Arizona’s Botched Execution
By Dahlia Lithwick
On Wednesday afternoon, in a ritual that has become increasinglyindeed almost numbinglyfamiliar, the state of Arizona administered a secret drug protocol that took almost two hours to kill a man. Joseph R. Wood III was sentenced to death in 1991 for shooting and killing his ex-girlfriend Debra Dietz and her father, Eugene. The murder was gruesome, and Wood was guilty. He shot his victims in the chest at close range. The only question that remains, as yet another state botches yet another execution, is whether the two hours of gasping and snorting by the accused before he finally died is excessive, or whether it sounds about right to us.
Woods execution dragged on for so long that at the midpoint, his lawyers filed an emergency appeal to stop the procedure and called on Justice Anthony M. Kennedy to intervene. Wood died before the federal court could respond, and Kennedy turned down the lawyers request. After Wood was pronounced dead, the Arizona Supreme Court ordered that the state preserve any drug labels and unused drugs pertaining to the execution of Mr. Wood.
The two-hour execution was just the latest debacle made possible by an ever more familiar combination of state secrecy, untried protocols being tested for the first time on live human beings, and a judicial system that cant quite make up its mind about how much gasping and coughing is reasonable in a state-sanctioned killing. The new wrinkle is that this time we must endure the spectacle of witnesses to the execution fighting over how much suffering they saw.
Woods lawyers challenged the execution before it took place. They raised First Amendment claims, arguing that the public and the accused had a right to know what was being pumped into Woods veins and where it came from. They asked the courts to let them know, specifically, the source(s), manufacturer(s), National Drug Codes (NDCs), and lot numbers of the drugs the Department intends to use in his execution; (2) non-personally identifying information detailing the qualifications of the personnel the Department will use in his execution; and (3) information and documents explaining how the Department developed its current lethal-injection drug protocol.
more
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/jurisprudence/2014/07/arizona_botched_execution_of_joseph_r_wood_iii_lethal_injection_secrecy.html