General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Ukrainian Nationalism at the Heart of ‘Euromaidan’
I guess The Nation has been infiltrated by cointelpro too?
http://www.thenation.com/article/178013/ukrainian-nationalism-heart-euromaidan
<snip>
Spearheading the clashes with police was Right Sector, a group with ties to far-right parties including the Patriots of Ukraine and Trident, which BBC Ukraine reported is largely comprised of nationalist football fans. In a statement the next day, the group claimed credit for Sundays unrest and promised to continue fighting until President Viktor Yanukovich stepped down.
Two months of unsuccessful tiptoeing about under the leadership of the opposition parties showed many demonstrators they need to follow not those who speak sweetly from the stage, but rather those who offer a real scenario for revolutionary changes in the country. For this reason, the protest masses followed the nationalists, the statement read.
The surge in violence sparked by Right Sector has revealed how uncritical and undiscerning most of the media has been of the far-right parties and movements that have played a leading role in the Euromaidan, the huge protests for closer ties to Europe that flared up in November and have taken over Kievs Independence Square (Maidan Nezalezhnosti). Protest coverage focused on the call for European integration and the struggle against the Yanukovich regime has largely glossed over the rise in nationalist rhetoric, often chauvinist, that has led to violence not just against police, but also against left-wing activists.
<snip>
On New Years Day, Svoboda led about 15,000 people in a torchlight march in honor of Stepan Bandera, the controversial leader of the wartime Ukrainian Insurgent Army, which fought the Soviets for an independent Ukrainian state but also ethnically cleansed tens of thousands of Polish civilians. (Right Sector also announced its own march that day in honor of Bandera.) Some historians have accused the Ukrainian Insurgent Army of cooperating in the massacres of thousands of Ukrainian Jews during the Nazi occupation, and Tyahnybok even commended the rebels in 2004 for fighting Russians, Germans, Jewry and other crap. The Simon Wiesenthal Center put Svoboda at number five on its 2012 list of top anti-semitic slurs, citing Tyahnyboks Moscow-Jewish mafia comment and Miroshnychenko calling Ukrainian-born actress Mila Kunis a dirty Jewess.
<snip>
The Ukrainian Insurgent Army colors are red and black, so if this emblem is spotted in the crowds, it's not Reds or Anarchists:
Again, you don't have to be a fan of contemporary Russia, or approve of the Ukrainian crackdown on civil liberties, to fear a tide of right-wing activity in the Ukraine. The article posits that Svoboda could see electoral gains coming out of this clash. Just food for thought...
Starry Messenger
(32,342 posts)<snip>
This became crystal clear during a cringe-inducing vertep, a comedic skit based on Ukrainian folk tradition, performed on the main stage at Euromaidan on New Years Eve. Based equally on the birth of Jesus and contemporary Ukrainian politics, the lead role was played by a Svoboda parliamentarian named Bogdan Benyuk, who donned black garb and sidelocks to play a stereotypical Orthodox Jewish wheeler-dealer character called Zhyd (Kike). Explaining to the crowd that he is involved in various occupations including banking, stock market speculation, loan sharking and hosting a talk show the Jewish oligarch character sings gleefully, East and West belong to me; our people are everywhere.
Zhyd creates problems for the newborn Jesus and contemplates taking a bribe from a character evoking both Yanukovych and King Herod to help him crush the protesters. Fascinatingly, the Jew switches sides and joins the opposition when he learns that on orders from the king, the regimes forces are preparing to kill Jewish firstborns. The audience is given to understand that the shift in loyalty is due not to a belated outburst of conscience, but rather because Zhyd is worried the regime may turn on his own people.
The bottom line of the supposedly all-in-good-fun skit it was followed by a solemn singing of the Ukrainian national anthem and congratulatory speeches by Yatsenyuk, Klitschko and Tyahnybok appeared to be that while perfidious Jewish oligarchs care only for the welfare of Jews, given their supposed power and influence its preferable for the opposition coalition to have them inside the tent pissing out rather than the other way around.
Even more jarring imagery came to the fore the following day when 15,000 opposition members greeted the new year by marching in a Svoboda-sponsored torchlight parade down Central Kievs Kreshatik Boulevard in commemoration of the 105th anniversary of the birth of Stepan Bandera, an ally of Nazi Germany whose followers participated in massacres of Ukrainian Jews. Marchers carried red and black nationalist banners and shouted nationalist slogans as they cheered Tyahnybok and expressed their undying love for Bandera.
<snip>
dipsydoodle
(42,239 posts)n the early days of the protests in Kiev, the most radical activists on Independence Square created the Right Sector movement, which took an active part in the clashes with police on 19 January.
This group consists mostly of young men with right-wing views.
They come from different regions of Ukraine, and there are both Ukrainian and Russian-speaking people among them.
>
The backbone of the organisation in Kiev is formed by Russian-speaking football fans sharing nationalist views.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-25826238
For those unaware the BBC is not Russian State owned media.
Starry Messenger
(32,342 posts)Good article. And...yikes?
"The Right Sector does not associate itself with the parliamentary opposition parties, including the nationalist Svoboda, which it considers to be too liberal and conformist."
Starry Messenger
(32,342 posts)BelgianMadCow
(5,379 posts)let's find out how alternative viewpoints are treated at DU.
Starry Messenger
(32,342 posts)After being here for a number of years, I've found that alternative viewpoints are either: 1) ignored, or 2) vociferously opposed, unless/until it turns out to be true, and then it becomes received wisdom that everyone felt that way at the time, etc.
It keeps life interesting, at any rate.
Igel
(35,300 posts)Just as nationalism is at the heart of a lot of other protests.
Ever observe Venezuelan politics in the last decade? Go Venezuela, and down with ______!
We hear nifty things about Catalonian nationalism.
And all kinds of other nationalisms. We just don't like some. When they're not going to support governments that we like. (It's not about them. It's really about us. We just like to think it's us caring about them.)
In the case of Ukrainian nationalism, it's usually "right."Almost by definitino. That's a loaded term, of course, since Ukrainian "right" and "left" aren't exactly the same as American "right" and "left." The problem is that a lot of Ukrainian nationalists aren't skinheads--they just don't want the Ukraine to be a fully-owned satrapy of Moscow, as it has been for hundreds of years. And Ukrainian nationalism is strongest in areas that were both non-Soviet and non-Russian-Empire for decades, even if for a few years they sided with Hitler because, well, they didn't like how the Ukraine was treated by Stalin and didn't want Ukraine to be essentially Russian.
The nationalists certainly include skinheads and ardent racists (not like that requires being all that "right" by American standards--I've known some fairly racist Russian "communists" . And, when confrontation's brewing, they're likely to be front and center. But they're not alone in the Maidan, they're just the ones getting the attention. They're the ones that Klitschko--not exactly a darling of the left himself--has to contend with in order to keep things from getting even more violent and making the entire Ukrainian nationalist cause seem fascist, even to other Ukrainians would would support a Ukraine free of foreign domination and intervention. They're the ones that the Russian media, official and merely paid for, love to point to because if the Russians are convinced only skinheads and fascists are opposed to Russia, well then there's no supporting any sort of Ukraine that's not properly under Russia's heel.
Starry Messenger
(32,342 posts)I feel like the Ukraine is stuck between two bad options right now, but voting in more Nazis probably won't help either of them.