Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Grasswire2

(13,568 posts)
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 08:47 PM Oct 2021

I interviewed Colin Powell in his Pentagon office when he was CJCS.

Just Powell, his press person, my photographer and myself.

I spent almost two hours with him. I was working as a writer and editor for a criminal justice reform non-profit, and seeking a message from him to deliver directly to PoC in America's prisons. Perhaps a word of encouragement or motivation. Even though his experience was not the same as that of ppl who came up in racial strife or impoverished circumstances (as is the experience of overwhelming numbers of prisoners), he still was a highly accomplished Black man who might be a role model for some.

He spoke from his heart, humbly, and with understanding and empathy. There was no artifice in him.

Whatever else he was, he was that, then.

28 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I interviewed Colin Powell in his Pentagon office when he was CJCS. (Original Post) Grasswire2 Oct 2021 OP
It's not who he was zipplewrath Oct 2021 #1
Everybody's got a moment UTUSN Oct 2021 #2
Each and every person involved with the death stillcool Oct 2021 #3
I don't understand how someone, who has no concept of greed, would allow himself to Baitball Blogger Oct 2021 #4
I don't know. Grasswire2 Oct 2021 #6
I respect/like you & seldom say "sorry", but sorry: We know enough. UTUSN Oct 2021 #9
Thanks for that perspective mountain grammy Oct 2021 #5
Not by all accounts unc70 Oct 2021 #7
Exactly! burrowowl Oct 2021 #14
Colin Powell's Vietnam Fog (May 2, 2001) Celerity Oct 2021 #8
Ignore the trolls. All people who have never had to lead, or make hard choices. Pisces Oct 2021 #11
we are NOT trolls Skittles Oct 2021 #12
"Troll" is a term that can mean many things to many people. ShazzieB Oct 2021 #20
I know the context Skittles Oct 2021 #22
Not trolls! burrowowl Oct 2021 #28
whenever it came time to do the right thing Skittles Oct 2021 #10
But if we're using that zero tolerance standard, then Biden, Clinton and all the rest ecstatic Oct 2021 #19
I have not forgiven anyone who voted for that POS war Skittles Oct 2021 #21
I heard him speak about 25 years ago... dixiechiken1 Oct 2021 #13
Shame there were not a lot of women watching him during his presentation at the UN Escurumbele Oct 2021 #17
It doesn't undo all the death, destruction and chaos he wrought berni_mccoy Oct 2021 #15
Thank you for your perspective Hekate Oct 2021 #16
Thank you Raine Oct 2021 #18
I realized that I still have the cassette tape recording of the interview. Grasswire2 Oct 2021 #23
You definitely should... dixiechiken1 Oct 2021 #27
Did he giggle about torture camps? traitorsgalore Oct 2021 #24
welcome to DU nt Grasswire2 Oct 2021 #25
I liked Colin Powell. I have always felt he was an honorable leftyladyfrommo Oct 2021 #26

zipplewrath

(16,646 posts)
1. It's not who he was
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 08:49 PM
Oct 2021

It's what he did.

That's the problem. A person is "judged" on what they do, not what they believe, or aspire to be.

Read his autobiography and look at the chances he had to "do the right thing" and he backed down.

stillcool

(32,626 posts)
3. Each and every person involved with the death
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 09:02 PM
Oct 2021

of over a million people had their reasons for doing their part. It is difficult to understand, because the mind-set at the time, what factored in to the decision, none of that is known. When the pinnacle of a career is defined by a such a life-destroying atrocity, it's hard to see past that.

Baitball Blogger

(46,702 posts)
4. I don't understand how someone, who has no concept of greed, would allow himself to
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 09:04 PM
Oct 2021

Last edited Mon Oct 18, 2021, 10:19 PM - Edit history (1)

be used like that. Was it a sense of duty? Then, Powell gave "duty" a dirty name.

Grasswire2

(13,568 posts)
6. I don't know.
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 09:21 PM
Oct 2021

I don't think we will ever know.

