General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSorry America, Ukraine isn’t all about you | PandoDaily
As the Ukraine crisis tips further into full-scale bloodbath and civil war, we seem to be getting more clueless than we were before this crisis started. Thats a pretty low bar to measure against, and the consequences of our cluelessness about whats driving the various sides could be catastrophic for everyone.
One of the biggest problems is that everyone who riffs on Putin and Ukraine frames their analysis through a very narrow, Americanized lens, as if the only thing on everyones minds out there is us, America. Either Putin is behaving evilly because he fears Americas empire of liberty and freedom; or Putin is behaving perfectly rationally because the evil American empire has bullied Putin into a corner, forcing him to annex Crimea and support pro-Russian separatists.
.....
The important thing to remember is this: Russias liberal intelligentsia and its big city yuppie class is small in numbers, outsized in influence and importance
. and hated by the rest of Russia. And theres a lot to hate: intelligentsia liberals and Moscow yuppies are elitist snobs on a scale that would turn anyone into a Bolshevik. They even named their go-to glossy Snob and they meant it. Its not just the new rich who are elitist snobs liberal journalist-dissident Elena Tregubovas memoir on press censorship interweaves her contempt for Putin with her Muscovite contempt for what she called aborigines, those provincial Russian multitudes who occupy the rest of Russias eleven time zones. Tregubova flaunted her contempt for Russias aborigines, whom she mocked for being too poor and uncivilized to tell the difference between processed orange juice and her beloved fresh-squeezed orange juice. Im not making that up either.
.....
Most living Russians still remember the Soviet era, when wealth inequality was so minute it was measured in perks rather than yachts. Thats what the Russians mean when they tell pollsters they preferred the Soviet Union days and rue its collapse. Lazy hacks interpret those polls as proof that Russians are still evil empirelings, for the sheer evil joy of having a Warsaw Pact to boast about. Rather than the obvious: Russians lived longer and easier under Soviet rule, then started dying off by the millions as soon as capitalism was introduced, when poverty exploded and they found themselves in the most unequal country on earth.
[And its not just Russians: In a Gallup poll late last year, a majority of Ukrainians said that the collapse of the Soviet Union was more harmful (56 percent) for Ukraine than beneficial (23 percent).]
http://pando.com/2014/05/14/sorry-america-the-ukraine-isnt-all-about-you/
Fred Sanders
(23,946 posts)independentpiney
(1,510 posts)it quotes from the movie Full Metal Jacket. Definitely representative of the way many Americans, including many on DU see non-western peoples and countries.