General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhy Charter Thinks Their Plan To Buy TWC Is Different Enough To Succeed Where Comcast Failed
Condumerist
Why Charter Thinks Their Plan To Buy TWC Is Different Enough To Succeed Where Comcast Failed
After months of rumors, this morning it became official: Charter plans to step in where Comcast failed, with a $55 billion plan to acquire Time Warner Cable. Regulators looked unfavorably on Comcasts bid, finding it would have too many negative effects on consumers and on competition. But Charter clearly would not be trying its own takeover, with such a huge price tag, if they didnt think they stood a good chance of success. So what makes the second offer so different from the first and is it any more likely to succeed?
Charter CEO Tom Rutledge said in a call this morning, Were a very different company than Comcast, and this is a very different transaction, which is true.
Different, of course, does not necessarily mean better. Advocacy group Free Press, for example, has already released a statement saying that the Charter/TWC deal raises similar public interest concerns to the failed Comcast purchase, and adding, Charter will have a tough time making a credible argument that consolidating local monopoly power on a nationwide basis will benefit consumers.
But a few big differences, in this case, might just add up to acceptable in the eyes of the FCC and Department of Justice.
The Comcast Counterweight
To understand where the cable industry is going, one first needs to understand where it is right now. In business, size matters. As of their latest earnings reports (except for Cox, which is privately held), heres where the landscape lies today:
Comcast: 22.3 million customers
Time Warner Cable: 11.9 million customers
Cox: about 6 million customers
Charter: 5.9 million customers
Cablevision: 3.1 million customers
Bright House: 2.5 million customers
Had Comcast and Time Warner Cable merged and completed their three-way customer handoff, new-Comcast would have remained the industry leader with 30 million customers and Charter, through GreatLand, would have picked up an extra 2.5 million.
But of course, that didnt happen. This merger, however, might. Charters arithmetic, which includes business customers, says that the transaction will give the new Charter a combined 23.9 million customers in 41 states.
Even using the residential customer numbers above, however, the combined company would easily have over 20 million customers. And either way you shake it, that puts them right in a competitive 1-2 situation with our existing dominant player, Comcast. If the TWC and Bright House acquisitions go through without spin-offs or concessions, that would make the new cable landscape look like this:
New Charter: 24 million customers
Comcast: 22 million customers
Cox: about 6 million customers
Cablevision: 3 million customers
Charters reasons for wanting to spend a ludicrous amount of money on this deal, then, are pretty clear cut. The new company would vault from the middle of the pack to the head, suddenly becoming a force to contend with. The only company larger would be the still-pending merged AT&T/DirecTV and they would exceed Charter in video customers, but not broadband ones.
Where size was an obstacle for Comcast when it came to wooing regulators, for Charter it may prove to be an asset. Comcast was (and is) already the largest cable company in the nation. Buying the second-largest would have vaulted it so far ahead that the also-rans couldnt be considered actual competition, and would have given it undue influence up and down the business chain, as well as over customers.
But the second, fourth, and sixth largest companies, joining together to form a company about the same size as the current number one? Well, thats a different matter. The FCC and DoJ might determine that although end consumers would be losing options, as far as the national-scale marketplace goes, creating a counterweight to Comcast may in some ways actually increase competitive pressures. Starting a new competitor from scratch is not going to happen but building one from a handful of smaller companies might succeed.
Vertical Integration and Bad Behavior
Its not just in the arithmetic where Charter benefits heavily from not being Comcast.
Much More
http://wp.me/p2L7Ik-GOZt