General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsBombs to stop genocide in Iraq. Wtf DO WE CALL WHAT'S GOING DOWN IN GAZA?
Wow this is Bushesque bullshit.
NightWatcher
(39,343 posts)Cali_Democrat
(30,439 posts)are you suggesting we bomb Israel?
LordGlenconner
(1,348 posts)It would make a few folks around here pretty happy. For example, the same people who create OPs like this.
elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)that's the point.
LordGlenconner
(1,348 posts)But wish in one hand, shit in the other. See which one fills up first.
Unfortunately violence has been, is, and always will be part of human nature. It is our most fundamental flaw.
laundry_queen
(8,646 posts)whenever I brought up some moral stance I had. Interesting that you use it too. I guess we should never aim for anything higher, we should just say, "Oh fuck it, war happens." I'm glad I'm not THAT cynical and jaded yet. Or maybe I just realize that violence has very specific causes that CAN be addressed. By people who care about it, that is.
elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)SammyWinstonJack
(44,129 posts)woo me with science
(32,139 posts)The moral dumpster fire.
Ash_F
(5,861 posts)Ahh...the internet. Where one can truly let it all out.
ReRe
(10,597 posts).... after all, it happened in the Old Testament all the time.
kentuck
(111,052 posts)Them's the rules.
rhett o rick
(55,981 posts)bombing Israel. Are you ok with the bombing in Iraq? How about Palestine?
ballyhoo
(2,060 posts)SammyWinstonJack
(44,129 posts)we could just cut off all aid and weapons shipments. Maybe even set up a few blockades.
sabrina 1
(62,325 posts)and always have, bombing anyone. If you know who these few are, point them out, alert on them, and they won't be here very long.
Meantime as one of those who vehemently opposes both US and Israels 'policies', if you can call them that, of brutal invasions as a means to 'bring about peace, if I could be God for a day, I would destroy all bombs and other WMDs and if politicians want to fight, I would force them to go face to face, no army, and do it with whatever they can find around the house or garden. The rest of us could watch it on TV and bet on the winner.
I have a feeling there would be very few 'contests' considering the amount of 'courage' generally displayed by the average warmonger in the world today.
msanthrope
(37,549 posts)We just need to stop sending them money umtil they play nice.
ancianita
(35,932 posts)elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)ancianita
(35,932 posts)I trust them as anything but a sensationalizing media org, anyway.
elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)ancianita
(35,932 posts)rhett o rick
(55,981 posts)msongs
(67,360 posts)Fred Sanders
(23,946 posts)To be fair Obama said "potential genocide", Gaza is potential genocide while in actual progress.
elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)HE said genocide.
HERVEPA
(6,107 posts)Words matter.
blackspade
(10,056 posts)And without shelter, water, and medicine is not genocide?
What about the targeting of shelter, schools, and homes?
What does the body count have to be?
Do they only count if the deaths happen over short time?
Yes, words do matter. So do definitions.
Fred Sanders
(23,946 posts)Seven years of siege, and little land to grow food for almost 2 million people. Maybe some of those 'terror tunnels' were used to smuggle in food and pampers? UN facilities bombed, and US charities denied entrance by the Israeli authorities. The main power plant bombed, to ensure there's no power for cell phones and pc's. So much for Pallywood. I fully support Obama's airlift to the people stranded on the mountain in Erbil, Iraq. We need to do the same for those stuck in Gaza.
notadmblnd
(23,720 posts)I Imagine that was the final total after Germany's defeat.
You're right though, words do matter. Not only those said/written, but also some words not said/written.
oberliner
(58,724 posts)Over a million children.
Two-thirds of all the Jews living in Europe (9 million) were killed during that time frame.
Are you really comfortable making this comparison?
notadmblnd
(23,720 posts)And if I'm not mistaken I did say 6 million Plus. So yes, yes I am comfortable
oberliner
(58,724 posts)You see some evidence pointing in that direction?
notadmblnd
(23,720 posts)elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)MFM008
(19,803 posts)gen·o·cide
/ˈjenəˌsīd/
noun
1. the deliberate killing of a large group of people, especially those of a particular ethnic group or nation.
synonyms: mass murder, mass homicide, massacre, annihilation
how large does large have to be?
