General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsLet's put the United States Electoral College to task!
Last edited Thu Nov 26, 2020, 11:52 AM - Edit history (3)
I say we abolish the Supreme Court, and let the Electoral College vote on these cases. We go to great trouble to form this slate every four years, and they only perform a single function (and poorly at that).
This has a number of advantages over the current scheme:
1) These delegates will only serve for four years instead of having lifetime appointments
2) These delegates are volunteers, so we can lay off the nine justices and recoup all the employment costs
3) These 538 delegates provide their own remote offices, so we can repurpose the Supreme Court building for something better
4) The damage a single rogue or "faithless" delegate can cause is quite limited
The Supreme Court justices have been voting strictly along partisan lines of late, so their votes are entirely predictable. So to that end, we don't need all these fancy-schmancy Juris Doctor degrees. We can task Tom, Dick, and Sally with these cases and get pretty much the same majority rule outcome without all the fuss.
beachbumbob
(9,263 posts)a constitutional amendment so we need to entertain serious policy and actions going forward if we are to make any change at all
Buckeyeblue
(5,499 posts)But I think there can be really good federal legislation that could pre-empt many of the cases that would be destined to the SC. In effect, we could remove much of the "power" the SC wields and turn them into more of an administrative body.
All we need is legislation that grants/affirms rights. Then state laws limiting rights would be irrelevant because of the prevailing federal laws.
Federal laws prevailing over state laws has long established precedent. If the SC were to overturn that idea, we would open ourselves up to seperate but equal laws returning.
MineralMan
(146,262 posts)for changes in our system.
Shermann
(7,399 posts)MineralMan
(146,262 posts)to distinguish it from other posts that propose silly things, but are not meant as satire.
Shermann
(7,399 posts)If it helps, THIS IS SATIRE people. I know reading eight full sentences is asking a lot.
MineralMan
(146,262 posts)I write satirical posts fairly often, usually in the form of a fake news story. For those, I indicate that it is satire by putting BROKEN: at the beginning of the title.
I also include the ;sarcasm; smiley at the end of the post.
I signal satire in other ways within the content of the post as well, but those got missed too often and confused some DUers. So, I added more direct and clear indications of satire. Even so, some miss the satirical nature of the post.
Satire is difficult to pull off, I'm afraid, here on DU.
Shermann
(7,399 posts)I added the ;sarcasm; emoji to the OP but it doesn't seem to work?
MineralMan
(146,262 posts)I used the semi-colons so you could see what the word is to use.
colonwordcolon is how you do it. No spaces, either.
Shermann
(7,399 posts)dware
(12,264 posts)click on the ... at the bottom and voila, the icon appears.
dware
(12,264 posts)about abolishing, term limits, etc concerning the SC, so how do we know, without some indication that it's satire, it's not a serious proposal?
Shermann
(7,399 posts)I'm trying to update the OP
Ain't that the truth, and all propagated by Pissolini and his enablers.
HUAJIAO
(2,379 posts)beachbumbob
(9,263 posts)happen. Starting out with fantasy concepts makes getting to reality tough. Changes to constitution will just NOT happen in any forceable future
dware
(12,264 posts)all you have to do is convince the Congress to take up the task of a Constitutional Amendment, get 2/3rd's of the Congress to vote aye, and then put it to the States for ratification, which requires a 3/4th's vote for ratification.
Easy peasy.
beachbumbob
(9,263 posts)a different America which is never coming back
Delays laws affecting Congressional salary from taking effect until after the next election of representatives
September 25, 1789
May 5, 1992
202 years, 223 days