Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

neverforget

(9,436 posts)
Thu Apr 3, 2014, 11:46 PM Apr 2014

Senator Wyden: Americans will be "profoundly disturbed" by report on CIA

Sen. Wyden: Americans will be 'profoundly disturbed' by report on CIA's terrorist interrogations

U.S. Sen. Ron Wyden explained today why he voted to declassify the Senate Intelligence Committee's apparently scathing 6,200-page report on the CIA's detention and brutal interrogation of overseas terrorism suspects.

"I believe the American people will be profoundly disturbed by the contents of this report," the senior senator from Oregon wrote in a news release. "Though I can't provide any details until that declassification process is finished, I can say that the American people will see that much of what CIA officials have said about the effectiveness of coercive interrogations was simply untrue."

-----

"I have spoken about the intelligence leadership's culture of misinformation before and it continues to be a problem to this day," Wyden said in his news statement. "I have also been asking questions publicly for years about the role that outside contractors played in the interrogation program and I hope the American people will soon get some answers to those questions."

-----

"It is going to make many people uncomfortable," he wrote, "but getting the facts about torture out to the American people will keep these mistakes from being repeated and make our national intelligence agencies stronger and more effective in the long run."


When this report is declassified, will anyone responsible for the torture, those that gave the orders and those that carried them out, be held accountable??
55 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Senator Wyden: Americans will be "profoundly disturbed" by report on CIA (Original Post) neverforget Apr 2014 OP
I'm looking forward to looking forward. MannyGoldstein Apr 2014 #1
Speak for yourself. I'm looking forward to looking backwards, Raksha Apr 2014 #46
If anybody is tried, it will be the proverbial bad apple. nadinbrzezinski Apr 2014 #2
This NSA spying business has been a stain and the CIA torture an embarrassment to the country quinnox Apr 2014 #3
This one won't be. Rex Apr 2014 #4
I hope you're not right, because if you are, we're doomed to repeat this again neverforget Apr 2014 #5
Doesn't that kinda seem like a major human trait? Rex Apr 2014 #7
Disturbed enough to drag King Georgie and his court rocktivity Apr 2014 #6
Barack and Nancy won't allow that FiveGoodMen Apr 2014 #39
You're right, unfortunately. Raksha Apr 2014 #47
Well since everything else has been, this might as well. Savannahmann Apr 2014 #8
Well if Congress has nothing to hide, why be so scared of a little CIA snooping? Rex Apr 2014 #35
I'm profoundly disturbed already. grahamhgreen Apr 2014 #9
What rock have they been living under for the last decade? pffshht Apr 2014 #10
Good point and welcome to DU nadinbrzezinski Apr 2014 #12
thank you Senator Wyden grasswire Apr 2014 #11
Good idea! neverforget Apr 2014 #14
kick and rec for attention this deserves 2banon Apr 2014 #13
yes creepy comments indeed lunasun Apr 2014 #49
MUST. blkmusclmachine Apr 2014 #15
Sen. Wyden was often a lone voice against these agencies, against the secrecy, the torture etc sabrina 1 Apr 2014 #16
When Wyden speaks about this stuff, I listen because neverforget Apr 2014 #21
Wyden and Merkley are a pretty good pair of Senators. Maedhros Apr 2014 #30
Me either condoleeza Apr 2014 #50
Wyden has disappointed me in the past (e.g. the healthcare reform debate) Maedhros Apr 2014 #51
As to your operational last question: vlakitti Apr 2014 #17
I'm afraid that it'll only be low level people and not the neverforget Apr 2014 #22
Well, someome probably will be. JoeyT Apr 2014 #18
The low level ones will get jail while those that gave the orders get off. I certainly hope not! neverforget Apr 2014 #43
If the US takes no action to prosecute those responsible for the torture, maybe some JDPriestly Apr 2014 #19
I wonder if we might have tortured out of vengeance? neverforget Apr 2014 #23
Probably. Yes. Out of vengeance. And yes. We have lost the moral high ground. JDPriestly Apr 2014 #26
FUCK RON PAUL AND THE LIBERTARIANS!! I'm a Democrat and I'm supporting my Party! Douglas Carpenter Apr 2014 #20
Sarcasm? [n/t] Maedhros Apr 2014 #31
Yep, being familar with his posts, it is. And pretty funny sarcasm at that. quinnox Apr 2014 #34
There need to be jail time associated with torture hootinholler Apr 2014 #24
It's already required! grahamhgreen Apr 2014 #41
Accountablity? Hell no, we're all too busy looking forward dontcha know... truebrit71 Apr 2014 #25
Wyden's full statement ProSense Apr 2014 #27
Thank you ProSense for posting that! neverforget Apr 2014 #48
There won't be any accountability get the red out Apr 2014 #28
Let's hope that justice wins the day. neverforget Apr 2014 #40
It is get the red out Apr 2014 #42
I am "profoundly disturbed" that there will be no accountability for these crimes. Autumn Apr 2014 #29
Putin lover! Rex Apr 2014 #36
And whose fault would that be Rex??? You post porn and dare to point out when a person Autumn Apr 2014 #37
Sigh, busted I am a Putin lover enabler... Rex Apr 2014 #38
It's almost like living a Walt Disney movie, only rated bare chested Autumn Apr 2014 #45
Me too. Solly Mack Apr 2014 #44
Drip, drip, drip. We can add it to this week's SC decision... polichick Apr 2014 #32
Wondering if coincidence ... retired af major Apr 2014 #33
Aren't we too numb, and too remote from the levers of power, to give a shit? librechik Apr 2014 #52
I wish they would be profoundly zentrum Apr 2014 #53
"will anyone responsible for the torture," Javaman Apr 2014 #54
Some people that carried it out have been punished shanemcg Apr 2014 #55

