General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsCreative writing teacher out of job because student writes of Jesus giving out marijuana to the sick
The administration said that the teacher was not fired, but she chose to resign rather than conduct her class "in a professional manner".
I would think there would be a wide range of what is considered "professional" in a creative writing class of all places. A student writes creatively of a topic that offends another student and their parents. She was targeted and harassed.
I found the news video at You Tube, the article is listed below it.
Creative writing teacher resigns after student writes about Jesus, pot
The assignment was to take a fairy tale or legend and rewrite it in modern times. One student changed the biblical story about Jesus handing out bread and fish to the poor to Jesus handing out marijuana to the sick.
I don't take any personal offense. It's not written for me. It's written for them. It's how they can express themselves, said Guarascio.
But according to the teacher, during peer review, one of the other students got highly offended by the story and told her parents. And then the teacher was put on administrative leave while the district investigated.
The teacher had one last message for her students.
If they have something to say, say it, Guarascio said. Not everyone's going to agree with you. But that doesn't make your point invalid or worthless. Tell your story.
Another article makes it clear that the teacher was said not to be conducting her class in a professional manner. That of course is ridiculous. It was a creative writing class. The student applied a present day problem and told how it might have been handled by Jesus.
Conservative Student Attacks Teacher Over Jesus Story, Teacher Resigns
Katrina Guarascio, a teacher at Cleveland High School in Rio Rancho, New Mexico, gave her class the assignment to rewrite a fairy tale or legend with a modern setting. One of her students, following instructions, rewrote a tale about Jesus, a central biblical figure, to have him handing out marijuana to the sick. During the subsequent peer review session, one of the students claimed to be so offended, she complained to her parents, who then filed a complaint to the school. Guarascio was subsequently placed on administrative leave pending investigation, despite not having violated any rules.
It was Kind of a slap in the face after years of hard work, Guarascio said to KOAT 7. The teacher had been working for the school for eight years at the time of the incident. Of the student who claimed offense, she said on Facebook that the student had been bragging to her classmates that she was going to get Guarascio fired. Now Guarascio has resigned amid being targeted and harassed.
In response, the school districts Communications Director Kim Vesely, declining to go on camera with KOAT7, released the following statement:
The teacher involved chose to resign rather than follow the school districts direction that classes be administered in a professional manner.
The teacher said that Kim Vesely was someone she had never met, and someone who had never even been in her classroom.
kentuck
(111,079 posts)...in my creative writing class. I don't see the problem?
KingCharlemagne
(7,908 posts)at the school who failed to uphold the principle of academic freedom.
NewDeal_Dem
(1,049 posts)bunch to begin with, but then, who was?
madfloridian
(88,117 posts)But now we are in cookie cutter format in education. We got there easily. Time to fight back if there is any time left to do so.
LeftyMom
(49,212 posts)because blood drinking isn't kosher.
I'm sure I could find the book somewhere and send it to the complaining kid's family if they really need something to be offended about.
madfloridian
(88,117 posts)School leaders tend to worry too much about what some parents gripe about. I once had several parents get together to complain about our 2nd grade Halloween bulletin boards. Luckily the principal nearly laughed them out of her office.
I would call that student creative in the way he applied present day problems to religion and its tenets.
bravenak
(34,648 posts)Sounds interesting.
LeftyMom
(49,212 posts)bravenak
(34,648 posts)Maybe alibris has it.
cer7711
(502 posts). . . intellectually, emotionally, spiritually.
As for the classroom informant who raised a ruckus: Has no one told him or her that (in the words of Orwell: close paraphrase) "living in a free society means that you may sometimes be exposed to ideas and art that offends you"?
A real-world lesson was indeed taught here. A very sad, pathetic one of corporatist compliance and necessary conformity to group-think, homogenizing self-expression and arbitrary authority.
surrealAmerican
(11,360 posts)... are not the sort who would teach their child that a free society is in any way desirable.
newfie11
(8,159 posts)Stupid is in, science is out, prejudice is in, freedom to form your own idea is out.
LWolf
(46,179 posts)buys the "bad teachers" propaganda promoted ad nauseum, it becomes easy to target teachers.
Even DUers love to post about bad teachers, and tend to ignore posts defending them. Outside of DU, it can get rabid.
I'm wondering where her union representation was; it should never have come to this.
madfloridian
(88,117 posts)and it gets pretty rabid here at DU also. Mostly it is just ignored, you are right.
It's like teachers are either not important or have become the ultimate bad guys.
villager
(26,001 posts)... in terms of promoting anything like a meaningful education for our kids (as noted elsewhere on this thread).
And increasingly, the good teachers are trapped in bad systems, and unable to be good teachers.
