated and to have full knowledge of being a woman named Anne Gerlach, the show visited the site and told her story.

Despite the damage and loss of life, the building was open for business on many floors on the following Monday. The crash spurred the passage of the long-pending Federal Tort Claims Act of 1946, as well as the insertion of retroactive provisions into the law, allowing people to sue the government for the accident.

</snip>




12 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
74 Years Ago Today; USAAF B-25 Mitchell crashes into the Empire State Building - 14 dead (Original Post) Dennis Donovan Jul 2019 OP
Wow, I never knew that happened. Quemado Jul 2019 #1
You're welcome. It was this event that immediately came to mind... Dennis Donovan Jul 2019 #2
I had the same initial thought on 9/11. LastDemocratInSC Jul 2019 #4
So did I. n/t MicaelS Jul 2019 #7
Didn't know that happened ... CatMor Jul 2019 #3
ESB is built much differently than WTC1-2 were localroger Jul 2019 #5
Will they ever go back to building that way ... CatMor Jul 2019 #6
Well $$$$ are important when building a skyscraper localroger Jul 2019 #8
And it didn't knock the building down? panader0 Jul 2019 #9
Oh good grief. nt Codeine Jul 2019 #10
I was aware of this crash, but wasn't aware of the story of Betty Lou Oliver. smirkymonkey Jul 2019 #11
The B25 Mitchell Mendocino Jul 2019 #12

Dennis Donovan

(18,770 posts)
2. You're welcome. It was this event that immediately came to mind...
Sun Jul 28, 2019, 07:26 AM
Jul 2019

...when I heard the first report of a plane hitting the World Trade Center on 9/11. Until the second aircraft hit, I was thinking it was an accident similar to when the B-25 hit the ESB.

CatMor

(6,212 posts)
3. Didn't know that happened ...
Sun Jul 28, 2019, 08:09 AM
Jul 2019

it is really something the accident did not compromise the buildings structural integrity.

localroger

(3,626 posts)
5. ESB is built much differently than WTC1-2 were
Sun Jul 28, 2019, 09:19 AM
Jul 2019

ESB is a steel reinforced masonry structure. Local structural failures have no tendency to spread. The WTC towers were concentric steel tubes which derived their stiffness from their geometry, and a compromise in that geometry could cause the whole system to fail -- in practice, the hooks hanging the floors up in the space between the concentric tubes were weakened and it only took a few failing to "unzip" the rest, and then that floor's impact took out the floor below it and la-di-da all the way to the ground. That sort of failure simply isn't possible in a building like the ESB, or even Sears Tower (or whatever they're calling it nowadays) which has a conventional rectangular-cell skeleton.

localroger

(3,626 posts)
8. Well $$$$ are important when building a skyscraper
Sun Jul 28, 2019, 03:32 PM
Jul 2019

I doubt anyone will do anything quite like the WTC's any time soon due to the 9-11 thing, but anything that saves weight and construction time will be considered. I think the new WTC is built more like conventional skyscrapers with a steel skeleton. But all the new big buildings depend on innovations that leverage geometrical stiffness tricks to make them possible. I know the Burj Khalifa uses an innovative mix of concrete and steel which is very unusual for a modern tall building, but that actually makes it more like the ESB in some ways. I think one thing we can count on is that aircraft impact + fire will be a thing that is considered for some time in skyscraper design, in ways that it wasn't when WTC1-2 were designed.

 

smirkymonkey

(63,221 posts)
11. I was aware of this crash, but wasn't aware of the story of Betty Lou Oliver.
Sun Jul 28, 2019, 04:47 PM
Jul 2019

What an amazing story. Very tragic about the other victims, but kind of remarkable that more lives weren't lost and that the structural integrity of the building wasn't compromised.

Mendocino

(7,486 posts)
12. The B25 Mitchell
Sun Jul 28, 2019, 04:52 PM
Jul 2019

a two engine medium bomber, was best known as the plane that took place during the Doolittle Raid. It had characteristic that leant itself to that particular mission.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»74 Years Ago Today; USAAF...