Skidmore
(37,364 posts)completely. Crossed my mind more than once today.
Fred Sanders
(23,946 posts)Cha
(296,822 posts)possible to help.
hopemountain makes some good points..
http://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=5356924
I've seen Bush's face on the teevee so many times today. I just feel angry. Disgusted and angry. So many bad actors over such a long period of time has created this black hole in the ME which just sucks the life out of the world.
Cha
(296,822 posts)Jefferson23
(30,099 posts)Skidmore
(37,364 posts)throw something besides a pillow at mine.
Cha
(296,822 posts)crash myself through the damn tv.
obxhead
(8,434 posts)We upset a violent balance.
We removed a brutal dictator that had control of a region with 1000's of years of war and turmoil.
We were wrong.
We can not fix it.
Iraqis are the ONLY people that can fix Iraq.
Cha
(296,822 posts)Arguably, Reagan did.
However that's not the point.
Someones got to END it.
Obviously Obama is content with continuing it with just planes and bombs so our next President can make the hard choice of boots on the ground.
I voted to END our actions in Iraq and Afghanistan, not continue them.
ZombieHorde
(29,047 posts)elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)Cha
(296,822 posts)point down whether it makes any fucking sense or not.
elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)sheshe2
(83,653 posts)Wow this is Bushesque bullshit.
So very profound.....
ZombieHorde
(29,047 posts)leftstreet
(36,098 posts)I mean 'US personnel'
DocwillCuNow
(162 posts)malaise
(268,693 posts)and apparently there's no need for a humanitarian approach for the Palestinians.
awoke_in_2003
(34,582 posts)at least that is purportedly what it is called over there
hopemountain
(3,919 posts)nor have they asked for it. nor do we have any military presence there.
the iraqi asked for help to stop the genocide. and the u.s. has personnel there.
what do you want? that we should start world war 3 and bomb the israelis? neither side of this conflict wants it to end in a peaceable compromise to stop the killing.
the president is making a very clear distinction with this aid with regard to conditions for involvment.
the "bushesque bullshit" statement is wholly incorrect. but you knew this.
Cha
(296,822 posts)the US created this horrible mess in Iraq and the President is trying to do the best thing possible.
Violet_Crumble
(35,955 posts)In response to the 'What do you want?' question. What I want is for the US to stop funding Israel's military machine and to show some backbone and speak up against the massive loss of civilian life in Gaza. Instead all I see is the American Congress passing totally one-side resolutions supporting everything Israel does and not saying one single word about the civilian victims...
SammyWinstonJack
(44,129 posts)840high
(17,196 posts)sheshe2
(83,653 posts)Exactly this! Thanks hopemountain, well said.
Violet_Crumble
(35,955 posts)I mean, what would the point be?
Jefferson23
(30,099 posts)swilton
(5,069 posts)It's not like there is one voice in the mess created after Hussein's overthrow.
obxhead
(8,434 posts)Every time we help an Israeli fires a bullet stamped "made in America".
If I were a Palestinian, every cry of Fuck Israel would mean Fuck America!
woo me with science
(32,139 posts)Perhaps?
We certainly do have a military presence there. See post 45. Every time one of our dollars funds a bomb or a bullet blasting into a child, that's a pretty damned significant military presence.
Maybe it never occurred to them to ask our help, since we are actively helping those who are slaughtering them.
Cha
(296,822 posts)trying to help in the best way possible. "bushesque" my
hopemountain
(3,919 posts)bush created the iraqi mess by dividing up the country of iraq and pitting her people against one another, disrupting the tried and true tribal traditions of compromise - as way to control the country's oil resources.
we can also see how those tactics are being played out right here in our own country ... the slivering and mongering is nonstop.