Which gives conscientious parents fewer and fewer meaningful choices about their own kids' educations...
LWolf
(46,179 posts)Administrators and districts are bound by the same mandates that limit teachers, and that's what drives the "bad" in the system. My principal yesterday said flat out that high-stakes testing demands constrict our time and resources for what our kids really need.
In my experience, the bigger and more bureaucratic, the farther away from the classroom and the student, a school district and its admins get, the more inefficient and less student friendly they get. Districts that hire business people instead of educators, people who have never actually BEEN on the front lines with students, to run things tend to be the worst. In my experience, of course.
Smarmie Doofus
(14,498 posts)>>>In my experience, the bigger and more bureaucratic, the farther away from the classroom and the student, a school district and its admins get, the more inefficient and less student friendly they get.>>>>
Not just your experience. It's demonstrably the case. And it works at every level in education: building admins, district admins, "coaches" , union brass, etc. And ultimately.... ugh!.... politicians who make ed law.
It may very well be just as true OUTSIDE of the ed world... I just don't have enough hands-on background there to say for sure.
LWolf
(46,179 posts)I know I'm not alone when I say that I still love working with my students; I still feel called to do so, but the rest? I hate it. Deeply. Viscerally.
A report from my local union, going into negotiations in a couple of months: more and more teachers, GOOD teachers, experienced teachers, are looking to leave the profession because they just don't want to be scapegoats any more.
MrMickeysMom
(20,453 posts)This is the bottom line
The administrator and district are spineless.
In reaction to the narrow-mindedness, you can expect a ministry of "professional" teaching methods, a la 1984.
chervilant
(8,267 posts)who berated me for teaching my 7th grade math students how to use a "magic square" to factor a quadratic. I also explained to the students why it worked, and how to write the formula for the quadratic. They LOVED it, and told me it really helped them understand that challenging concept.
The assistant principal told me their "brains are not formed enough to learn about quadratic equations."
(I just realized that this incident was likely the beginning of the end for me at that school, and my use of the word "uber" with the principal iced that cake.)
B Calm
(28,762 posts)madfloridian
(88,117 posts)that it wouldn't be worth her effort and stress. It would have been nice to see her stand her ground, but I can see why she wouldn't want to do so.
treestar
(82,383 posts)Why blame the teacher for what another student wrote? The teacher can't enforce religious norms in assignments.
el_bryanto
(11,804 posts)If a teacher had been suspended because a student had written a story in which Jesus visited, say, a drone facility to strike the fear of God into the evil Muslims, would everybody just change seats in this particular drama? I mean I am pretty sure our Republican friends would happily defend that kind of artistic expression - but would we decide to condemn it?
Bryant
RedCappedBandit
(5,514 posts)for what a student wrote, regardless.
GreatGazoo
(3,937 posts)http://www.vice.com/read/did-jesus-perform-his-miracles-with-cannabis-oil
deutsey
(20,166 posts)Yeah, that's just the kind of person we want to run out of our schools.
Here's a bio from a book of her poetry available on Amazon:
Katrina K Guarascio is a writer and teacher living in New Mexico. As an active member of the poetry community, she has worked as an editor for various literary magazines and small presses, along with hosting poetry workshops and producing various poetry performances, including The Second Saturday Slam, Rio Ranchos only monthly Poetry Slam and Open Mic.
Guarascio sponsors the Rio Rancho Youth Poetry Community, coaches a youth Slam Team, and produces a yearly literary magazine of student poetry.
http://www.amazon.com/Fall-Sparrow-Katrina-Guarascio-ebook/dp/B00OYB175I/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1418311476&sr=8-1&keywords=Katrina+Guarascio
edhopper
(33,570 posts)who believe God is the active ruler of the Universe, get so offended at any perceived slight of the omnipotent deity.
Is God that thin skinned, can't he defend himself.
villager
(26,001 posts)If one has faith in a traditionally-conceived God, does that always mean it/he takes offense as easily as an emotionally damaged 12 year old?
edhopper
(33,570 posts)have no problem with it.
It's people like the parents here who need to get a life and not worry about what others say about God.
villager
(26,001 posts)...wouldn't actually worth worshipping, in the first place -- because how "powerful" could they/it actually be? (Again, if one wanted to approach this in "traditional" terms...)
edhopper
(33,570 posts)says it.