Raksha

(7,167 posts)
46. Speak for yourself. I'm looking forward to looking backwards,
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 10:07 PM
Apr 2014

even though I know I'm not going to like what I see.

I assume you were being sarcastic, though.

 

quinnox

(20,600 posts)
3. This NSA spying business has been a stain and the CIA torture an embarrassment to the country
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 12:11 AM
Apr 2014

Thanks to Sen. Wyden for being one of those who refused to shut up about it!

He certainly didn't make friends at the White House for his stubborn persistence.

 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
4. This one won't be.
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 12:11 AM
Apr 2014

Also I know no one will be held responsible. THAT would require accountability and we ain't doing that!

 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
7. Doesn't that kinda seem like a major human trait?
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 12:31 AM
Apr 2014

If we look throughout history, it almost seems like we are fated to make the same mistakes over and over.

Somewhat like heroin imo, we go until we take that one fatal dose (as a nation) and we either die or barely survive to hopefully have an epiphany and then hope that it lasts a lifetime.

With attention spans being what they are, well it just worries me.

indeed.

 

Savannahmann

(3,891 posts)
8. Well since everything else has been, this might as well.
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 12:34 AM
Apr 2014

Come on Gang, let's GOTV! That way we can stop the CIA from spying on the Senate or something.

 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
35. Well if Congress has nothing to hide, why be so scared of a little CIA snooping?
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 01:21 PM
Apr 2014

Before you say WTF...I read it RIGHT HERE on DU by a longtime poster! I wish I was joking.

pffshht

(79 posts)
10. What rock have they been living under for the last decade?
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 12:42 AM
Apr 2014

The people who will shocked by this are the same ones who were shocked by Snowden's "revelations" about what the NSA has been doing.

 

2banon

(7,321 posts)
13. kick and rec for attention this deserves
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 12:54 AM
Apr 2014

anyone have a look at the comment section at that link?

unbelievable trash/mindset there.

sabrina 1

(62,325 posts)
16. Sen. Wyden was often a lone voice against these agencies, against the secrecy, the torture etc
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 01:17 AM
Apr 2014

during the Bush era. He has never stopped trying to get the truth out to the American people. Several years ago on a different blog, I wrote a thank to him as he was the ONLY one with the guts to speak out back then. It's been a long road for him but he must have been very relieved by the Snowden revelations which forced the issue to the front pages of the world's media finally.