Cha
(296,822 posts)many of us knew the giant can of snakes he would unleash. This is a horrible situation.
Mahalo for your post, hopemountain
former9thward
(31,936 posts)It was the British and French after WW I who drew the lines and divided up the area pitting people against one another. Saddam Hussein kept it together through a brutal dictatorship. Bush broke it apart and now we live with the results. To paint Iraq as ideal before Bush is a distortion.
Rex
(65,616 posts)committed by his predecessor. Even if people don't want to admit to it, we are largely responsible for what is going on in Iraq and I think President Obama not only knows that but would like to show how different Ds and Rs are in handling a crisis.
Of course we are all free to sit here and watch on TV as ISIS murders 40,000 people...glad to see the POTUS is doing something about it.
Very insulting to say it is 'bushesque'...nothing even close to Shock and Awe. This time, we have a valid REASON for being in Iraq.
pampango
(24,692 posts)Baclava
(12,047 posts)seriously
riverwalker
(8,694 posts)we are Israel.
False analogy.
Baclava
(12,047 posts)much more complicated and serious
obxhead
(8,434 posts)Bombing in Iraq to stop potential genocide, while we supply weapons and coordinates to Israel to COMMIT genocide.
GObama!
This is exactly what I was thinking when I voted for hope and change.
ballyhoo
(2,060 posts)RufusTFirefly
(8,812 posts)oberliner
(58,724 posts)Is that a fair read on your post?
RufusTFirefly
(8,812 posts)Excerpts from remarks by Israeli deputy Knesset speaker Moshe Feiglin in an open letter to Netanyahu:
...
2. Definition of the tasks: Conquest of the entire Gaza Strip and elimination of all fighting forces and their supporters.
...
4. Definition of war ethics: Woe to the evildoer, and woe to his neighbor
If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck.... The entire letter is chilling. I left out many of the worst parts.
oberliner
(58,724 posts)From the far right fringe of an already right wing party.
Ahmed Tibi is another of the 10 deputy speakers. His opinions on the subject could not be more opposite.
RufusTFirefly
(8,812 posts)I trust that Netanyahu and the IDF will ignore Feiglin's remarks and continue to gently prod the people of Gaza as before.
oberliner
(58,724 posts)I mean, at least he isn't in charge.
Ash_F
(5,861 posts)The far right is historically more powerful than its number in all countries.
onenote
(42,581 posts)Who knew?
Ash_F
(5,861 posts)TexasProgresive
(12,155 posts)if the U.S.Airforce dropped humanitarian aid in Gaza and the West Bank that they would come under Israeli fire?
oberliner
(58,724 posts)You could even donate if you want.
elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)oberliner
(58,724 posts)TexasProgresive
(12,155 posts)Like the food and supplies that were dropped to the Kurds pre Iraq war and recently to those peole caught up in the mountains.
The airdropped aid would be to supplement the "diet" imposed by Israel.
So, my question is still, if the U.S. did food airdrops into Gaza would they face A.A. fire from Israel? You understand this is a hypothetical question, but is nonetheless begging an answer.
oberliner
(58,724 posts)"Despite the end of the ceasefire, aid is getting through and many of our member agencies are still working on the ground. But with the scale of the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, they urgently need more money to scale up their life-saving work."
http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-28715052
TexasProgresive
(12,155 posts)because you can dance around a question with the best of them.
I can see that you will not answer my question so this discussion is at an end.
onenote
(42,581 posts)$47 million from the US. Additional amounts from other countries. Some comes through Egypt, some through Israel, which has accommodated aid getting to Gazans by, among other things, providing for temporary cease fires.
Remind me again, does ISIS offer cease fires so humanitarian aid gets to the Yazidi?