HappyMe
(20,277 posts)Because 1 kid was "offended" this teacher was forced to resign! Freedom of speech is offensive to that girl and her family - oh wait, she was "bragging to her classmates that she was going to get Guarascio fired". Vindictive words from that shithead is also freedom of speech.
madfloridian
(88,117 posts)madfloridian
(88,117 posts)Katrina K Guarascio
December 9 at 6:53am ·
I think it is interesting that the reply from district (from a woman I have never met and has never been in my classroom) was that I refused to conduct my class in a professional manner, yet I was professional enough for them for the last 8 years. Once again showing how RRPS does not acknowledge their teachers' hard work and sacrifices. KOAT also didn't mention that this was a case that had been going on since October and that the student who complained actually boasted to her classmates about how she was "going to get her teacher fired." But overall, at least I don't look like a jackass...do I?
Taitertots
(7,745 posts)Sorry. But someone had to say it after hearing the exact same thing said about Muslims in the media echo chamber.
hunter
(38,310 posts)They'd rather stifle everyone with non-dangerous and therefore useless rote rules-are-rules "facts."
Truly educated and creative people are dangerous; they have a way of upsetting the established order of things.
Dull, fearful, uneducated, authority and scripture quoting law-and-order people are easier to manipulate.
Dont call me Shirley
(10,998 posts)The kids at CHS all loved their teacher, Katrina Guarascio.
Email or call
mailto:schoolboard@rrps.net
mailto:district@rrps.net
505-896-0668 District Office Kim Vesely, Communications
505-938-0300 V Sue Cleveland High
http://superintendent.rrps.net/modules/groups/integrated_home.phtml?&gid=2324946&SID=&t=&_ga=GA1.2.1868493761.1414869695&_gat=1
"Dr. Cleveland is a former state superintendent of the year and was one of four finalists considered for the AASA National Superintendent of the Year Award in 2004"
http://superintendent.rrps.net/modules/groups/integrated_home.phtml?&gid=2324946&SID=&t=&_ga=GA1.2.1868493761.1414869695&_gat=1
http://amarillo.com/stories/2000/10/10/usn_cheneyto.shtml
madfloridian
(88,117 posts)That Kim Vesely had her nerve to say she was not professional when she had never been in her classroom.
Dont call me Shirley
(10,998 posts)The district pretends to be so progressive, but they're not. They use the Rotten To The Core curriculum as well.
PS district office won't answer
gordianot
(15,237 posts)bluestateguy
(44,173 posts)and crybabies on the Left and Right are often prone to such thinking.
madfloridian
(88,117 posts)Been used way too much.
bluestateguy
(44,173 posts)I'm very much on the left myself. But I acknowledge that other people see the world differently, they will say things that I disagree with , and they should not be fired from their jobs for doing so.
alp227
(32,018 posts)Such as:
- opposing equal rights for people of color of LGBT's,
- denying the Holocaust,
- accusing immigrants of "disloyalty to the US" (whatever the frick that means),
- accusing Obama of being a "Manchurian candidate from Kenya",
- and stuff like that.
I would never want to associate with people who hold views like that, because such views are beyond mere disagreement.
chervilant
(8,267 posts)"...crybabies on the left and right." I can think of quite a few "crybabies" on the right, but I cannot come up with a "crybaby" on the left. Perhaps, you might help? Who is (are?) a "crybaby" on the left?
bluestateguy
(44,173 posts)I don't think she is bound by FERPA anymore (which is a stupid law, btw).
Blue_Tires
(55,445 posts)to out themselves everytime they try to dismantle an entire school system just because Ned Junior saw a woman's nipple in National Geographic...
winterwar
(210 posts)That's classic!
City Lights
(25,171 posts)Ugh. What year is it? I seem to have forgotten.
kydo
(2,679 posts)But to answer your question it is the year 2014. 98 years before 2112 but 32 years after Subdivisions was released.
Sorry I grew up as a Rush and Police fan. Always wanted to form a band and name it KGB.
Seriously though, sometimes with peoples mind sets these days it does feel more like 1914 then 2014.
City Lights
(25,171 posts)I'm a big Rush fan, too, so thanks for this!
Derek V
(532 posts)"Okay, your students reported you. But if you'll just report on the principal....."
winterwar
(210 posts)But they squel like pigs if they hear anything about Jesus that they might not like. Freedom of speech means nothing to them.
merrily
(45,251 posts)madfloridian
(88,117 posts)Did you see the BBC article gordianot linked above?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/2633187.stm
Interesting ideas.
merrily
(45,251 posts)(To people on all sides of the "Even a non-divine Jesus never existed" issue, please lighten up.)
JEB
(4,748 posts)chade
(103 posts)If they have something to say, say it, Guarascio said. Not everyone's going to agree with you. But that doesn't make your point invalid or worthless. Tell your story.
Even on her way out the door, she uses her situation as a teachable moment for her students! It's a good thing this district took out this terrible teacher.