General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsAbolish the Police. Instead, Let’s Have Full Social, Economic, and Political Equality.
Abolish the Police. Instead, Lets Have Full Social, Economic, and Political Equality.
Mychal Denzel Smith on April 9, 2015 - 4:10 PM ET
............
We dont consider the abolition of police a viable position to take because we believe theyre the only thing standing between upstanding citizens and the violence of the deranged. Were afraid of being attacked on the street, of having our homes shot at, and being left without access to equally violent retribution. But does this mean we want police, or safety and security? Safety and security are ideas, ones that may never be fully achieved, and the police are an institution that have proved themselves capable of only providing the illusion of safety and security to a select few. The bulk of their jobs has nothing to do with violence prevention. They spend most of their time doing things like Slager did in his initial contact with Scottstopping people for broken taillights. Writing for Gawker, David Graeber of the London School of Economics says:
The police, then, are essentially just bureaucrats with weapons. Their main role in society is to bring the threat of physical forceeven, deathinto situations where it would never have been otherwise invoked, such as the enforcement of civic ordinances about the sale of untaxed cigarettes.
http://gawker.com/ferguson-and-the-criminalization-of-american-life-1692392051
Ninety percent of an officers time isnt devoted to our safety, but rather to things we may find annoying (or in the case of things like untaxed cigarettes, create a black market for goods that threaten the profits of businesses), inserting the potential for violence where there is cause for none. And when it comes to preventing heinous acts of violence (or holding the perpetrators accountable) that should be condemned by all, like domestic violence and sexual assault, the police are largely ineffectual. The police are not performing the function we say they are, and there are real ways to achieve a world with less violence that dont include the police. We simply havent tried. Until we invest in full employment, universal healthcare that includes mental health services, free education at every level, comprehensive sex education that teaches about consent and bodily autonomy, the decriminalization of drugs and erasure of the stigma around drug use, affordable and adequate housing, eliminating homophobia and transphobiathings that actually reduce the amount of violence we witnessI dont want to hear about how necessary the police are. They are only necessary because we are all too willing to hide behind our cowardice and not actually put forth the effort to create a better world. Its too extreme.
When I say, abolish the police, Im usually asked what I would have us replace them with. My answer is always full social, economic, and political equality, but thats not whats actually being asked. What people mean is who is going to protect us? Who protects us now? If youre white and well-off, perhaps the police protect you. The rest of us, not so much. What use do I have for an institution that routinely kills people who look like me, and make it so Im afraid to walk out of my home?
....................
MORE:
http://www.thenation.com/blog/203873/abolish-police-instead-lets-have-full-social-economic-and-political-equality#
Trillo
(9,154 posts)The staring is aggressive behavior, and it's possible they were actively scoping you for a shakedown. Curiously, by staring, they also change your behavior, though that type of aggression is preferable to being shot in the back as you went for ice cream. It kinda sucks that you consider it good luck to be making it to the grocer alive. It would be even luckier to not be stared at while going about your business, or perhaps finding $100 bill just inside your front door, some anonymous benefactor having shoved it under your door.
One people working together for a common goal. Protecting eachother and taking care of eachother.
We have lost our community our connection most people dont even speak to their neighbors or trust their neighbors. But that is due to the fear they feed us. But is the fear without cause?
Daily we hear of another violent crime, murder rape molestation leads the headlines. We live with a Government that murders people around the world and here at home. How can a people know that murder is wrong when our leaders are doing the same thing?
And it is all because we have lost our community and communism and commune have become bad words or a joke.
We do need police to investigate crime and arrest the truly bad guys. The rapist the serial killer. I see nothing with a group of citizens being paid to drive around and stand gaurd for their fellow citizens.
What we need to do is end the war mentality. War on gangs war on drugs war on crime. Its time to declare peace. And bring back the peace officer. Whose job is to ensure peace safety and security for all citizens equally. And to approach every citizen with the upmost respect and love in their hearts. Even the safety of the suspect who is innocent until proven guilty should be their number one priority.
Historic NY
(37,449 posts)its the lawyers who think they are politicians that craft them or vice versa. Its been like that since this country was founded. The problem is people, politicians and communities want the police to be something they are not _______________ fill in the blank. Have trouble with your neighbor call the cops, have trouble with your kid call the cops, loud music call the cops.....its goes on and on.
Unfortunately the OP is just looking at Ferguson, as an example.
PotatoChip
(3,186 posts)I'm surprised that this article got so little attention. I think it raised some interesting points.