He could have been president, easily. It was always said that his wife, Alma, did not want him to run. As president, would he have been owned in the same way, by someone?

I guess it would take a shrink to figure it out.

mountain grammy

(26,619 posts)
5. Thanks for that perspective
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 09:21 PM
Oct 2021

He was a soldier who by all accounts served honorably. That’s not insignificant.

unc70

(6,112 posts)
7. Not by all accounts
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 09:53 PM
Oct 2021

No where near.

His complicity in the My Lai coverup and later tarnished him and his reputation. His later behavior did not change that assessment.

Celerity

(43,333 posts)
8. Colin Powell's Vietnam Fog (May 2, 2001)
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 10:00 PM
Oct 2021
The war was years ago, but that does not excuse misrepresenting one's participation in it.

https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/colin-powells-vietnam-fog/

Bob Kerrey is lost in the haze of Vietnam. As he has contended with the public revelation that the Navy SEAL team he led killed a dozen or so civilians during a nighttime mission in 1969 (accidentally, he and five colleagues maintain; not-so-accidentally, says one team member), his recollections have shifted. “Please understand,” he told journalist Gregory Vistica, who uncovered this story, “that my memory of this event is clouded by the fog of the evening, age and desire.” His is not an uncommon fog, as attested to by other vets. The hell of Vietnam—an unpopular war that involved hard-to-discern guerrilla combatants, brutal depopulation strategies, indiscriminate bombing and much “collateral damage,” as military bureaucrats called civilian kills—offers its distinct challenges to memory, the individual memories of many who served there and the collective memory of the nation that sent them and sponsored a dirty war of free-fire zones and destroy-the-village-to-save-the-village tactics. In reviewing Colin Powell’s military service recently, I found that Powell had his own trouble in setting the record straight on his involvement—tangential as it was—in one of the war’s more traumatic episodes.

As Powell notes in his 1995 autobiography, My American Journal, in 1969 he was an Army major, the deputy operations officer of the Americal Division, stationed at division headquarters in Chu Lai. He says that in March of that year, an investigator from the inspector general’s office of Military Assistance Command Vietnam (MACV) paid a call. In a “Joe Friday monotone,” the investigator shot questions at Powell about Powell’s position at the division and the division’s operational journals, of which Powell was the custodian. The inspector then asked Powell to produce the journals for March 1968. Powell started to explain that he had not been with the division at that time. “Just get the journal,” the IG man snapped, “and go through that month’s entries. Let me know if you find an unusual number of enemy killed on any day.” Powell flipped through the records and came upon an entry from March 16, 1968. The journal noted that a unit of the division had reported a body count of 128 enemy dead on the Batangan Peninsula. “In this grinding, grim, but usually unspectacular warfare,” Powell writes, “that was a high number.” The investigator requested that Powell read the number into the tape recorder he had brought, and that was essentially the end of the interview. “He left,” Powell recalls, “leaving me as mystified as to his purpose as when he arrived.”

It would not be until two years later (according to the original version of Powell’s book) or six months later (according to the paperback version of the book) that Powell figured out that the IG official had been probing what was then a secret, the My Lai massacre. Not until the fall of 1969 did the world learned that on March 16, 1968, troops from the Americal Division, under the command of Lieut. William Calley, killed scores of men, women and children in that hamlet. “Subsequent investigation revealed that Calley and his men killed 347 people,” Powell writes. “The 128 enemy ‘kills’ I had found in the journal formed part of the total.” Though he does not say so expressly, Powell leaves the impression that the IG investigation, using information provided by Powell, uncovered the massacre, for which Calley was later court-martialed. That is not accurate.

