Everything Is Like Slavery, Except Slavery

[phantom power]

How’s that Republican outreach to racial minorities going these days?

North Carolina Republican Senate candidate Greg Brannon has an interesting argument for eliminating food stamps: “slavery.” In a videotaped interview with the North Carolina Tea Party in October, Brannon, a Rand Paul-endorsed doctor who is top contender for the GOP nomination to take on Democratic Sen. Kay Hagan, cited James Madison in making the case for abolishing the Department of Agriculture—and with it, the $76 billion-a-year Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, also known as food stamps. Brannon has a real chance of winning: A December poll from Public Policy Polling found the GOP primary field split but showed him leading Hagan, 45-43.

“We’re taking our plunder, that’s taken from us as individuals, [giving] it to the government, and the government is now keeping itself in power by giving these goodies away,” Brannon said in the interview. “The answer is the Department of Agriculture should go away at the federal level. And now 80 percent of the Farm Bill was food stamps. That enslaves people. What you want to do, it’s crazy but it’s true, teach people to fish instead of giving them fish. When you’re at the behest of somebody else, you are actually a slavery to them [sic]. That kind of charity does not make people freer.”

Also, Medicaid is like the Gulag, and unemployment benefits are like concentration camps. Subsidies to tobacco farmers are like the Emancipation Proclamation. Surely, we can all come together to agree on these points.

And now, to Serwer with the punchline:

I take it back. Everything is like slavery except for slavery, which wasn't that bad and definitely didn't cause the civil war.

http://www.lawyersgunsmoneyblog.com/2014/01/everything-is-like-slavery-except-slavery

[1StrongBlackMan]

1. I suspect ...

“We’re taking our plunder, that’s taken from us as individuals, it to the government, and the government is now keeping itself in power by giving these goodies away,” Brannon said in the interview.

This was an accidental truth moment ... http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/plunder Did he really mean to use that word?

[phantom power]

2. interesting, I had the same reaction

[Tierra_y_Libertad]

3. If elected, I'm sure Brannon will turn down his salary and perks to avoid becoming a slave.

"Suppose you were an idiot. And suppose you were a member of Congress.  But I repeat myself." Mark Twain

[Iggo]

4. Perfect.

[pampango]

5. "Foodstamps = slavery", "Third World slave labor", "slave wages": "Everything is like slavery except

for slavery."

[Vattel]

6. Libertairans need to learn what slavery really is.

Slavery of the sort eradicated through the civil war involved treating people as property and unjustifiably using violence or threats of violence to enforce that alleged property right. Taxation does involve coercion, but so does all government, and the question is whether and when governments have a right to coerce their citizens. In my opinion, social justice demands that children have enough food to have a decent chance at reaping the benefits of social cooperation. And for that reason I have no problem with societies through their governments requiring and, where necessary, coercing their more fortunate citizens to contribute to food stamps.

[joeglow3]

7. The WORST thing about slavery

They make you work all day but they don't pay you or let you go.