I always wondered why he was so deeply concerned about this issues when many of his colleagues chose to remain silent.

Then I read his father's book and learned something of his family's history, and it all became clear to me.

Thanks once again Senator, for understanding what 'Never Again' really meant.

neverforget

(9,436 posts)
21. When Wyden speaks about this stuff, I listen because
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 06:30 AM
Apr 2014

he's not known for overblown rhetoric. He's a good Senator and I'm proud that I can vote for him.

 

Maedhros

(10,007 posts)
30. Wyden and Merkley are a pretty good pair of Senators.
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 12:28 PM
Apr 2014

God, I can't believe we had to suffer through the Gordon Smith years.

condoleeza

(814 posts)
50. Me either
Sun Apr 6, 2014, 10:46 AM
Apr 2014

So happy we now have Wyden and Merkley and to see them making a difference, not just collecting a paycheck.

 

Maedhros

(10,007 posts)
51. Wyden has disappointed me in the past (e.g. the healthcare reform debate)
Sun Apr 6, 2014, 12:27 PM
Apr 2014

but his efforts with respect to reforming the NSA are welcome.

vlakitti

(401 posts)
17. As to your operational last question:
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 02:11 AM
Apr 2014

"When this report is declassified, will anyone responsible for the torture, those that gave the orders and those that carried them out, be held accountable??"

That's a rhetorical question, right?


The answer is hell, no. These are the people who are never held accountable.

JoeyT

(6,785 posts)
18. Well, someome probably will be.
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 02:42 AM
Apr 2014

I'm sure a few scapegoats will be hauled out into the village square and crucified so the Very Serious People can pretend we totally restored the rule of law and anyone that still talks about torture or other war crimes is just a malcontent to be ignored.

neverforget

(9,436 posts)
43. The low level ones will get jail while those that gave the orders get off. I certainly hope not!
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 08:12 PM
Apr 2014

It's a recipe for it to happen again.

JDPriestly

(57,936 posts)
19. If the US takes no action to prosecute those responsible for the torture, maybe some
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 02:50 AM
Apr 2014

international body will. I don't think the US will do a thing. And the right-wing press will try to make heroes of the people who authorized the torture. The world will judge in any event. And I think that is a good thing. Maybe if the world let's the Bush administration know how immoral this torture is, then Republicans will think twice before doing such things again.

By the way, it seems logical to me that the torture did not produce much information. I would be surprised if Al Qaeda is organized like a well-oiled military in a sophisticated country. They may be successful in their inhuman, cruel isolated actions. But I gather from how widespread they seem to be and what fanatics they are that the individuals in Al Qaeda are probably not people who follow a leader with great discipline. Their actions may take short-term discipline and there may be small to medium-sized groups that are well disciplined, but the left hand probably does not always know what the right-and is doing, and neither does the brain, whoever that is.

If, in an organization, the information about strategy is diffused through the system and tends in part to bubble up rather than to trickle down, people working in the system know random facts that vaguely form a pattern, but do not know have an overall understanding of that system. In other words, systems that are loosely formed, made up of people who have a vague goal but are not focused on organization are difficult to spy on. Which is why the NSA is so frustrated that it tries to spy on all of us. It needs a different approach. It has a tough challenge.

neverforget

(9,436 posts)
23. I wonder if we might have tortured out of vengeance?
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 09:43 AM
Apr 2014

We lose the moral high ground when we act like those we despise.

hootinholler

(26,449 posts)
24. There need to be jail time associated with torture
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 10:11 AM
Apr 2014

From the highest high to the lowest low, if you torture you go to jail.

Additionally there needs to be a failure to prosecute burden, such that if you are aware of torture and fail to prosecute it, you are an accomplice and get to go to jail too.

We already require health professionals to pursue signs of child abuse under the penalty of law, we can require this.

