Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

woolldog

(8,791 posts)
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 03:12 AM Jan 2012

A case of mass hysteria in New York

Anyone read about this? The human mind is so incredible.

The day after TODAY reported on the baffling case of 12 teenage girls at one school who mysteriously fell ill with Tourette's-like symptoms of tics and verbal outbursts, a doctor who is treating some of the girls has come forward to offer an explanation. Dr. Laszlo Mechtler, a neurologist in Amherst, N.Y., says the diagnosis is "conversion disorder," or mass hysteria.

"It's happened before, all around the world, in different parts of the world. It's a rare phenomena. Physicians are intrigued by it," Mechtler told TODAY on Wednesday.

"The bottom line is “I was fine. I was perfectly fine. There was nothing going on, and then I just woke up, and that’s when the stuttering started,” Sanchez told TODAY.

“I’m very angry,’’ Sanchez told TODAY’s Ann Curry during an interview Tuesday. “I’m very frustrated. No one’s giving me answers.’’

these teenagers will get better."


http://todayhealth.today.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/01/18/10181277-teen-girls-mystery-illness-now-has-a-diagnosis-mass-hysteria

26 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
A case of mass hysteria in New York (Original Post) woolldog Jan 2012 OP
please move to the DU lounge nt woolldog Jan 2012 #1
Hosts can't move topics like Mods could wooolldog tkmorris Jan 2012 #2
Ah ok woolldog Jan 2012 #10
I don't think this is a Lounge topic obamanut2012 Jan 2012 #16
My comment to Dr. Mechtler: Suich Jan 2012 #3
They are not faking but are getting the symptoms after seeing it. grantcart Jan 2012 #4
But vomiting... Control-Z Jan 2012 #5
This case was particularly well documented but there are other outbreaks with grantcart Jan 2012 #13
Click on the ... button Generic Brad Jan 2012 #26
I saw an interview with 2 girls who are experiencing the same thing. Suich Jan 2012 #7
So the girl is an athlete and was in the town... Javaman Jan 2012 #14
There has been speculation that the Salem witch accusations PotatoChip Jan 2012 #11
read up on Ergot. Javaman Jan 2012 #17
Puking is one thing, fits are another. lonestarnot Jan 2012 #25
Something similar used to happen to people, including myself when I was younger. A Simple Game Jan 2012 #20
Mass hysteria? RZM Jan 2012 #6
EMFs?....sort of sounds mysterious, like the bees Alameda Jan 2012 #8
Makes me scared something like that could happen to me woolldog Jan 2012 #9
Possible link between pharm companies and Dr. Mechtler? FedUpWithIt All Jan 2012 #12
When they start pointing out people as witches to be put on trial, then I'll be worried. Skidmore Jan 2012 #15
Same thing happened with the Salem Witch Trials obamanut2012 Jan 2012 #18
I read somewhere 12 of them are cheerleaders.... Dr. Drew... IcyPeas Jan 2012 #19
People need to understand the difference between "faking" and psychosomatic illnesses. TheWraith Jan 2012 #22
I just saw on TV that Erin Brokovich is going Suich Jan 2012 #21
The story was just on Dr. Drew Show graywarrior Jan 2012 #23
PANDA perhaps... Agony Jan 2012 #24

tkmorris

(11,138 posts)
2. Hosts can't move topics like Mods could wooolldog
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 03:28 AM
Jan 2012

Best we can do is lock it, you'll have to repost it in the Lounge yourself.

obamanut2012

(26,049 posts)
16. I don't think this is a Lounge topic
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 12:45 PM
Jan 2012

This is a very interesting medical topic, which has an historically link (ie Salem Witch Trials).

Suich

(10,642 posts)
3. My comment to Dr. Mechtler:
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 03:36 AM
Jan 2012

Horse feathers!

Why would an Honor's Student, star athlete fake it???????

edited to ask: Why move this to the Lounge? It's ok here, imho.

grantcart

(53,061 posts)
4. They are not faking but are getting the symptoms after seeing it.
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 03:47 AM
Jan 2012


There have been many many well documented cases of similar types of 'outbreaks'.

For example there was a case where students in one wing of a school were in a room where one student started vomitting and soon many in the same room started vomitting. In an attached wing students could see the students vomit and started vomitting and so on and dozens were sent to the hospital and an investigation for toxic elements were searched. However it was later determined that their was no shared air space between the students and the only common environmental factors they shared were line of sight.

Other class rooms that shared ventilation but did not share line of sight did not experience the vomiting contagion.

Control-Z

(15,682 posts)
5. But vomiting...
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 03:57 AM
Jan 2012

witnessing it, smelling it, just hearing it...can easily trigger more cases.

