General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsCan anyone explain this to me?
A conservative friend posted this on Facebook and I've not heard anything about it before.
But since this is from Faux, i give it no credibility.
He says Biden 'outed' them, as if Biden listed their names etc. Surely
he must have said nothing more than 'seal team 6'?
arcane1
(38,613 posts)I admittedly didn't watch it
Shankapotomus
(4,840 posts)As for the accusations at the administration:
1.) They had 3 months to request a reassignment, transfer or honorable discharge.
2.) Not sure how the Taliban would know they were Seal Team 6 from the ground.
3.) They just found out their lives were in danger in Afghanistan? Isn't the possibility of injury or death one of the first things you are informed about when you sign up for the military? So they knew going in to the military it was dangerous and they knew 3 months ahead of time they could be a special target. At that point, that is when they should have reevaluated their priorities. If the "working" conditions had become unacceptable 3 months ago, even a dishonorable discharge, barring all other options, should have been seriously considered.
Ohio Joe
(21,748 posts)A few days after the raid that killed bin laden, Joe Biden confirmed that it was Seal Team Six that did the job. This, was what allowed al-queda to feed bad intel that there would be some high profile target in a specific place/time and that instantly they would get Seal Team Six and have their revenge.
There are a few problems with this... First, I remember that night, after watching President Obama's announcement, my brother and I had a discussion. We agreed it had to be Seal Team Six with an outside chance of Delta Squad... We have seen more then one action movie in the last 20 years or so Next, 'The Set Up'... A plot that uses a high value target as the bait in the aftermath of their leaders demise is expected to draw in a top squad... I don't think they really gave a shit which one it was, their media plays out the same.
It is more shit being thrown against the wall by the racist nut job repugs that would rather ruin this country then see it saved by a black man.
chowder66
(9,066 posts)Why is Biden to blame? Repeating a story that ran on Snopes back in January 2012, Klayman claims,
Shortly after that successful raid on bin Laden, the president - through the vice president for political purposes - released the name of SEAL Team Six. Thats classified information, and even (then) Defense Secretary Robert Gates was critical of that. So that was like putting a target on the backs of the sons of my clients.
Klayman is speaking of a speech given by Joe Biden on May 3, 2011 at the Atlantic Councils 50th anniversary, where supposedly Biden outed Seal Team 6 as the killers of Bin Laden.
Yet, if you listen to the speech, Biden does not identify the unit, saying simply SEALS. Watch for yourself, in a video provided by some folks who, like Klayman, blame Biden (though they did not apparently actually watch the video):
http://www.politicususa.com/seal-team-6-gate-replaces-benghanzi-worst-scandal.html
mercuryblues
(14,530 posts)big lie. This originated from World Nut Daily.
Here are the relevant bits from Bidens speech:
Let me briefly acknowledge tonights distinguished honorees. Admiral James Stavridis is a, is the real deal. He can tell you more about and understands the incredible, the phenomenal, the just almost unbelievable capacity of his Navy SEALs and what they did last Sunday.
and,
from http://www.politicususa.com/seal-team-6-gate-replaces-benghanzi-worst-scandal.html
Folks, Id be remiss also if I didnt say an extra word about the incredible events, extraordinary events of this past Sunday. As Vice President of the United States, as an American, I was in absolute awe of the capacity and dedication of the entire team, both the intelligence community, the CIA, the SEALs. It just was extraordinary.
That same evening, Leon Panetta also said that SEALS had killed Bin Laden.
But neither man identified the unit involved.
As Time Magazine reported on May 13, Back at Lejeune on Thursday [May 12], [Defense Secretary Robert] Gates surrendered on the operational details including the unit involved.
The media, as Time admits, was complicit in outting the SEALS, admitting, Unfortunately, the media glare here at Time, as well as around the globe has been unrelenting. Former SEALS contributed by offering interviews and writing books. That doesnt include the three members of SEAL Team 6 who have offered details of Bin Ladens death. And you wont find Klayman mentioning that FOX News outed a Navy Seal by name.
But you wont know any of this if you rely on Larry Klayman.
Kali
(55,007 posts)no wonder people who watch teevee, and especially that kind of shit seem so brain damaged.
bhikkhu
(10,715 posts)Or the SECRETS OF SEAL TEAM 6 television movie, 2011?
Or maybe they read the book, INSIDE SEAL TEAM 6, 2011?
...one of the worst kept secrets in the military, it would seem.
GoneFishin
(5,217 posts)To me the hype and fervor around this story smelled like the Jessica Lynch story. Now people close to the story are dying as often happens with stories that smell fishy. I smelled something stinky when they said they buried him at sea, and they simultaneously refused to release any photos. Whatever else they think they accomplished, they also, coincidentally, made it impossible for any independent verification that they got the right guy.
DebJ
(7,699 posts)We'll see what he says.