General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIran’s Underground Nuclear Sites Not Immune To U.S. Bunker-Busters, Experts Say
By Joby Warrick,
Western spy agencies for years have kept watch on a craggy peak in northwest Iran that houses of one the worlds most unusual nuclear sites. Known as Fordow, the facility is built into mountain bunkers designed to withstand aerial attack. Irans civil-defense chief has declared the site impregnable.
But impregnable it is not, say U.S. military planners who are increasingly confident of their ability to deliver a serious blow against Fordow, should the president ever order an attack.
U.S. officials say they have no imminent plan to bombard the site, and they have cautioned that an American attack or one by its closest Middle Eastern ally, Israel risks devastating consequences such as soaring oil prices, Iranian retaliation and dramatically heightened tension in a fragile region.
Yet as a matter of physics, Fordow remains far more vulnerable than generally portrayed, said current and former military and intelligence analysts. Massive new bunker buster munitions recently added to the U.S. arsenal would not necessarily have to penetrate the deepest bunkers to cause irreparable damage to infrastructure as well as highly sensitive nuclear equipment, likely setting back Irans program by years, officials said.
MORE...
http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/experts-irans-underground-nuclear-sites-not-immune-to-us-bunker-busters/2012/02/24/gIQAzWaghR_story.html?tid=pm_pop
zipplewrath
(16,646 posts)Hardened facilities require multiple sorties, said a former senior intelligence official who has studied the formerly secret Fordow site and agreed to discuss sensitive details of U.S. strike capabilities on the condition of anonymity. The question is, how many turns do you get at the apple?
U.S. confidence has been reinforced by training exercises in which bombers assaulted similar targets in deeply buried bunkers and mountain tunnels, the officials and experts said.
U.S. officials have raised the necessity of multiple strikes as they warn Israel against a unilateral strike against Irans nuclear installations, the officials said. While Israel is capable of launching its own bunker-buster bombs against Fordow, it lacks both the United States more advanced munitions and the capability of waging a sustained bombing campaign over days and weeks, U.S. officials and analysts said.
All they are really claiming is that they can "shake things up" a bit by repeated sorties. This is roughly what they tried in Tora Bora. The problem is of course is that Iran has a greater ability to "fight back". i.e. they could get some anti-aircraft missiles and start shooting at the incoming bombers. This is what they guy is talking about when he mentions "the bite of the apple". It's not an impossible strategy by any means, but probably one that Israel can't pursue. And to some extent, you won't know when you're "done". The part that would scare you is that someone might get desperate at some point and decide to try to put a penetrating nuke into there, after softening up the ground a bit.
Response to Purveyor (Original post)
zipplewrath This message was self-deleted by its author.