Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

applegrove

(118,622 posts)
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 06:43 PM Feb 2017

Why Melissa McCarthy Had to Play Sean Spicer

by Anna North at the NY Times

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/06/opinion/why-melissa-mccarthy-had-to-play-sean-spicer.html?_r=0

SNIP.........

“Saturday Night Live,” too, has long put its male players in female drag, sometimes just for laughs and sometimes because it simply had too few female cast members to play all the necessary female roles. In 2013, Kenan Thompson announced he would no longer perform in a dress, tired of being the show’s go-to choice to play black female celebrities from Oprah Winfrey to Maya Angelou. The show subsequently hired two black female cast members, Sasheer Zamata and Leslie Jones. But it continues to put men in dresses — Fred Armisen’s character Regine, a mean, sexually demonstrative girlfriend, cropped up most recently in 2016.

As Mr. Spicer, meanwhile, Ms. McCarthy makes cross-dressing almost beside the point. She wears a fairly convincing wig, and her ill-fitting suit feels more like a joke about the poor tailoring that plagues the president and his administration than about the incongruity of a woman in male garb.

Ms. McCarthy isn’t funny as Mr. Spicer because she’s a woman, she’s funny as Mr. Spicer because she’s made a career of playing aggressive characters who are often angry for no reason. As Megan, in “Bridesmaids,” she broke new ground as a tough, crude woman with bizarre ideas and no boundaries who nonetheless finds romantic fulfillment, and in subsequent films like “The Heat,” she’s established herself as a powerful physical comedian whose best weapon is her snarl. On “S.N.L,” as she lifts up her podium to attack the press corps, it’s clear she was born to play the mouthpiece of an administration already defined by outbursts of rage.

While her gender isn’t the center of her performance, it matters. There’s a bit of an extra bite in a woman lampooning the spokesperson of a president who once bragged about grabbing women’s genitals, and who was reportedly moved to rage last month when attendance at women’s protests around the world dwarfed attendance at his inauguration. Add to that the fact that President Trump reportedly wants his female staffers to “dress like women,” and Melissa McCarthy dressing like a man to play his press secretary feels like a particularly astute way to needle the White House.


............SNIP

44 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Why Melissa McCarthy Had to Play Sean Spicer (Original Post) applegrove Feb 2017 OP
SNL needs Rosie O'Donnell to play president Bannon Achilleaze Feb 2017 #1
Hell yeah! tazkcmo Feb 2017 #6
Perhaps GeoWilliam750 Feb 2017 #29
I think she's lost too much weight BainsBane Feb 2017 #16
Yes! eom LittleGirl Feb 2017 #38
oh yes! Rosie is Bannon! flying_wahini Feb 2017 #20
She would play the part of The Donald's brain. Stellar Feb 2017 #23
Oh MAN that'd be great! calimary Feb 2017 #25
Tweeted this to SNL earlier today - we'll see. blm Feb 2017 #28
her ill-fitting suit feels more like a joke about the poor tailoring that plagues the president and Angry Dragon Feb 2017 #2
And I bet they're made in China, too. calimary Feb 2017 #19
All Trump clothes are made overseas except the neck ties is what I have heard Angry Dragon Feb 2017 #22
I'm no expert here. What I think back to is a David Letterman bit when trump was a guest. calimary Feb 2017 #24
I do know Ivanka's stuff is made overseas Angry Dragon Feb 2017 #26
McCarthy was tremendous in the role of Spicer True Dough Feb 2017 #3
Brilliant on every level - casting, writing, performing and on and on EOM elfin Feb 2017 #4
"its clear she was born to play the mouthpiece of an administration already defined . . . . . Stinky The Clown Feb 2017 #5
Melissa did an excellent job.. thank you, applegrove Cha Feb 2017 #7
Who can look at Spicer now and not see Moose and Lambs? deminks Feb 2017 #8
I think that was my favorite part of the skit justiceischeap Feb 2017 #33
I have always enjoyed Melissa McCarthy. Solly Mack Feb 2017 #9
She was flawless. TNNurse Feb 2017 #10
I thought she was outstanding. NBachers Feb 2017 #11
Am still laughing at how great she did.....SHE LOOKS LIKE HIM TOO....eom a kennedy Feb 2017 #12
I think my abs are still sore from laughing Maru Kitteh Feb 2017 #13
I just saw your "Twitler" image and started laughing hard, too. That's great! manicraven Feb 2017 #17
Beautiful take-down of Spicer by McCarthy Paladin Feb 2017 #14
I think I will now and forever see Melissa McCarthy when angry Spicer appears for a Press briefing Pachamama Feb 2017 #18
And let us not omit the quite excellent Leslie Jones turn this week, as Samuel L. Jackson... Drum Feb 2017 #15
She nailed it. Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #21
Tina Fey said they often preferred men in drag to giving a woman a woman's role.... bettyellen Feb 2017 #27
Wow, Gilda was the best of all SNLers, IMO. And Jane Curtin a close second. JudyM Feb 2017 #30
Yeah, Fey's book Bossy Pants is an interesting and funny read... bettyellen Feb 2017 #31
That's a losing proposition for SNL IMO justiceischeap Feb 2017 #34
Past decade is post Fey's influence- thank her for the change! bettyellen Feb 2017 #35
Meryl Streep already played Trump brilliantly Justice Feb 2017 #32
McCarthy was brilliant! Watching again. (Can't actually stand to watch the real thing) FailureToCommunicate Feb 2017 #36
just finished watching the latest SNL... MontanaMama Feb 2017 #37
Great suggestion, him dominating Baldwin's Donald would be an excellent visual bigbrother05 Feb 2017 #39
I can see him with a bottle in hand Ligyron Feb 2017 #44
She was excellent in the role, and good for Kenan for refusing to play women IronLionZion Feb 2017 #40
I think that the last push was when they had Kerry Washington question everything Feb 2017 #43
"President Trump was most bothered by the fact that Spicer was portrayed by a woman" IronLionZion Feb 2017 #41
I remember when Phil Hartman would play Barbara Bush ailsagirl Feb 2017 #42

