Bill Gates in NYT: Publicly ranking teachers by name 'is a big mistake'
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/23/opinion/for-teachers-shame-is-no-solution.html
By Bill Gates
Last week, the New York State Court of Appeals ruled that teachers individual performance assessments could be made public. I have no opinion on the ruling as a matter of law, but as a harbinger of education policy in the United States, it is a big mistake.
I am a strong proponent of measuring teachers effectiveness, and my foundation works with many schools to help make sure that such evaluations improve the overall quality of teaching. But publicly ranking teachers by name will not help them get better at their jobs or improve student learning. On the contrary, it will make it a lot harder to implement teacher evaluation systems that work.
In most public schools today, teachers are simply rated satisfactory or unsatisfactory, and evaluations consist of having the principal observe a class for a few minutes a couple of times each year. Because we are just beginning to understand what makes a teacher effective, the vast majority of teachers are rated satisfactory. Few get specific feedback or training to help them improve.
Many districts and states are trying to move toward better personnel systems for evaluation and improvement. Unfortunately, some education advocates in New York, Los Angeles and other cities are claiming that a good personnel system can be based on ranking teachers according to their value-added rating a measurement of their impact on students test scores and publicizing the names and rankings online and in the media. But shaming poorly performing teachers doesnt fix the problem because it doesnt give them specific feedback.