General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsObama On JP Morgan: ‘This Is Why We Passed Wall Street Reform’
President Obama told the hosts of a pre-taped episode of ABCs The View that the JP Morgan trade fiasco exemplified the reason why he pushed for Wall Street reform, according to ABC News:
Watch below:
http://livewire.talkingpointsmemo.com/entries/obama-on-jp-morgan-this-is-why-we
Occupy the SEC agrees.
Dear Sirs and Madam:
Occupy the SEC1 submits this comment letter in response to the above-mentioned regulatory agencies (Agencies) notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPR, Proposed Rule)2 implementing Section 619 of the Dodd-Frank Act (the Act).3
<...>
The United States aspires to democracy, but no true democracy is attainable when the process is determined by economic power.4 Accordingly, Occupy the SEC is delighted to participate in the public comment process for the implementation of Section 619 of the Dodd-Frank Act by the SEC, Federal Reserve, OCC and FDIC (.the Agencies.). This country.s governing principles of transparency and due process mandate that any rules implemented by our regulators comport with the democratically-elected legislature.s intention to protect the people from the widespread banking abuses and excesses of the recent past. We believe the Volcker Rule is important to the future of the banking industry and, if strongly enforced, will help move our financial system in a more fair, transparent, and sustainable direction. Prohibiting banking entities from engaging in proprietary trading and banning their sponsorship of covered funds are key elements to regulating the financial system and giving force to the Dodd-Frank Act. At its core, the Volcker Rule seeks to make sure that if a banking entity fails, it does not bring down the whole system with it. We appreciate the momentous challenges that the Agencies continue to face in effectively implementing the Rule, and we present these comments to assist them in their task.
- more -
http://www.occupythesec.org/letter/OSEC%20-%20OCC-2011-14%20-%20Comment%20Letter.pdf
Posted by Suzy Khimm
NEW YORK Occupy Wall Street has moved. Its new address: 60 Wall Street.
<...>
Kline, a former Wall Street trader-turned-Occupier, is a member of Occupy the SEC, an offshoot of the large movement that has burrowed deep into the regulatory process. At this moment, shes trying to figure out if the drafting of the Volcker Rule a provision of President Obamas Wall Street overhaul that would restrict commercial banks from making speculative investments that do not benefit their customers is tight enough to keep banks in check.
After much discussion, the group agreed that the Volcker Rules earlier definition of clearing agencies, which banks use for exchanging futures contracts, was clear and tough and good, but decided that it was worth double-checking section 17(a) of questions that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission raised about it.
<...>
While the Dodd-Frank act of 2010 provides a blueprint for the new regulations on Wall Street, its up to federal regulators to determine precisely how these guidelines will be put into effect. The regulatory process is intended to provide transparency into this process: Regulators will typically issue a preliminary version of a new rule and then allow for outside feedback during a public comment period.
Anyone is allowed to weigh in. But industry groups, lawyers and lobbyists issue an overwhelming number of formal comment letters to regulators, as they tend to have the most money, resources and technical expertise...Occupy the SEC aims to be a counterweight to this deep-pocketed lobbying push. Over the past six months, the Occupiers have slogged through the 300-plus pages of the Volcker Rule to figure out how the regulation would work in practice and whether it would or could come anywhere close to what its authors had intended.
- more -
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/ezra-klein/post/occupy-the-regulatory-system/2012/04/27/gIQAjo21lT_blog.html
applegrove
(118,600 posts)Enrique
(27,461 posts)i like the View, but I am not confident in their willingness to follow up on that odd vote of confidence in JP Morgan and Jamie Dimon. Also, to ask the necessary question, Dodd Frank DID pass, so why did this happen?
Luminous Animal
(27,310 posts)Oh and Jamie Dimon (who does NOT want the Volcker Rule to pass, has also claimed that, even if the Volcker Rule had been implemented, it would not have been applicable in this situation.
Enrique
(27,461 posts)and hedges are allowed under the Volcker Rule. Do you think they will be getting into this on the View? I hope so, they ought to. We'll see.
KoKo
(84,711 posts)Your Quote from President Obama:
JPMorgan is one of the best managed banks there is. Jamie Dimon, the head of it, is one of the smartest bankers we got and they still lost $2 billion and counting, the president said. We dont know all the details. Its going to be investigated but this is why we passed Wall street Reform.
Icicle
(121 posts)My translation of that is:
"they're one of the best, and yet they STILL screwed the pooch. That's why we need to regulate them."
grasswire
(50,130 posts)I hope that was not a "non-statement statement" from Obama. It could mean anything.
boxman15
(1,033 posts)Dyedinthewoolliberal
(15,563 posts)to show he's not out to get them. Maybe he is, maybe he isn't, but he's not tipping his hand......
girl gone mad
(20,634 posts)JP Morgan was not and would not have been in violation of Dodd-Frank.
This is why our government received so much criticism from informed commentators for taking this foolish approach of enacting feel-good legislation rather than doing what will ultimately be necessary.
How many times have I warned you over the years that Dodd-Frank would do nothing to prevent the next crisis? Even if it ever gets fully implemented, it will be ineffective.
Good that milquetoasts like Klein have been forced to write on this topic since its become such a glaring clusterfuck of fail, but bad that they still pretend a little tweak here or there will make everything okay.
ProSense
(116,464 posts)"You should actually read what Occupy the SEC wrote."
...I understand clearly what "loophole" means. Do you? A loophole can be closed. The key point is that the law made significant changes, but some issues still need to be addressed. Some of these issues can be addressed in the rule-making process. The focus of group's letter is to strengthen the rule.
Washington, DC- Oregons Senator Jeff Merkley, cosponsor of the Merkley-Levin provision in Dodd-Frank that put into law the Volcker Rule, issued the following statement after news that J.P. Morgan lost at least $2 billion in portfolio hedging trades made by their risk management division.
Moreover, it is essential that bank regulators issue rules that do not permit hedge fund investments by Wall Street banks to be disguised as market making or risk mitigation, as this case so dramatically demonstrates.
"I ask, once again, that regulators implement without delay a Volcker Rule as intended by Congress, with a clear, effective firewall between hedge fund-like trading and traditional banking.
"American families and businesses should not be subsidizing these types of risks or victimized by these types of losses. We need a wholesale change of culture at our banks and at our regulatory agencies, which is precisely what the Volcker Rule firewall is intended to create."
http://www.merkley.senate.gov/newsroom/press/release/?id=14790A0A-6018-4331-AF15-7D8B842C9CF8
"How many times have I warned you over the years that Dodd-Frank would do nothing to prevent the next crisis? Even if it ever gets fully implemented, it will be ineffective."
You've warned me? Are you serious?
gratuitous
(82,849 posts)Some reform.
I hope we "reform" things again with another meaningless round of toothless feel-good laws and leave all the same robber barons (unpunished) in place to do it again. That'll teach someone somewhere a lesson, fer sure.
PoliticAverse
(26,366 posts)ProSense
(116,464 posts)"It illustrates why the passed 'reform' was a sham."
...it should be repealed before it's fully implemented, and replaced with something that can be slammed before it's fully implemented. That'll show Wall Street.