ProSense

(116,464 posts)
27. Wyden's full statement
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 10:35 AM
Apr 2014
Wyden Statement on the Senate Intelligence Committee’s Vote to Declassify its Interrogation Report

Thursday, April 3, 2014

Washington, D.C. – U.S. Senator Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) released the following statement after the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence voted to begin the process of declassifying the committee’s 6,200 page report on CIA interrogations:

“I believe the American people will be profoundly disturbed by the contents of this report. Today, I joined my colleagues in voting to begin the process of declassifying the findings. Though I can’t provide any details until that declassification process is finished, I can say that the American people will see that much of what CIA officials have said about the effectiveness of coercive interrogations was simply untrue. I have spoken about the intelligence leadership’s culture of misinformation before and it continues to be a problem to this day.

I have also been asking questions publicly for years about the role that outside contractors played in the interrogation program and I hope the American people will soon get some answers to those questions. I urge the administration to move quickly to declassify this report. It is going to make many people uncomfortable, but getting the facts about torture out to the American people will keep these mistakes from being repeated and make our national intelligence agencies stronger and more effective in the long run.”


http://www.wyden.senate.gov/news/press-releases/wyden-statement-on-the-senate-intelligence-committees-vote-to-declassify-its-interrogation-report


Other statements

Senate Committee Votes to Release Landmark Report on CIA Torture

Upcoming Declassification Review Will Be Key Test for President Obama

WASHINGTON – The Senate Select Committee on Intelligence voted today, by a bipartisan majority, to submit to the White House for declassification review and public release the executive summary, findings, and conclusions of the panel’s report on the CIA’s Bush-era rendition, secret detention, and torture program. The full 6,300-page report is the most comprehensive account to date of the torture program.

"The vote on this landmark report is a big step towards making sure that all Americans know the truth about torture, so that we can make sure that torture is never used again," said Christopher Anders, senior legislative counsel with the American Civil Liberties Union. "The key challenge for President Obama now is whether he will finally stand up to the CIA. The president should assert his authority to have the White House itself, and not the CIA, decide what gets declassified and what gets redacted. The CIA should not be handed a black-out pen to hide its use of torture or the lies it told to keep the torture program going."

A coalition of human rights and civil liberties groups sent a letter to President Obama last week to urge him, "given the CIA's inherent conflict of interest concerning the report," to have the White House itself lead the declassification process.

According to media accounts, the Senate report found that the CIA misled Congress, the Justice Department, and the Bush White House about the use of torture methods such as simulated drownings, shackling in painful positions, induced hypothermia, and slamming detainees against walls. The report also reportedly found that such methods did not help locate Osama bin Laden or thwart any terrorist plots, and were in fact counterproductive.

The ACLU is currently litigating a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit to obtain the full investigative report, the CIA’s official response defending its actions, and an internal agency review commissioned by then-CIA Director Leon Panetta. The Panetta review reportedly contradicts some of the CIA’s official response to the Senate report. The CIA agreed in January in the lawsuit to process for possible release the CIA response and the Panetta review. That potential release is scheduled for May 22.

https://www.aclu.org/national-security/senate-committee-votes-release-landmark-report-cia-torture


Comment Of Senator Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.), Chairman, Senate Judiciary Committee, On The Senate Intelligence Committee’s Torture Report

“The Intelligence Committee’s report on the now-defunct CIA detention and interrogation program should be shared with the American people to the greatest extent possible. The Senate at its best can act as the conscience of the Nation, and part of that responsibility is ensuring transparency in our government. We cannot learn from our mistakes without understanding what happened and how they occurred. The administration should move swiftly to review the committee’s executive summary, findings and conclusions so that they can be made public in as full a form as possible.

