Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Celerity

(43,302 posts)
Thu Aug 5, 2021, 04:07 AM Aug 2021

Quitting a Job Due to Vaccine Requirements? You Won't Be Eligible for Unemployment

As more companies mandate vaccines, it's important that employees understand the implications of not getting one.

https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/personal-finance/articles/quitting-a-job-due-to-vaccine-requirements-you-wont-be-eligible-for-unemployment/



At this point, many people have been working remotely for a solid year and a half. But many companies are getting tired of that arrangement and are eager to bring workers back to the office in some capacity. Unfortunately, the Delta variant is throwing a wrench in the works. With COVID-19 cases soaring once again, employers need to take steps to protect their employees if they're going to require them to show up to an actual workplace. And to that end, many are requiring that employees get a COVID-19 vaccine before coming back to work. At first glance, that may seem like an infringement on individual rights. But actually, companies do have the right to mandate vaccines. And if you refuse to get one and are decide to quit your job or are terminated because of that, you may be in for a financial shock, because you won't be eligible for unemployment benefits.

Violating company policy means you're out of luck

To qualify for unemployment benefits, you'll need to have lost your job through no fault of your own. If your company struggles financially and has to downsize its staff, for example, that's a valid reason for getting unemployment. On the other hand, if you're fired from your job for consistently showing up late, that's a scenario where you're likely to be denied unemployment benefits. Similarly, any time you violate a company policy, it's grounds for termination. And if your company's policy is to require COVID-19 vaccines, and you don't get one, then you could be terminated and ineligible to receive any unemployment money.

The same holds true if you quit your job because you don't want to get vaccinated. With that said, companies that are requiring vaccines generally need to make exceptions for employees who can't get a jab for medical or religious reasons. In that situation, the burden will be on you to prove that you're exempt from your company's general policy. In that scenario, if you're terminated, you may have a right to unemployment benefits. You may also have a wrongful termination lawsuit on your hands. So in that case, speaking to an employment lawyer could be a good thing to do.

Know the rules

Unemployment benefits can be a financial lifeline when you lose your job, especially if you don't have any savings to fall back on. But if you refuse to get vaccinated and that violates your company's rules, you should be prepared for your unemployment claim to be denied. If your company is mandating vaccines and you really don't want to get one, but you also don't qualify for an exemption, then you might consider trying to negotiate a different arrangement with your employer. You may be given permission to work from home, if not permanently, then at least for the time being while the current outbreak is raging. Getting vaccinated is a sensitive issue and one that a lot of people feel strongly about. It pays to speak up for yourself if your company's vaccination policy doesn't align with your personal comfort level.

snip
13 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

OhioChick

(23,218 posts)
1. Good, I'm glad they're doing this...
Thu Aug 5, 2021, 04:23 AM
Aug 2021

Force everyone to get vaccinated, dammit.

Microsoft to require vaccines for workers at its US offices

https://www.cnn.com/2021/08/03/success/microsoft-vaccine-requirement-reopening-delay/index.html

I believe that Google is on board, as well.

Rhiannon12866

(205,167 posts)
3. Aren't vaccines required when kids enter school?
Thu Aug 5, 2021, 05:44 AM
Aug 2021

Seems likely to me and I can even remember getting vaccines right in school - though I was a kid and don't know what they were. And when my friend returned to college a few years back, she had to get the MMR vaccine before she could attend classes - I drove her to get it. Seems to me that vaccines have always been required to keep ourselves and others safe - at least in my lifetime.

Igel

(35,300 posts)
12. Doesn't matter.
Thu Aug 5, 2021, 11:15 AM
Aug 2021

The argument was made that Indiana couldn't impose a vaccine requirement, and the court ruled for Indiana. U of, that is.

Schools, private and public, can impose vaccination requirements for a vaccine with just EUA.

Schools can't make it required quite yet because it's not available for those under 12, and seriously, nobody's going to watch the calendar. "Jon and Jaela turned 12 today--as of tomorrow, Jon mom and Jaela mom, your kids can't be on campus until they're fully vaccinated." That means it's only really useful for high schools. High school students are at higher risk than those younger (regardless of the terrormongers in the media, this is still true).

Otherwise it's also a political thing in most states. The school board is elected, the school board floats bonds for referenda, and no superintendent wants the teachers to catch untold quantities of flak.

Sherman A1

(38,958 posts)
5. Curious?
Thu Aug 5, 2021, 06:47 AM
Aug 2021

When does one ever get unemployment if one quits? I believe you have to be terminated by the employer and even then it can be an uphill battle for benefits.