Achilleaze

(15,543 posts)
1. SNL needs Rosie O'Donnell to play president Bannon
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 06:50 PM
Feb 2017

as other DUers have already suggested. That would be excellent!

Angry Dragon

(36,693 posts)
2. her ill-fitting suit feels more like a joke about the poor tailoring that plagues the president and
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 06:51 PM
Feb 2017

his administration


They all must be wearing Trump suits
Trumps sells to them at cost plus 25%

calimary

(81,220 posts)
19. And I bet they're made in China, too.
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 08:01 PM
Feb 2017

How 'bout those neckties? All this talk about making other countries move jobs back home - charity begins at HOME, Donald. Don't go getting all high 'n' mighty on us, on how many jobs you're relocating here because you're bullying companies, while you get your ties made for cheap in China. You, too, pal. "Move it back here" means YOU, too.

calimary

(81,220 posts)
24. I'm no expert here. What I think back to is a David Letterman bit when trump was a guest.
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 08:26 PM
Feb 2017

Letterman commented on his ties, which trump proceeded to talk up as to how wonderful and high-quality they were. Letterman turned one over and on the underside was the embroidered label with "Made in China." Maybe he's changed between then and now. That was awhile ago - when David Letterman still had his late night show on CBS - the slot Colbert has now.

But there you are. I'm basing it on something I saw on reality TV. Which certainly verifies that I'm no expert!

Stinky The Clown

(67,790 posts)
5. "its clear she was born to play the mouthpiece of an administration already defined . . . . .
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 07:10 PM
Feb 2017

. . . . . . by outbursts of rage."

Amen!

Pussy Power!

justiceischeap

(14,040 posts)
33. I think that was my favorite part of the skit
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 10:28 PM
Feb 2017

I will admit I've not seen a single Spicer press conference but I hear she hit it out of the park.

Maru Kitteh

(28,339 posts)
13. I think my abs are still sore from laughing
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 07:27 PM
Feb 2017

Thought I might choke or pass out from lack of oxygen I was laughing so hard.

Best. Skit. Ever.

Paladin

(28,252 posts)
14. Beautiful take-down of Spicer by McCarthy
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 07:27 PM
Feb 2017

Possibly lethal---I can't imagine anybody taking Spicer seriously, now.