The facts are inconvenient to your position, but they're still facts.
http://news.yahoo.com/us-send-47m-humanitarian-aid-gaza-strip-205105077--politics.html
http://www.aa.com.tr/en/gaza/369201--italy-sends-emergency-aid-to-war-torn-gaza
https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/news/europe/13020-scandinavian-countries-condemn-israels-disproportionate-violence-sends-millions-to-aid-palestinians
http://venezuela-us.org/2014/08/06/venezuela-sending-16-tons-of-humanitarian-aid-to-the-gaza-strip/
https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/news/middle-east/13103-jordanian-aid-convoy-arrives-in-gaza
madokie
(51,076 posts)And that my friend is the difference.
calilama
(18 posts)The Palestinians walked away from the peace process or at least that's what President Clinton is on record saying....I'm sure you can find some anti Semitic piece of shit to twist that story as well...there will be peace between Israel and Palestine the moment the Palestinians recognize Israel's right to exist...just as Jordan and Egypt have done
How fucking complicated is this?
You say you plan on killing every Jew in Israel and you fire hundreds of missiles at civilian areas you deserve to get your ass kicked...if Hamas had ISIL's military skillset there would be 6,000,000 more dead Jews...
madokie
(51,076 posts)and I won't bother trying to clue you in either.
If you can't figure it out on your own there is nothing I can do to fix that.
Peace
Have a good evening.
Oh I forgot to remind you I'm none religious. don't believe in a supreme being or an after life. I like it this way too.
For a tip, according to the bible the Jews are Gods chosen people. LOL Thats why they get a pass on all this carnage.
oberliner
(58,724 posts)What does that mean exactly?
madokie
(51,076 posts)Not me. I don't believe in any of that crap.
oberliner
(58,724 posts)You must think it means something to them.
madokie
(51,076 posts)I speak truth on this subject. If you can't handle that I don't know what to tell you.
oberliner
(58,724 posts)Doesn't every religious person kind of view themselves that way?
riverwalker
(8,694 posts)seems most of the injuries documented are devastating head wounds. Snipers? #GazaUnderAttack
the photos are unforgettable
The girl in the wheelchair who could not escape the bomb haunts me. Her mutilated body covered with a blanket by her brother, to allow some dignity. Her wheelchair twisted and mangled. Him sitting next to her in shock and grief, he could not save her.
The little boy who lost both eyes, and both his parents. What lies ahead for him?
Marrah_G
(28,581 posts)KoKo
(84,711 posts)All day CNN is saying "Genocide in Iraq." Yet not a mention of GAZA.
Chathamization
(1,638 posts)onenote
(42,581 posts)It is estimated that there are between 600,000 and 700,000 Yazidi in the world. ISIS has already killed at least 500. There are approximately 40,000 that will die in the next few weeks if ISIS gets to them or they don't get aid. Moreover, ISIS has made it clear that they will kill any other Yazidis that they come across. In Gaza, 2000 of 1.8 million Palestinians (including some disputed number of combatants) have been killed in the current conflict with Israel. Another 2.5 million Palestinians in the West Bank and 1.5 million in Israel are not under assault. You can do the math. (And remember, you're the one that made it about numbers).
woo me with science
(32,139 posts)oberliner
(58,724 posts)People of DU please stop with this nonsense.
SammyWinstonJack
(44,129 posts)onenote
(42,581 posts)what's happening in Gaza. Or people who assume things about Gaza that aren't true. Or who simply use the term to further a political agenda.
Genocide has a specific definition in international law: any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:
(a) Killing members of the group;
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.
The "in part" aspect has been clarified in international law to mean a substantial portion of the group so as to threaten the viability of its continued existence.
What is happening in Gaza is horrible. But if one thinks that it is genocide, then one must think that what happens in virtually every armed conflict is genocide. One must think that the Germans were the victims of genocide when the British firebombed Dresden. That the British were the victims of genocide when the Germans bombed London. That the Japanese were the victims of genocide when the United States dropped atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Those actions killed tens if not hundreds of thousands of civilians and left enormous numbers of people homeless. But they weren't genocide.