Celerity

(43,302 posts)
7. Unemployment Benefits: What If You Quit?
Thu Aug 5, 2021, 06:56 AM
Aug 2021
If you quit a job without good cause, you may not qualify for unemployment benefits.

https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/unemployment-benefits-when-quit-32450.html

To collect unemployment benefits, employees must be out of work through no fault of their own. Workers who lose their jobs in a layoff are clearly eligible for benefits, as are most employees who are fired for reasons other than serious misconduct. (See Nolo's article Unemployment Benefits: What If You're Fired? for more information on this requirement.)

Can You Get Unemployment Benefits If You Quit?

Even employees who quit their jobs may be able to collect unemployment, but that depends on their reasons for leaving. In every state, an employee who voluntarily quits a job without good cause is not eligible for unemployment. But state laws vary as to how they define "good cause."



Unemployment Eligibility if You Quit Voluntarily

Even if you think you had a good reason to leave a job, that doesn't necessarily mean you had good cause in the eyes of the law. For example, it might make sense to leave a job that doesn't offer opportunities for advancement, but a worker who makes this choice won't be eligible for unemployment benefits. Similarly, some people quit their jobs because they find the work unfulfilling or they want to pursue an entirely different career path. These decisions may lead to a better qualify of life and higher job satisfaction -- but what they won't lead to is an unemployment check. In some states, former employees are eligible for benefits if they leave a job for compelling personal reasons -- for example, to relocate when a spouse gets a distant job or because a family emergency requires the worker to be home. In other states, benefits are available only if the employee's reasons for quitting are related to the job.

When Can You Quit Your Job and Still Receive Unemployment Benefits?

Here are some reasons for quitting that might entitle you to collect unemployment.

Constructive discharge. Most states allow employees to collect unemployment if their work situation had grown so difficult that they were essentially forced to quit (for example, if you feel that quitting is the only option because of constant sexual harassment, dangerous working conditions that your employer refuses to remedy, or a manager's demands that you commit an illegal act). If a reasonable person in that situation would have found the working conditions intolerable, quitting most likely won't make you ineligible for benefits. Legally, constructive discharge is considered a form of wrongful termination, not a voluntary quit.


Bernardo de La Paz

(48,988 posts)
6. No worries, RepubliQons don't take socialism dollars, right? Actually, employees may have grounds
Thu Aug 5, 2021, 06:47 AM
Aug 2021

I think that there might be grounds for unemployment payments if the company changes work rules during your employment.

Suppose you work for a meat packing company in the accounting department, and an edict comes down that everyone must work a week in the abattoir and on the killing floor every two years, starting with you, so that employees can all be aware of all aspects of the business. This is too much for you to endure and you refuse and are fired.

Since it was due to an implicit change of the employment contract, by the employer, I think you should be able to collect unemployment while you look for a new job. This is what the insurance is for.

That all said, I think requiring vaccination for in-person work is an excellent policy, but it needs to be spelled out, and because it is a change during employment, people need to given time to adjust, even the anti-vaxxers. This is not "coddling" because they would soon be out anyway.

Might be simplest to give all anti-vaxxers layoff notices so they can collect unemployment, and be less of a drag on the economy that way.



Beastly Boy

(9,307 posts)
8. Changes in your job description give you grounds for refusing to comply, but not quitting the job.
Thu Aug 5, 2021, 07:18 AM
Aug 2021

The former shifts the decision making on the employer: whether to retain you under the original terms of employment or fire you. If you are fired, you are eligible for unemployment, but if you quit, you get none.

Having said that, I believe that accepting a job implies that you agree to follow the employer's health and safety protocols and workplace conduct rules, especially when they are mandated by government authorities. I am not sure how it works out in real life, but I don't think you are eligible for unemployment if you are fired for failing to comply with these.

markie

(22,756 posts)
10. 15 nurses at the VA in Vermont
Thu Aug 5, 2021, 08:11 AM
Aug 2021

left because of the mandate... no words to describe the disgust I have for these selfish, disrespectful people

my daughter works in HR there and it is causing an upheaval

Igel

(35,300 posts)
13. Eligibility has been an issue in the last year.
Thu Aug 5, 2021, 11:19 AM
Aug 2021

A lot of states just waived all sorts of requirements.

In Texas you're supposed to have on-going proof of seeking work, employers are to let the unemployment agency know if they contact an unemployed worker who turns down a job offer.

For the last year, nobody's enforced those rules. Don't look for work? Meh. Ignore job offers? Whatever (hair-flip, eye-roll).

I'd doubt they bothered to contact employers to confirm the claim that an employee was laid off and didn't just walk away.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Quitting a Job Due to Vac...