General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsHow A Crackpot Theory of Education Reform Became National Policy
Future historians are likely to tell the following story: some time during the early twenty-first century, a cross-section of the American elite began to panic. They looked at the growing chasm between the rich and poor, the huge size of the nations prison population, and the growing racial and socieconomic gulf in education, and decided something dramatic had to be done to remedy these problems.
But instead of critically examining how these trends reflected twenty years of regressive taxation, a futile war on drugs, the deregulation of the financial industry, the breaking of unions and the movement of American companies abroad, Americas leaders decided the primary source of economic inequality could be found in failing schools, bad teachers, and powerful teachers unions.
No serious scholar, looking at the economic and social trends of the previous twenty years or the major innovations in social policy that have unleashed the power of big capital, gives the slightest credence to this analysis of the sources of inequality, but the idea that educational failure is the prime source of all other social deficits has taken hold with the force of a religious conversion. Corporate leaders, heads of major foundations, civil rights leaders, and politicians in both major parties have bought this explanation hook line and sinker, and so thus we have one of the strangest social movements in modern American historythe demonization of Americas teachers and the development of strategies to radically transform education by taking power away from them.
The consequence of this leap of faith is the idea that there has to be a centralized effort to monitor educational progress though quantifiable measures, coupled with accountability strategies that call for the removal of teachers and the closing of schools if they dont meet their criteria. Through policies developed at the federal level, but implemented locally so that they affect every school district in the nation, scrutinizing teacher effectiveness has become a national mission with as much fanfare as was Americas efforts to put a rocket in space during the 1950s and 60s.
more . . . http://hnn.us/articles/how-crackpot-theory-education-reform-became-national-policy
Fumesucker
(45,851 posts)On the 99%.
Tebow forbid that anything the elite might do be thought to have a negative impact on society.
Starry Messenger
(32,342 posts)LOL.
It's so good, and he nails it with the "crackpot theory" description. I liked this part too:
"This all sounds very rational until you look at it from the perspective of individual schools. To evaluate teachers through standardized test results, and do it across the board, you have to have tests in every grade and every subject. This not only means tests in English, math, science and social studies, it means tests in art, music and gym (or the elimination of those programs entirely, as some schools have done).
No public school has ever willingly tried doing something like this, and for good reason. It means that all that goes on in school is preparation for tests. There is no spontaneity, no creativity, no possibility of responding to new opportunities for learning from current events, either globally, nationally, or locally. It also means play and pleasure are erased from the school experience, since students will be under constant pressure from their teachers, who know that their own jobs depend on student performance."
proud2BlibKansan
(96,793 posts)He's great. Do you know anything about him?
Starry Messenger
(32,342 posts)He really nailed it! I can't even remember where I saw the link posted this morning, I mailed it to myself from my tablet. Not enough coffee this morning! Maybe it was off Twitter?
proud2BlibKansan
(96,793 posts)I believe that's where I found it. But I think I saw some Tweets too?
You and I meet in too many places on the intertubes. LOL
Starry Messenger
(32,342 posts)I'll keep looking! Hehehe.
proud2BlibKansan
(96,793 posts)LOL
Starry Messenger
(32,342 posts)mmonk
(52,589 posts)Response to proud2BlibKansan (Original post)
Tesha This message was self-deleted by its author.
Nay
(12,051 posts)teachers and snotty principals, but the orchestrators of this attack haven't put any "faith" in this idea -- frankly, they couldn't care what kind of education the rubes' kids get. The plan is to build another for-profit monster (like the prison system, military-industrial complex, etc.) that will perform walletectomies on every parent in the nation to enrich themselves and their companies and ensure that the rubes' brats can't compete with their rich children.
Period.
LARED
(11,735 posts)Sadly the strategy by officals to improve education has gone horribly worng.
Tansy_Gold
(17,855 posts)is that the elites didn't panic at all. They saw the evidence -- which their own policies had in fact created -- as the means to widen the gap, shove the middle class down with the poor, dismantle public education entirely, and return the United States of America to a feudal society where a very very rich few (yeah, themselves) would own and control everything.
There was no panic. There was glee.
TG
xchrom
(108,903 posts)ananda
(28,858 posts)All according to the trend of corporatizing and privatizing
EVERYTHING.... even including food and water.
madrchsod
(58,162 posts)proud2BlibKansan
(96,793 posts)eomer
(3,845 posts)I think they're getting exactly the results they want. The goal is to grade public schools as failing so that they can replace them with privatization. It's just a corollary of Naomi Klein's Shock Doctrine.
knitter4democracy
(14,350 posts)It's all about power and control anymore. I was lucky enough to get a great job in a great school that will mostly likely get closed down in two years because of NCLB, and you would not believe the micro-managing we get from the state (whose forces have come en mass to "fix" us). We have to have a particular set of four posters in the room. We didn't have 100% compliance on that, and the state people freaked out, which made our principal freak out, and that meant we all got another set of the four posters which have educationese on them to the point where the kids will ignore them as unreadable. Yeah. It's seriously insane.