As is the case in most areas that are locus of an armed conflict, Gaza is a horrible place to be. Even before the conflict, it was hardly paradise. But despite the blockade, which undoubtedly made conditions worse, it was not the hellhole some seem to assume it was.
Populations undergoing genocide don't grow. The population of Gaza has been growing, even during the blockade, at a rate far above the international average. Infant mortality in Gaza is half that of the international average and the birthrate is well above the average.
Populations undergoing genocide don't have positive growth in gross domestic product. WHile the blockade has set back economic development in the occupied territories, it has not stopped it cold. According to the official Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics, from 2008 to 2012, GDP in Gaza and the West Bank grew from 1.17 billion to 1.72 billion. During 2012, GDP in Gaza alone grew at a faster rate than GDP in the West Bank (6.6% v. 5.6%). GDP growth continued during 2013, but at a slower rate.
And this assumes that Gaza is somehow separate from the other occupied territories (West Bank and East Palestine). If Israel is pursuing a policy of genocide against Palestinians, it is hard to explain how it is that there is no armed conflict in West Bank. It is hard to explain how the 1.5 million Palestinian Arabs in Israel not only are not being killed but, in fact, can become Israeli citizens, can vote and elect representatives to the Israeli government (there are around a dozen Palestinian Arabs in the Knesset) or serve on the Israeli Supreme Court.
I know I will be accused of minimizing the horror that is currently Gaza. I recognize that it is horrible. I agree that it merits international condemnation. But the devastation rendered on the people in Dresden, London, Hiroshima, Nagasaki and untold other locations also was horrific. But they were not genocide. And neither is what is happening in Gaza.
elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)terrorize and kill Palestinians it's a coincidence rather than genocide?
onenote
(42,581 posts)Last edited Sat Aug 9, 2014, 04:28 PM - Edit history (1)
I've made it clear any number of times that the goal should be negotiations leading to the a two state solution. But those that label the armed conflict that is occurring in Gaza as "genocide" do so out of ignorance or in pursuit of whatever political agenda they are pursuing.
bahrbearian
(13,466 posts)Marrah_G
(28,581 posts)....By killing them. Freedom is death or death is freedom or some shit like that.
onenote
(42,581 posts)Sometimes the facts are inconvenient to a particular narrative, but it doesn't change the facts.
They get it from the US
http://news.yahoo.com/us-send-47m-humanitarian-aid-gaza-strip-205105077--politics.html
They get it from other countries.
http://www.aa.com.tr/en/gaza/369201--italy-sends-emergency-aid-to-war-torn-gaza
And they get it during cease fires that allow the safe distribution of this aid. In case you haven't noticed, ISIS isn't into cease fires.
Tierra_y_Libertad
(50,414 posts)And, give the killers more weapons to provide the "collateral damage", "unfortunate mistakes", and "precision bombing".
Boom Sound 416
(4,185 posts)woo me with science
(32,139 posts)The deep state is continuous.
Secret government is continuous.
The MIC is continuous.
Sheepshank
(12,504 posts)having trouble drawing a parallel between that and the conflict in Gaza?
Are they EXACTLY the same thing and should be treated in EXACTLY the same manner?
Shheeeesh, the one size fits all commentary is a huge, huge fail!
riseabove
(70 posts)If after bombing the crap out of people and sticking our nose in others peoples business didn't work first, as usual.
He said he would evacuate them, why not just do it, so we don't have to start bombing?
Sheepshank
(12,504 posts)Iraq asked for help, US has no agreements with Isis. The issues and terms are NOT the same. To pretend they are IS a huge fail.
FWIW, I'm not advocating for Israel I'm simply stating that actions in one part of the world is never an excuse for identical action in another. The merits of it's own situation must stand.
Are you suggesting USA must advance air strikes towards Israel?
woo me with science
(32,139 posts)Kicking again for a succinct and spot on post.
Unvanguard
(4,588 posts)And in terms of immediate risk to human life, just in cold, quantitative terms, at least an order of magnitude less serious than the threat posed by ISIS (and that's a conservative estimate).