Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

blm

(113,040 posts)
Thu Aug 1, 2013, 09:13 PM Aug 2013

Must read: 25yo teacher's open letter to the state of NC

Kelly Andrew Thomas
In reference to the NC Budget:

To Anyone Who Will Listen:

I've been very hesitant and have tried, with great effort, to guard and hone my temperament concerning the dire and malicious attacks towards North Carolina educators.

I am a 25 year old English teacher. I am entering my second year of teaching. I have received my undergraduate degree in English Literature and immediately pursued my Masters in Education to better myself with the instruction of secondary English. I am “highly qualified” and I will say with reasonable confidence that I am a damn good educator...or in the least, have the makings of one.

What I have witnessed in the past few weeks--breaks my heart.

Allow me your time to explain this in detail. I will be open and candid about my situation in order to allow (what I feel is required) empathy to be used.

I love what I do. Teaching was not an immediate calling for me. It kind of snuck up on me by surprise, but I am glad it did. When within those four walls of my classroom, I feel like I am doing good work. I know that I am doing good work.

I know that what I do is important.
However, I know that this is not the majority view of the population.

And I don’t quite know why this is the case. Parents trust us, educators, counselors, nurses, administration... with safeguarding and protecting their children for the majority of the year. More often than not, we see their kids more than they do.
And while we have their most beloved possessions within our possession, we strive to enrich them with the tools and knowledge that we best feel will prepare and equip them for the rest of their lives.

We bring to the table, a plethora of skills, of ideas, and for most of us, a heart that is so big, that we willingly accept everything that is thrown our way.

This is important to note.

Good teachers come to a school, every morning, with a heart that truly beats for 100 kids. For some, it’s more. However, it’s not always good that we take in. We take in the struggles of low-income households, the persecution of race, the distastes of temperament, the hesitance of confidence and self-worth, the absence of hope.

Sure, we also receive kindness and enrichment and a fortitude to better one’s self. But our hearts are vast and we actively seek to fill the voids of others by swapping their trials with our compassion.

Why my heart is breaking:

I am young.
I am broke.
I am not respected by my elected leaders.
I feel alone.
I feel my own hope dwindling each day.

I have read on multiple postings and PSAs and statistics that the average teacher salary in this country is around $49,000.

With a master’s degree, and being single (on my tax forms), I take home an annual net income of about $21,000.

Each check (12 month), I have over a third of my check taken out for taxes. Last year, I received a federal refund check of $1,500. My state refund check was $264.00

My rent will amount to $12,500 this coming year.

I am in this profession because I believe it is my duty to be an educator. I honestly feel that it is my God-given ability to teach. And teach well. And I do the best I can.

In North Carolina, a first year teacher makes about $2.15 more than a person on Welfare. (This is based on the average number of hours/week - 60. I worked an average of 77 hours/week last year).

With the cut of pay increases for NC teachers and a requirement eligibility for a $500 substitute “bonus” that will be distributed 5 years from now, it makes things look and feel very despairing. Yes, we must “rank” within the top 25% of effective teachers, but no criteria has been outlined or perhaps, been created yet. This compensation is provided either every 2 or 4 years, I can’t really remember the specifics--it was buried in the bill.

I have sought to pursue a doctorate in education, but it honestly seems meaningless now. Not that I would be deprived of a great education, but rather, it would not be asked of me.

Quality teachers are not wanted in North Carolina.

We are required to teach to a test that is an abomination in regards to assessment. Data is the new dictation of progress. Administrators are required to visit classrooms even less...because numbers can replace observation and judgement.

I chose to become a teacher because I feel that I have the unique ability to recognize and encourage the potential of my students. I taught in a very rural school during my student-teaching and my first year--and many of my kids had never believed they had the “umph” to make something significant happen in their lives. No one took the time to tell them that they were special.

I get to do this. As a job.
And that’s why Teachers have the best job in this country.

But unlike the Middle East and East Asia, where teachers are treated like royalty (because parents trust them with the educational and emotional upbringing of their kids), we get a bad rep in the United States.

And maybe I’m still too young, but I do not understand why this is so. If you are a teacher in Saudi Arabia, go out to dinner, your meal is covered by the restaurant. It's appreciation.