Not to argue your point. I'm sure it happens with other illnesses. Puking is just too easy, if you know what I mean. Now where it that puke emoticon?

grantcart

(53,061 posts)
13. This case was particularly well documented but there are other outbreaks with
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 10:39 AM
Jan 2012

other symptoms.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_Psychogenic_Illness#Late_20th_Century_and_21st_Century

On the morning of Thursday 7 October 1965, at a girls' school in Blackburn, several girls complained of dizziness.[15] Some fainted. Within a couple of hours, 85 girls from the school were rushed by ambulance to a nearby hospital after fainting. Symptoms included swooning, moaning,chattering of teeth, hyperpnea, and tetany. Moss and McEvedy, published their analysis of the event about one year later. Their conclusions follow.[15] Note that not their conclusion about the above-average extroversion and neuroticism of those affected is not necessarily typical of MPI.[2]:
Clinical and laboratory findings were essentially negative.
Investigations by the public health authorities did not uncover any evidence of pollution of food or air.
The epidemiology of the outbreak was investigated by means of questionnaires administered to the whole school population. It was established that the outbreaks began among the 14-year-olds, but that the heaviest incidence moved to the youngest age groups.
By using the Eysenck Personality Inventory it was established that in all age groups the mean E [extroversion] and N [neuroticism] scores of the affected were higher than those of the unaffected.
The younger girls proved more susceptible, but disturbance was more severe and lasted longer in the older girls.
It was considered that the epidemic was hysterical, that a previous polio epidemic had rendered the population emotionally vulnerable, and that a three-hour parade, producing 20 faints on the day before the first outbreak, had been the specific trigger.
The data collected were thought to be incompatible with organic theories and with the compromise theory of an organic nucleus.

Suich

(10,642 posts)
7. I saw an interview with 2 girls who are experiencing the same thing.
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 04:05 AM
Jan 2012

They live in a town that is either 150 or 250 miles away. The only commonality is that one of the girls, the one who is an athlete, was in the town where this started last Saturday for a meet, (I can't remember what she plays...I think it's soccer.) and had lunch there.

I think this doctor is dismissing it because they are female.

When Princess Diana died, the reaction of the people was played off as "mass hysteria" when, in fact, it may have been genuine grief.

I've seen a couple of these girls with the Tourette's syndrome and one of them asked, "Why would I do this to myself?" She was exhausted and her whole body ached.

I think there's more to it than Dr. Mechtler suggests, but that's just me. I hope they keep looking.

Peace

Javaman

(62,507 posts)
14. So the girl is an athlete and was in the town...
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 12:42 PM
Jan 2012

I wonder what kind of sport she participates in?

If it's outdoors and on a field and if the girls effected at the school are also athletes.

Since I'm just spitballing here, maybe it has something to due with the pesticides used on the field?

something is not right here and someones not giving all the information.

PotatoChip

(3,186 posts)
11. There has been speculation that the Salem witch accusations
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 04:48 AM
Jan 2012

were predicated on a similiar event. The whole witch hysteria thing came about shortly after several Salem teenage girls suddenly came down w/baffeling symptoms that sound very much like those mentioned in the OP.

Town religious leaders, believing the girls were victims of some type of demonic forces, began intense inquisitions of them, which ultimately resulted in the girls pointing fingers at various residents-- mostly older/widowed women but a few men too. The accusations quickly got out of hand as these types of things tend to do.

A PBS program (might have been NOVA- don't remember exactly) attempted to uncover the reasons why the girls became 'ill' in the first place. Could it have been caused by toxins in some blighted barley crops harvested that year, or perhaps something just like the OP's 'Conversion Disorder?' If I remember correctly, the program left that as an open question, but seemed to lean toward the latter.

Javaman

(62,507 posts)
17. read up on Ergot.
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 12:46 PM
Jan 2012

the outbreak of the crazies in Salemn has been theorized as being a result of ergot poisoning.

fasinating stuff.

http://www.hbci.com/~wenonah/history/ergot.htm

"My goal was to demonstrate that women could be as wicked as men. As I began researching, I remember having one of those kind of 'ah-hah!' experiences, where I was reading a book in which the author said he was at a loss to explain the hallucinations of all these people in Salem. It was that word 'hallucinations' that made everything click. Years and years ago, when I was a little kid, I had read about the French case of ergot poisoning, and I made the connection between the two."

and...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergotism

Salem witchcraft accusationsThe convulsive symptoms that can be a result of consuming ergot-tainted rye have also been said to be the cause of accusations of bewitchment that spurred the Salem witch trials. This medical explanation for the theory of “bewitchment” is one first propounded by Linnda R. Caporael in 1976 in an article in Science. In her article, Caporael argues that the convulsive symptoms, such as crawling sensations in the skin, tingling in the fingers, vertigo, tinnitus aurium, headaches, disturbances in sensation, hallucination, painful muscular contractions, vomiting and diarrhea, as well as psychological symptoms, such as mania, melancholia, psychosis and delirium, were all symptoms reported in the Salem witchcraft records. Caporael also states there was an abundance of rye in the region as well as climate conditions that could support the tainting of rye.[6] In 1982 historian Mary Matossian raised Caporael’s theory in an article in American Scientist in which she argued that symptoms of “bewitchment” resemble the ones exhibited in those afflicted with ergot poisoning.[7]

