Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Jefferson23

(30,099 posts)
Fri Feb 21, 2014, 01:57 PM Feb 2014

Man Framed by Detective Will Get $6.4 Million From New York City After Serving 23 Years for Murder

FEB. 20, 2014


David Ranta, wrongly convicted in a 1990 killing, was freed last year. The office of New York City’s comptroller settled the case before a suit had been filed.

A man who was framed by a rogue detective and served 23 years in prison for a murder he did not commit will receive $6.4 million from the City of New York in a settlement that came before a civil rights lawsuit was even filed, lawyers involved in the case said on Thursday.

A $150 million claim filed last year by the man, David Ranta, was settled by the city comptroller’s office without ever involving the city’s legal department — which the lawyers involved in the negotiations described as a “groundbreaking” decision that acknowledged the overwhelming evidence the city faced.

The comptroller’s quick acceptance of liability in the high-profile conviction is also significant because the case is the first of what is expected to be a series of wrongful conviction claims by men who were sent to prison based on the flawed investigative work of the detective, Louis Scarcella, who has been accused of inventing confessions, coercing witnesses and recycling informers.
Related Coverage

“While no amount of money could ever compensate David for the 23 years that were taken away from him, this settlement allows him the stability to continue to put his life back together,” Mr. Ranta’s lawyer, Pierre Sussman, said. “We are now focusing our efforts on pursuing an unjust conviction claim with the State of New York.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/21/nyregion/man-framed-by-new-york-detective-to-get-6-4-million-without-filing-suit.html?_r=0

19 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Man Framed by Detective Will Get $6.4 Million From New York City After Serving 23 Years for Murder (Original Post) Jefferson23 Feb 2014 OP
Who was the cop? jollyreaper2112 Feb 2014 #1
Louis Scarcella...a piece of shit detective. Jefferson23 Feb 2014 #3
Amen uponit7771 Feb 2014 #6
Do they have to pay taxes on that? tammywammy Feb 2014 #2
I don't know, but what is striking is that NYC is paying out, now..with no filing. Jefferson23 Feb 2014 #4
Oh, I agree! tammywammy Feb 2014 #5
We'll see what happens going forward, but I agree...he could get more and deserves it. n/t Jefferson23 Feb 2014 #8
Not on a settlement. nt msanthrope Feb 2014 #7
Thanks! n/t tammywammy Feb 2014 #9
I recommend reading the entire article...makes it seem like this might not be joeybee12 Feb 2014 #10
Yes, see post #3. n/t Jefferson23 Feb 2014 #11
Good Lord... joeybee12 Feb 2014 #12
Outrageous, and why you can reason NYC is making the gesture to pay out before the lawyers Jefferson23 Feb 2014 #13
Oh yeah, they know there's no way they'd not have to pay... joeybee12 Feb 2014 #14
This message was self-deleted by its author Th1onein Feb 2014 #15
Scarcella needs to spend at least as much time behind bars as the innocent man he put there DFW Feb 2014 #16
There is not much legal power as yet that I have seen to go after Scarcella and Hynes, yet Jefferson23 Feb 2014 #19
Kick! Heidi Feb 2014 #17
Jail Louis Scarcella of the NYPD is on Facebook. Jefferson23 Feb 2014 #18

Jefferson23

(30,099 posts)
3. Louis Scarcella...a piece of shit detective.
Fri Feb 21, 2014, 02:05 PM
Feb 2014

Last edited Fri Feb 21, 2014, 03:37 PM - Edit history (1)

Louis Scarcella’s Ex-Partner Is Coming Under Scrutiny in Brooklyn Cases

Nelson I. Cruz, who is in prison for a 1998 murder, holding a drawing of the crime scene he made based on testimony he said was false.
By FRANCES ROBLES

Published: December 27, 2013


Behind his back, Stephen W. Chmil was called Robin — the quiet sidekick to his more handsome, daring and celebrated partner.



Detectives Louis Scarcella, left, and Stephen W. Chmil in 1990. Dozens of Mr. Scarcella’s cases are under review by Brooklyn prosecutors.

Batman was Louis Scarcella, a star detective known for making arrests and getting convictions in the crime-plagued Brooklyn of the 1980s and ’90s. He and Detective Chmil spent a dozen years together as part of a roving homicide unit in Brooklyn North that investigated more than 500 murders a year.

“I don’t know who loved being a detective more — him or me,” Mr. Chmil recalled.

Their legacy was deeply tarnished in March when they were accused of lying and cheating to make a high-profile case stick. At the Brooklyn district attorney’s request, a judge ruled that the man convicted in that case, who spent 23 years in prison, should go free.

That, and misconduct allegations found in other cases, prompted District Attorney Charles J. Hynes to reopen the cases of 56 people arrested by Detective Scarcella who were convicted at trial.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/28/nyregion/like-his-old-partner-scarcella-chmil-comes-under-scrutiny.html

Jefferson23

(30,099 posts)
4. I don't know, but what is striking is that NYC is paying out, now..with no filing.
Fri Feb 21, 2014, 02:07 PM
Feb 2014

The suit started out at 150 million..but he gets over 6 with no delay.

 

joeybee12

(56,177 posts)
10. I recommend reading the entire article...makes it seem like this might not be
Fri Feb 21, 2014, 03:19 PM
Feb 2014

the only guy the detective set up...for phucks sake.

Jefferson23

(30,099 posts)
13. Outrageous, and why you can reason NYC is making the gesture to pay out before the lawyers
Fri Feb 21, 2014, 03:35 PM
Feb 2014

even filed.

 

joeybee12

(56,177 posts)
14. Oh yeah, they know there's no way they'd not have to pay...
Fri Feb 21, 2014, 03:38 PM
Feb 2014

And doing it quickly keeps their costs down...

Response to Jefferson23 (Original post)

DFW

(54,363 posts)
16. Scarcella needs to spend at least as much time behind bars as the innocent man he put there
Wed Feb 26, 2014, 05:49 AM
Feb 2014

The same goes for the DA, Hynes.

There is no way to compensate someone for 23 years of life robbed, but there is a way to show that society will not tolerate it--unless society IS willing to tolerate it.

Their other phony conviction need to be made public as well, the victims compensated and the two of the put away for life.

Catching bad guys is all well and good, but putting innocent guys away because you can't catch the real perps is NOT an acceptable alternative.

Jefferson23

(30,099 posts)
19. There is not much legal power as yet that I have seen to go after Scarcella and Hynes, yet
Wed Feb 26, 2014, 03:20 PM
Feb 2014

PR is bad for them and keeping their crimes in the press:

EXCLUSIVE: Chris Noth set to play former Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes in new movie
The movie is based on the case of 19-year-old Fairfield University honor student Mark Fisher, who was shot dead in Ditmas Park, Brooklyn, after a night of barhopping on Oct 12, 2003.

Noth hopes the movie helps free convicted killer John Giuca.

Actor Chris Noth plans to play former Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes in an independent film being developed.

Monday, February 10, 2014, 2:00 AM

Read more: http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/chris-noth-plans-star-brooklyn-district-attorney-charles-hynes-article-1.1607882#ixzz2uSQB6zkc


Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Man Framed by Detective W...