“The use of torture during the previous administration was a shameful chapter in our history, and I fully support the Committee’s efforts to investigate and document what really happened. Senator Feinstein deserves enormous credit for her continued leadership in seeking declassification of portions of this report. I applaud her and those members of the Intelligence Committee who took the important step today of bringing this critical information one step closer to the public.”

http://www.leahy.senate.gov/press/comment-of-senator-patrick-leahy-d-vt-chairman-senate-judiciary-committee-on-the-senate-intelligence-committees-torture-report


Udall Heralds Historic Vote to Declassify Senate Intelligence Committee Study of CIA's Detention, Interrogation Program

Udall Pledges to Fight to Ensure White House, CIA Do Not Stymie Public Release of Landmark Study

Mark Udall, a leading advocate for Congress's duty to provide strong and independent oversight of covert agencies, heralded the U.S. Senate Select Committee on Intelligence's bipartisan 11-3 vote today to declassify its landmark study of the CIA's detention and interrogation program. Udall, who serves on the committee and has led the effort to declassify the Senate Intelligence Committee's study, pledged to press the White House and CIA for the fullest possible declassification of the committee’s report.

"Today's vote is a historic moment for the Senate Intelligence Committee and our vigorous oversight efforts. I am calling on the president today to oversee the declassification process to ensure that as much of this important document as possible sees the light of day," Udall said. "The Constitution is clear and Coloradans agree that the Senate Intelligence Committee has a responsibility to oversee the CIA — regardless of who is president — and provide a full and accurate accounting of the operation and effectiveness of this misguided and destructive program.

"The public release of this study is critical to shedding light on this dark chapter of our country's history. It is also critical to restoring the credibility and integrity of the CIA as an institution. Anyone who dismisses this study for its focus on actions of the past need only look at the events of the past few months — in particular, the CIA's unauthorized search of the committee's computers — to understand that the CIA not only hasn't learned from its mistakes, but continues to perpetuate them. This study should impart crucial lessons to the CIA about the need to better operate and assess its programs and to accurately represent them. Acknowledging the detention and interrogation program's flaws is essential for the CIA's long-term institutional integrity, as well as for the legitimacy of ongoing sensitive programs. The findings of this report directly relate to how other CIA programs are managed today.

"To those who continue to argue that torture is effective, this study makes a powerful argument to the contrary — drawing from six million of the CIA's own records and past interview reports of key personnel to do so. I hope that one of the key lessons that the CIA and our national security leaders take from this study is that we should never again torture in the name of national security — and that oversight of intelligence operations is essential in a constitutional democracy."

Udall, who has repeatedly pressed the White House to publicly commit to declassifying the Senate Intelligence Committee's study, further urged the White House to ensure the CIA does not oversee the declassification of the study.

"Following today's historic vote, the president faces what I believe should be a straightforward question. He can defer declassification decisions to the CIA — which has demonstrated an inability to face the truth about this program — or pass this authority to the Director of National Intelligence or hold on to the redaction pen himself," Udall added. "The president needs to understand that the CIA's clear conflict of interest here requires that the White House step in and manage this process."

http://www.markudall.senate.gov/?p=press_release&id=4154


get the red out

(13,461 posts)
28. There won't be any accountability
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 10:47 AM
Apr 2014

But, I hope it could fuel an actual desire to get the CIA under control! Hope anyway.

I'm afraid some people will like the fact that "enemies" were tortured. There are probably those on the right who will try to make it a badge of honor for the CIA. Will people really care after "both sides" are heard on torture? Scary to think many might not.

neverforget

(9,436 posts)
40. Let's hope that justice wins the day.
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 05:04 PM
Apr 2014

It's the right thing to do to hold those people accountable for what happened.

Autumn

(45,056 posts)
29. I am "profoundly disturbed" that there will be no accountability for these crimes.
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 10:50 AM
Apr 2014

You know, looking forward and all that shit.

Autumn

(45,056 posts)
37. And whose fault would that be Rex??? You post porn and dare to point out when a person
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 01:50 PM
Apr 2014

succumbs to the mighty shirtlessness that is Putin ? I blame you for my being a Putin lover!

http://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=4710306

 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
38. Sigh, busted I am a Putin lover enabler...
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 01:56 PM
Apr 2014

I take one look at that hairy, manly chest and I just melt...plus he is the King of the Animals! Don't you want to be friends with the King of the Animals?