The hypothesis that ergotism could explain cases of bewitchment has been subject to debate and has been criticized by several scholars. Within a year of Caporael’s article, the historians Spanos and Gottlieb argued against the idea in the same journal. In Spanos and Gottlieb’s rebuttal to Caporael’s article, they concluded that there are several flaws in the explanation of ergot poisoning as a cause of conditions associated with cases of alleged bewitchment. For example, they argued that if the food supply was contaminated, the symptoms would have occurred on a house-by-house basis, not just in particular individuals. Historian Leon Harrier has challenged this theory by claiming that even if supplies were properly cooked, residents suffering from stomach ulcer's had a risk of absorbing the toxin through the stomach lining, offering a direct route to the blood stream. Being similar to Lysergic acid diethylamide, the chemical composition of the average humans stomach would be too acidic for the ergot to survive, especially if the food was properly cooked, but if some residents were malnourished and suffering from bleeding stomach ulcers, there is valid reasoning to say that while most of the residents would not be affected by ingesting contaminated grains, a small percentage could have become infected, offering an explanation for why ergotism was never initially recognized. Harrier has even argued that the numbers could have been exponentially larger, possibly even the entire town, but due to the trials on bewitchment and heresy, and the fear of being accused and subsequently executed, few could come forward while suffering from legitimate medical conditions. Spanos and Gottlieb also state that ergot poisoning has additional symptoms not associated with the events in Salem and that the proportion of children afflicted were less than in a typical ergotism epidemic.[8] The anthropologist H. Sidky noted that ergotism had existed for centuries before the Salem witch trials, and argued that its symptoms would have been recognizable during the time of the Salem witch trials.

A Simple Game

(9,214 posts)
20. Something similar used to happen to people, including myself when I was younger.
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 10:06 PM
Jan 2012

First one or two people would start acting weird and then people around them would "catch it".

We used to call it a contact high. Didn't seem to last long.

Alameda

(1,895 posts)
8. EMFs?....sort of sounds mysterious, like the bees
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 04:12 AM
Jan 2012

whatever it is, it's a problem and needs to be seriously addressed.

 

woolldog

(8,791 posts)
9. Makes me scared something like that could happen to me
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 04:15 AM
Jan 2012

lol, they're not faking. There's nothing they can do to stop it. But there's no real cause either.

FedUpWithIt All

(4,442 posts)
12. Possible link between pharm companies and Dr. Mechtler?
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 06:30 AM
Jan 2012
http://thebatavian.com/howard-owens/doctor-who-reportedly-diagnosed-conversion-disorder-received-substantial-payments-pharm

Suspicions that there may be an HPV link at least in the initial cases.

Edited to add that even the Dr. only asserted that 10 of the 12 were suffering from possible conversion disorder.

obamanut2012

(26,049 posts)
18. Same thing happened with the Salem Witch Trials
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 12:47 PM
Jan 2012

Even when the girls were never left alone, they acted in unison, including being sick and hurting themselves. Some of these girls were also the "Big Girls On Campus," such as the minister's daughter and niece.

IcyPeas

(21,855 posts)
19. I read somewhere 12 of them are cheerleaders.... Dr. Drew...
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 04:33 PM
Jan 2012

has had three of the girls on his show a couple of times. One had a fit during the show -- her mother was there to aid her - apparently she has seizures frequently now - that doesn't sound like something that can be faked. It looked awful.

TheWraith

(24,331 posts)
22. People need to understand the difference between "faking" and psychosomatic illnesses.
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 10:26 PM
Jan 2012

Psychosomatic means that you REALLY BELIEVE that you have a condition or that there's something wrong with you. It may be all in your head, but you're not "faking," and it also means that you can have things happen like nervous tics, nausea, vomiting, even seizures, and many other symptoms.

Suich

(10,642 posts)
21. I just saw on TV that Erin Brokovich is going
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 10:13 PM
Jan 2012

to join the investigation...could be a good thing.

If there's a cover-up she might be able to expose it.

Agony

(2,605 posts)
24. PANDA perhaps...
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 10:59 PM
Jan 2012
http://www.13wham.com/news/local/story/leroy-teens-mystery-illness/TlmiJ8KBhUaN5Vio_5Q38g.cspx?autoplay=1

Dr. Trifiletti says the illness used to be known as PANDAS but is now called PAND, because it was determine that strep isn't always the cause of the infection.

The full name for the illness is: Pediatric Acute Autoimmune Neuropsychological Disorders. Here's a link with more information on this illness www.pandasnetwork.org.

While it isn't contagious, he says it is often linked to an unusual immune response.

http://intramural.nimh.nih.gov/pdn/web.htm
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»A case of mass hysteria i...