I don’t feel appreciated, minus my students and their parents.
I don’t feel appreciated by this country, but especially, by this state I was raised in for 21 years of my life.

I’m scared.
I’m scared because I one day want to get married. But that may have to wait longer than we want.
My biggest goal in my life is to be the best father I can be. But this also may have to wait.

And money has never been a forefront concern to me because I have replaced my need for it with the appreciation of friends, family, and what I do.

However, NC, how can I afford to be a supportive husband and father? How can I live a life that is beneficial to my children? I fear, I truly fear what is happening to my profession in this state and the longevity of consequences that will befall on young teachers like myself.

I fear for my future family and whether or not I will live above the line of poverty. They’ll have love. Absolutely. They’ll have a smart head on their shoulders. They’ll be appreciative.

However, their father will still be a teacher...doing what he feels is his greatest contribution to society...and fighting the inevitable pressure of breaking down in despair. I don’t want the bitterness of politics and educational reform to threaten my passion for teaching. I don’t want it to cause me to change into a harder person.

But with the new NC Budget... it is hard to feel optimistic, it’s hard to feel appreciated.

I’ll end this letter with a quote from a conversation I had with a custodian from my school last year:

[Him: You hear that? (Our choir was warming up outside my room in the hallway for their spring concert)

Me: Yea. It sounds pretty incredible.

Him: It’s beautiful. You know...what you do...it’s important. Because the world is just waiting to see what these kids can do.]

It's all about the kids. Why hurt us even more, NC, when this is our mission statement?

https://www.facebook.com/kellyandrewthomas?fref=ts

Please share this, DU.

37 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Must read: 25yo teacher's open letter to the state of NC (Original Post) blm Aug 2013 OP
Where did this come from? LWolf Aug 2013 #1
He posted it on Facebook. It's an open letter to all, so I shared it. blm Aug 2013 #4
I'll see if I can find him LWolf Aug 2013 #5
here blm Aug 2013 #6
I didn't know you were with the BAT.... NYC_SKP Aug 2013 #10
Yes. LWolf Aug 2013 #15
Only primary and secondary education? a la izquierda Aug 2013 #20
Everybody counts. LWolf Aug 2013 #25
Super! a la izquierda Aug 2013 #28
Mahalo blm Cha Aug 2013 #2
What's his salary? michigandem58 Aug 2013 #3
Don't know - NC teachers are 48th in pay. blm Aug 2013 #8
Here's a link to the pdf. Igel Aug 2013 #12
It's real. And, yes, the changes just happened this week. blm Aug 2013 #13
kr HiPointDem Aug 2013 #7
As a person with exactly the same education and profession, I know exactly how much work comes with WinkyDink Aug 2013 #9
You would think this country would value a smart, young man's decision to teach. blm Aug 2013 #11
Kick Scuba Aug 2013 #14
good luck to him and NC deek Aug 2013 #16
Kicked and recommended. Uncle Joe Aug 2013 #17
k&r theaocp Aug 2013 #18
Yep. Nt a la izquierda Aug 2013 #21
This underscores the danger of jobs that are a "calling" and laws that prohibit unions Lee-Lee Aug 2013 #19
I spent 13 years teaching CRK7376 Aug 2013 #27
He's young and idealistic ... but he'll learn soon enough that chemenger Aug 2013 #22
k&r sheshe2 Aug 2013 #23
He's right... I don't understand why teachers are not more highly valued in America Xyzse Aug 2013 #24
Shared HillWilliam Aug 2013 #26
My wife has been teaching for 28 years gopiscrap Aug 2013 #29
Shared on FB n/t Bertha Venation Aug 2013 #30
I have a relative marions ghost Aug 2013 #31
"With a master’s degree... I take home an annual net income of about $21000" phantom power Aug 2013 #32
My wife has two masters degrees and makes less than that. progressoid Aug 2013 #37
It's not very well written. progressoid Aug 2013 #33
I second your observation Cronus Protagonist Aug 2013 #36
Scott Walker was in the vanguard of the ALEC RW et al assault on public education-k&r n/t bobthedrummer Aug 2013 #34
Sad, and just yesterday there was a local news story about Butterbean Aug 2013 #35

LWolf

(46,179 posts)
1. Where did this come from?
Thu Aug 1, 2013, 09:22 PM
Aug 2013

Is there a link?

