General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsStudy: One Out of Twenty Five Death Row Inmates Is Innocent
How many American prisoners have been wrongfully convicted of the crimes they're serving time for? Answering that question would help measure the effectiveness the criminal justice system.
Researchers of a study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences tried to get to this answer by reviewing death penalty cases. Because of the life-or-death stakes involved, a lot more effort is exerted to exonerate death row inmates than any other cohort of inmate.
In fact, according to the research, 1.7 percent of all death row inmates are eventually exonerated. It's a higher number than the one quoted by Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia in Kansas v. Marsh, a case about the death penalty. He claimed the error rate was .027 percent. The researchers dismissed that number; they say it was arrived at by extending the exoneration rate of a small subgroup of inmates (capital cases) to the wider American prison population.
Instead, the researchers used the exoneration rate on death row and extended it to inmates whose capital punishment is replaced by life imprisonment, at which point efforts to exonerate them largely subside. Based on that idea, they estimate 4.1 percent, or one in 25, of all death row inmates are innocent, meaning that they would be exonerated if they remained on death row.
more
http://reason.com/blog/2014/04/29/study-one-out-of-twenty-five-death-row-i
truebrit71
(20,805 posts)...
JustAnotherGen
(31,781 posts)truebrit71
(20,805 posts)"ITA"??
JustAnotherGen
(31,781 posts)truebrit71
(20,805 posts)For some reason I just couldn't work that out!!
The Magistrate
(95,243 posts)And it is a weighty one.
JustAnotherGen
(31,781 posts)morningfog
(18,115 posts)Other arguments against the DP include the extreme cost and resources, that it is cruel and unusual punishment, and that is an act of killing.
KamaAina
(78,249 posts)The race of the victim matters more than the race of the killer. In effect, the penalty for taking a white life is death, while for taking a black life, it's life in prison without parole.
Shoulders of Giants
(370 posts)I don't like the idea that the government has the power to kill people who are no longer a threat to society. Vengeance solves nothing. I wish we as a society did not sink to the level of the people who are on death row. This is the main reason I'm against the death penalty. However, the fact that there are innocent people on death row adds to the problem. An innocent person on who gets executed on death row can't appeal a false conviction.
Logical
(22,457 posts)The Magistrate
(95,243 posts)The question boils down to how good is the state's aim in particular instances.
Logical
(22,457 posts)Death penalty! Not many I admire!
The Magistrate
(95,243 posts)Egnever
(21,506 posts)Logical
(22,457 posts)RedCappedBandit
(5,514 posts)Victor_c3
(3,557 posts)and that is coming from a guy that is on the fence on capital punishment (or who at least was until hearing this number). That is a totally startling number.
surrealAmerican
(11,358 posts)How about the fact that it's more costly than the alternatives, yet no more effective at preventing crime?
Drale
(7,932 posts)Arugula Latte
(50,566 posts)being executed as a factor that makes state-performed execution entirely unacceptable. The fact that many, many innocent people have been killed in our names says volumes about this country.
nadinbrzezinski
(154,021 posts)RedCappedBandit
(5,514 posts)and people will be outraged at you.
ZombieHorde
(29,047 posts)etherealtruth
(22,165 posts)whopis01
(3,491 posts)If the death penalty is eliminated, anyone who would have gotten it is likely to get life in prison. So all the innocent ones will just be locked up for life.
Of course, as long as they are alive there is a chance that they will be exonerated. I get that. But it is still a life of hell for an innocent person to be locked away for a crime they didn't commit. I am sure it feels good to get set free after 20, 30, 40 years or more - but that only feels good because it is better than the alternative of staying wrongfully imprisoned. It is a far cry from how they should have been treated to begin with.
And, as pointed out in the article, people don't try as hard to get a lifer exonerated as they do someone on death row.
Don't get me wrong - the death penalty has no redeeming qualities and needs to be banned immediately. It just pisses me off that it still won't help many.