The transcript of the tape-recorded interview between the IG man—Lieut. Col. William Sheehan—and Powell tells a different story. During that session—which actually happened on May 23, 1969—the IG investigator did request that Powell take out the division’s operations journals covering the first three weeks of March. (The IG inquiry had been triggered by letters written to the Pentagon, the White House and twenty-four members of Congress by Ron Ridenhour, a former serviceman who had learned about the mass murders.) Sheehan examined the records. Then he asked Powell to say for the record what activity had transpired in “grid square BS 7178” in this period. “The most significant of these occurred on 16, March, 1968,” Powell replied, “beginning at 0740 when C Company, 1st of the 20th, then under Task Force Barker, and the 11th Infantry Brigade, conducted a combat assault into a hot LZ [landing zone].” He noted that C Company, after arriving in the landing zone, killed one Vietcong. About fifteen minutes later, the same company, backed up by helicopter gunships, killed three VC. In the following hour, the gunships killed three more VC, while C Company “located documents and equipment” and killed fourteen Vietcong. “There is no indication of the nature of the action which caused these fourteen VC KIA,” Powell said. Later that morning, C Company, according to the journal, captured a shortwave radio and detained twenty-three VC suspects for questioning, while two other companies that were also part of Task Force Barker were active in the same area without registering any enemy kills.

snip

burrowowl

(17,639 posts)
28. Not trolls!
Tue Oct 19, 2021, 05:52 PM
Oct 2021

Just saying it like it was! My Lai he tried to cover up and the lies on Iraq were egregious!

Skittles

(153,150 posts)
10. whenever it came time to do the right thing
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 10:27 PM
Oct 2021

he faltered, folded like a deck chair - it would seem his career was more important. Accomplished - meh.

ecstatic

(32,688 posts)
19. But if we're using that zero tolerance standard, then Biden, Clinton and all the rest
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 11:57 PM
Oct 2021

are guilty as well, are they not? They voted to allow the war to happen. I was extremely angry about it for a long time, but we've all had to forgive a lot of people since then.

dixiechiken1

(2,113 posts)
13. I heard him speak about 25 years ago...
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 10:36 PM
Oct 2021

At a motivational seminar in Denver. It was an all day thing and there were a number of speakers - Picabo Street, Ed Asner and Colin Powell among them.

Colin Powell was the 2nd to the last speaker of the day. He spoke quite a bit about how he grew up and how he could never get away with anything because all the women in the neighborhood sat in their windows and watched everything that went on. And they would always tell each other what their kids were doing. He said all the ladies in the neighborhood were like his aunts - and he had a thousand aunts. lol

He was a great speaker, very impactful, and you could have heard a pin drop in the arena the entire time he spoke. We all felt sorry for the last speaker who had to follow him because once Colin Powell was done, everyone started clearing out.

Escurumbele

(3,389 posts)
17. Shame there were not a lot of women watching him during his presentation at the UN
Mon Oct 18, 2021, 11:36 PM
Oct 2021

He may have told the truth then.

Grasswire2

(13,568 posts)
23. I realized that I still have the cassette tape recording of the interview.
Tue Oct 19, 2021, 12:43 AM
Oct 2021

I might have to play it for my edification.

dixiechiken1

(2,113 posts)
27. You definitely should...
Tue Oct 19, 2021, 10:03 AM
Oct 2021

It would be interesting to see if your memory comports with what you hear now.

I often think of the time I heard him speak and remember it fondly. While my experience wasn't one-on-one, as yours was, I came away with much the same impression you did:

"He spoke from his heart, humbly, and with understanding and empathy. There was no artifice in him."

Thanks for sharing your experience and your perspective.

leftyladyfrommo

(18,868 posts)
26. I liked Colin Powell. I have always felt he was an honorable
Tue Oct 19, 2021, 07:31 AM
Oct 2021

man that got sucked into the Iraq war mania.

Cheney. Wolfowitz, Rumsfeldt were going to war no matter what. And there was a lot of popular support for that war at that time.

It was all how awful Hussain was. How awful the rape rooms were. And on and on.

Powell didn't cause the Iraq war. War mania caused that war. Super male egos caused that war.

It was awful. It was wrong. But you can't blame just one person. He was the scapegoat but a whole lot of Americans backed that war.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I interviewed Colin Powel...