This teacher needs to share this letter on the BAT group at FB.

LWolf

(46,179 posts)
15. Yes.
Thu Aug 1, 2013, 11:03 PM
Aug 2013

We're at almost 24,000 already! I don't post much; it's an effort to keep up with that many conversations. There are other DUers there, as well.

blm

(113,040 posts)
8. Don't know - NC teachers are 48th in pay.
Thu Aug 1, 2013, 09:36 PM
Aug 2013

Sadly, before the economy crashed and we had a Dem governor they recruited a LOT of out-of-state teachers here, too. The state has been growing really quickly this past decade. Since 2008 most have had their salaries frozen.

Igel

(35,296 posts)
12. Here's a link to the pdf.
Thu Aug 1, 2013, 09:56 PM
Aug 2013
http://www.ncpublicschools.org/docs/fbs/finance/salary/schedules/2012-13schedules.pdf

10 month salary is $30 800 this coming year.

I'm using the bachelor's degree salary for him because of this article http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323971204578630312785220612.html (no more automatic salary increase for the master's). It just happaned a few days ago and might have prompted this letter. Real or fake.

No increase for the first 4 years seems harsh. After that it's a piddling increase.

Don't know what happens to 32% of his gross, taking it from 30.8k to 21k. Retirement? Insurance? Extra federal tax?

Also don't know if NC has districts to be required to be in lockstep or if districts can pitch in additional money. Wait. Google is my friend.

http://apps.schools.nc.gov/pls/apex/f?p=1:25:413590019438101::NO:: Don't know if the search will be hotlinkable, but districts in 12/13 added anywhere from $0 to $6400 (per year, I presume) Don't know if that will continue this year, but typically (at least in TX and other states I've heard of) the increase over state-mandated base pay was usually for higher costs in cities. Houston and Dallas had high salaries; rural areas had lower.

On edit: One more thing. Those are 10-month salaries. Locally a lot of teachers tutor or teach summer school over the summer, if they're not neck-deep in professional development. I've known teacher to take time at paid professional developmen or engage in curriculum writing. Some have part-time jobs that are a struggle during the school but blossom over the summer. When I was growing up it was standard for teachers (in MD) to get a summer job, sometimes just temping.
 

WinkyDink

(51,311 posts)
9. As a person with exactly the same education and profession, I know exactly how much work comes with
Thu Aug 1, 2013, 09:44 PM
Aug 2013

his job.

A HELLACIOUS AMOUNT. I won't bore with the details.

blm

(113,040 posts)
11. You would think this country would value a smart, young man's decision to teach.
Thu Aug 1, 2013, 09:56 PM
Aug 2013

RW Talkradio and politics put an end to that.

deek

(3,414 posts)
16. good luck to him and NC
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 12:18 AM
Aug 2013

a lot of amazing teachers are lost because of this.
I hope this letter does not have negative consequences for him.

theaocp

(4,235 posts)
18. k&r
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 07:15 AM
Aug 2013

I may have missed it, but don't forget about debt from achieving those degrees. Just more shoved on top.

 

Lee-Lee

(6,324 posts)
19. This underscores the danger of jobs that are a "calling" and laws that prohibit unions
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 07:34 AM
Aug 2013

Most outside NC are not aware, but by law all government employees in NC are prohibited from having collective bargaining rights. You can have a union, but it ends up powerless.

So when you have jobs that people do as a calling- public safety and teaching primarily- people will put up with more BS than they would with any other job, and because there are always people willing to step in and do the job you have very little power to change anything.

They will always be able to recruit scores of new idealistic college grads who want to teach because all they think about is the kids. It is just like working in LE or Fire here- for every job opening there are hundreds of applicants. So why care about keeping people long term?

I do have to question one thing. I know a lot of teachers, a whole lot, and nobody comes even close to averaging 77 hours a week. Sorry, even with take home work no teachers out there work 11 hour days 7 days a week. Not unless you are also coaching, and then you get extra money that his figures don't show.