Pachamama

(16,887 posts)
18. I think I will now and forever see Melissa McCarthy when angry Spicer appears for a Press briefing
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 07:57 PM
Feb 2017

I never took Spicer seriously - but this brings it to a whole new level of ridicule...

I hope she will return again in future to do an impersonation of Spicer...Just like Alec Baldwin imitating Trump and his Anus Mouth, Melissa McCarthy was brilliant in her imitating the sheer disgust and venom that comes out of Spicer when talking to the Press and American people...

Drum

(9,154 posts)
15. And let us not omit the quite excellent Leslie Jones turn this week, as Samuel L. Jackson...
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 07:35 PM
Feb 2017

...in addition to Kate McKinnon's Bieber and the million other doppelgangers she personifies.

I immediately cheered Kenan's decision as a conscientious objector's line in the sand...though as a fan of "Monty Python" and "Kids in the Hall" I do appreciate the huge range of these actors!

 

bettyellen

(47,209 posts)
27. Tina Fey said they often preferred men in drag to giving a woman a woman's role....
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 08:47 PM
Feb 2017

Even when the woman did a much better version of the character. Said it was an ongoing struggle with the directors writers and Lorne. They felt like "no one wanted to watch" two women- when talking about Gilda and Lorraine of all people.

justiceischeap

(14,040 posts)
34. That's a losing proposition for SNL IMO
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 10:29 PM
Feb 2017

In the past decade the biggest SNL breakout stars have been the women.

MontanaMama

(23,307 posts)
37. just finished watching the latest SNL...
Tue Feb 7, 2017, 12:49 AM
Feb 2017

Got a much needed laugh! Melissa McCarthy was off the hook! I hope she returns as the little Banty Rooster, Sean Spicer...she was golden!!

My suggestion to SNL would be to stop portraying Bannon as the grim reaper. He WANTS to be portrayed that way. This is a guy who compared himself to Dick Cheney, Satan and Darth Vader!!! He has an over inflated ego.

Have Bobby Moynihan dress up as a drunken turd. THAT would be a a perfect Bannon...

a sloppy has been drunken turd. 💩

bigbrother05

(5,995 posts)
39. Great suggestion, him dominating Baldwin's Donald would be an excellent visual
Tue Feb 7, 2017, 09:22 AM
Feb 2017

Seeing a version of Bobby's drunk uncle pushing this so called president around would really grind his gears

Ligyron

(7,627 posts)
44. I can see him with a bottle in hand
Tue Feb 7, 2017, 01:34 PM
Feb 2017

constantly taking swigs out of it while stumbling about. This would enrage Bannon and perhaps he'd order Trump to do something particularly obnoxious.

At some point Trump's lunacy may actually prove too much for the GrOPers.

IronLionZion

(45,427 posts)
40. She was excellent in the role, and good for Kenan for refusing to play women
Tue Feb 7, 2017, 10:27 AM
Feb 2017

and getting them to hire two black women

My favorite SNLer is Kate McKinnon

question everything

(47,470 posts)
43. I think that the last push was when they had Kerry Washington
Tue Feb 7, 2017, 11:59 AM
Feb 2017

who was running back and forth playing several black characters and I think that she was the one who wondered about the lack of a black cast member.

IronLionZion

(45,427 posts)
41. "President Trump was most bothered by the fact that Spicer was portrayed by a woman"
Tue Feb 7, 2017, 10:40 AM
Feb 2017
http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/white-house-unhappy-with-snls-spicer-sketch-report/ar-AAmGmFb?li=BBmkt5R&ocid=spartanntp



The "Saturday Night Live" spoof of White House press secretary Sean Spicer hit a nerve with the White House spokesman and President Trump, according to a new report.

"Trump doesn't like his people to look weak," a top Trump donor told Politico two days after Melissa McCarthy portrayed an aggressive Spicer firing insults at journalists, chowing down on gum and busting out a super soaker during a press breifing.

But President Trump was most bothered by the fact that Spicer was portrayed by a woman, according to the Politico report.
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Why Melissa McCarthy Had ...