Yes, you too can ride a sharkbear! Thrilling!

Autumn

(45,056 posts)
45. It's almost like living a Walt Disney movie, only rated bare chested
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 08:29 PM
Apr 2014

dare I say I could almost swoon with the emotion. I feel like wearing a cape and dancing and singing in the woods.

retired af major

(49 posts)
33. Wondering if coincidence ...
Fri Apr 4, 2014, 01:15 PM
Apr 2014

A new season of 24 starts in May! You remember that show don't you, the CIA guy beats the bad guys silly during interrogations looking for weapons of mass destruction. First show premiered two months after Sept 11, 2001.
Nothing sketchy about this at all.

librechik

(30,674 posts)
52. Aren't we too numb, and too remote from the levers of power, to give a shit?
Sun Apr 6, 2014, 12:39 PM
Apr 2014

If people could see that it's only a moment and a few anonymous decisions before we all are in places like Guantanamo and nobody will give a shit about us?

I think we're hopelessly suicidal as a species, let alone an electorate.
.

zentrum

(9,865 posts)
53. I wish they would be profoundly
Sun Apr 6, 2014, 07:47 PM
Apr 2014

...disturbed, but they will yawn. The majority don't care what is done to those labeled "terrorists". Our country has lost its moral center.

Javaman

(62,517 posts)
54. "will anyone responsible for the torture,"
Mon Apr 7, 2014, 11:10 AM
Apr 2014

No.

That's how it works in todays America.

When confronted with questions as to why the purps won't be brought up on charges we will be the recipient of various forms of the now tired phrase, "the nation wouldn't survive it". And a rough translation means, "we, the current crop of willful stooges (aka politicians) to the wealthy and military machine, wouldn't survive it"

It's all about preserving legacy based on lies and the "winners" who write/rewrite the history.

Don't get me wrong, there will always be those who will work as the poster children for the outraged. The various congress people that will call for investigations (blue ribbon or otherwise) to "get to the bottom of this".

There will be all sorts of speeches, televised conferences and various hearings filled with lots of feigned indignation and finger wagging. The well rehearsed and over practiced expressions of "exasperation" and "head shaking in wonderment".

And most certainly there will be the usual smoke and mirrors by both sides to cloud out the actual issue which could lead to an actual real investigation.

In the end?

Several underlings will fall on their swords to serve their time in a country club jail for "crimes" that only cut the surface of the actual travesty, but they will be paraded around as the "one" who was the "mastermind".

The full court press by the Sunday talk show spokes models will make sure that subterfuge is the name of the game.

But the main mission is further division, not between the have mores and the have even less, but to further exploit infighting within the middle and lower class. Continuing to make sure that we the people never ever coalesce on a common cause.

And our gaze is never kept for long on the actual issue.

Don't be the least surprised if some non-trovercy (think Benghazi) is trumped up to distract us all when the real red meat of this report is issued. (most likely on a Friday Night News dump)

Yes, I'm cynical. I have lived a long time and have been witness to how our nation transitioned from the rights of the people to the rights of the corporation.

And at the end of the day, when all is lied and done, it's about money. It's always been about money. Nothing more nothing less.

And those in power; (don't insult yourself by thinking the politicians are in power) want to stay in power.

 

shanemcg

(80 posts)
55. Some people that carried it out have been punished
Mon Apr 7, 2014, 12:26 PM
Apr 2014

All the low lying fruit at Abu Graibh were convicted based on the photos that came out in the media and I believe a few officer sacrificial lambs, but no one of the higher ups like Cheney, Rumsvillan, or W. I guess the buck stops much lower these days!

Think of the jail time and life of derision that little hillbilly woman with the leash will endure for her part in torture, while W and the others that ordered it NO DOUBT, enjoy lives of splendor and honor.

Edit: removed an unnecessary epithet to an unfortunate backwoods woman.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Senator Wyden: Americans ...