CRK7376

(2,199 posts)
27. I spent 13 years teaching
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 11:09 AM
Aug 2013

in rural NC; high school history and absolutely loved it. Unfortunately our family could not survive on the pay NC gave us with 3 kids. I coached Cross Country and Track and Field and got very little in coaching supplement for working with young athletes. At that time I had not completed a Master's degree program so we were not getting the pay increase for having an advanced degree. We could not have survived with out my Army Reserve pay. Finally, we threw in the towel and I returned to the Army and my salary more than doubled overnight. Now I have three Master's degrees that the Army paid for and will get to retire in 20 months with a retirement that is more than what I made as a teacher when I left teaching. My plan is to return to the classroom and the sooner the better. Fortunately Uncle Sam will give me a pretty good retirement check and combined with a 10 month teaching position and maybe some coaching I will be happy again and able to take care of my family. Most importantly, I will be back in a high school classroom where I belong.

chemenger

(1,593 posts)
22. He's young and idealistic ... but he'll learn soon enough that
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 07:53 AM
Aug 2013

the American capitalistsdo not want an educated proletariat. They want stupid people that will blindly listen to what our 'leaders' tell us without questioning them.

Our 'leaders' are afraid of teachers.

Xyzse

(8,217 posts)
24. He's right... I don't understand why teachers are not more highly valued in America
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 10:45 AM
Aug 2013

Other than lip service to how noble they are, they get lambasted for being greedy which doesn't make any sense to me.

gopiscrap

(23,736 posts)
29. My wife has been teaching for 28 years
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 11:26 AM
Aug 2013

and I am sure she would validate much if not all of what you are saying...so much of this is done as a union busting tactic!

marions ghost

(19,841 posts)
31. I have a relative
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 12:10 PM
Aug 2013

a young HS teacher who was considering moving to NC to teach when he finishes his masters.
I think that idea has suddenly gone out the window.

I foresee a brain drain in NC. That'll be just fine with the legislature. They don't want smart people in NC. Dumb it down. Make NC a loser of a state. You just can't understand it except that the Koch-funded pirates are just in there for the booty.

This is a historic case that will be studied for quite awhile. How to steal and destroy.

phantom power

(25,966 posts)
32. "With a master’s degree... I take home an annual net income of about $21000"
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 12:11 PM
Aug 2013

It's a miracle we have any competent teachers at all.

progressoid

(49,969 posts)
33. It's not very well written.
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 12:15 PM
Aug 2013

Last edited Fri Aug 2, 2013, 01:20 PM - Edit history (1)

While I heartedly agree with the sentiment, the structure and delivery of his letter makes me cringe a bit. Especially coming from an English instructor.

Cronus Protagonist

(15,574 posts)
36. I second your observation
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 01:17 PM
Aug 2013

I too cringed more than a few times at the shockingly poor standard of English coming from a "well qualified" teacher.

I'll cut slack here because it is a FaceBook post and we all know these are usually written while in one's underwear, drunk and tired from a long day at work; at least mine usually were.

Butterbean

(1,014 posts)
35. Sad, and just yesterday there was a local news story about
Fri Aug 2, 2013, 12:24 PM
Aug 2013

our superintendent misusing district property for personal use:

http://www.wral.com/durham-schools-superintendent-reprimanded-for-private-use-of-bus/12731029/

He makes 195k a year and $600/month in travel expenses, but he decided he had to take a district bus and a district driver (supposedly he paid the driver) to take his family to a local mall. Then he claimed he didn't know this was against the rules. There is so much WTF written all over this. Our district can afford these shenanigans, yet they can't afford to pay our teachers, and they are increasing class size, yadda yadda yadda. Why not yank some money from the bigwigs at the top of the food chain and pay the people who matter most, THE TEACHERS??

My sons' teachers are goddesses, straight up, no bones about it. They do what they do because their hearts are in it and they love their jobs. You bet your ass they are under paid and under appreciated. So you bet your ass I have gone to bat for them and put my neck on the line with the school administration more than once when they have messed with my kids' teachers. I can't up their pay, but I can damn sure be a huge bitch and fight for them when they need someone in their corner. I pray every year that my son's former k-3 teacher doesn't leave from exhaustion and a broken spirit. She is truly one of the best people I have ever had the privilege to know.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Must read: 25yo teacher's...