General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhat Ails America (excerpt from Timothy Snyder's new book about our health care system)
New York Review of Books
Timothy Snyder
This article is adapted from Our Malady: Lessons in Liberty from a Hospital Diary by Timothy Snyder, published by Crown, an imprint of Penguin Random House, on September 8.
September 3, 2020, 2:34 pm
Excerpt:
The doctors in New Haven did think that the doctors in Florida might have made a mistake. As it became clear that I had some kind of bacterial infection, they suspected meningitis arising from a spinal tap performed in Florida. The New Haven doctors therefore performed a second spinal tap but were distracted even as they punctured my back and searched for the spinal fluid. The resident made an obvious mistake, penetrating my spine through the wound of the previous puncture, which is to say at the putative site of infection. The attending physician had to tell her to pull the needle back out.
People are much poorer at almost every task when they are close to a cell phone; both physicians had kept theirs turned on and close by. I was hunched over a bed with my face against a wall; I know that their phones were present because they rang three times during the procedure. The first was the most memorable. After reinserting the long needle in my spine at a second point, the resident jumped in reaction to her ringtone. Bent over the railing of my bed, I did my best not to move.
My body was at the mercy of the doctors permanent distraction. My friend had called the surgeon who performed my appendectomy; she did not remember the liver finding and did not, at this or any other time, mention that it was in the record. If the attending physician and the resident in the emergency department hadnt been distracted, they could have taken a moment to look up the record of my previous surgery themselves, noted the liver problem, and spared me the second spinal tap. If they had been able to talk to me for a moment longer, I could have shown them my Florida record, which indicated elevated liver enzymes, a clue as to what was happening. I had even circled those results on the paper, but I couldnt get anyone to pay attention to them. If the two doctors had silenced their cell phones before the spinal tap, they could have done what they thought they needed to without shaking a needle in my spine.
Like everything that happened, this wasnt my bad luck or the doctors bad intentions. It is the nature of the system that doctors are harried and make mistakes.
On December 29, after seventeen hours in the emergency room, I had an operation on my liver. Lying on my back in a hospital bed early the next morning, tubes in my arms and chest, I couldnt ball my fists, but I imagined that I was balling my fists. I couldnt raise my body from my bed on my forearms, but I had a vision of myself doing so. I was one more patient in one more hospital ward, one more set of failing organs, one more vessel of infected blood. But I didnt feel that way. I felt like an immobilized, infuriated me.
Read more at link: https://www.nybooks.com/daily/2020/09/03/what-ails-america/
Really powerful, depressing article.
WyattKansas
(1,648 posts)It is based entirely on the profits of three industries on Wall Street, instead of being based on the medical well being of patients in the United States.
ANYONE that directly or indirectly supports that monetary system is self centered death merchant and deserves to rot in hell... The only adjustments the medical industry, pharmaceutical industry, and insurance industry ever make are to increase profits and that is the bottom line, unless the U.S. Government regulates the profiteering. And no, your careers, financial portfolios, and retirement accounts do not justify the dysfunctional profiteering system that harvests patients.