General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThinking about renting a room out through AirBnB? Read this:
http://www.twincities.com/2017/09/26/airbnb-guest-tried-to-rape-7-year-old-in-minnetonka-charges-say/Airbnb guest allegedly assaulted young girl in Minnetonka home where he was staying
A 28-year-old Michigan man has been charged with criminal sexual conduct after authorities say he tried to assault a 7-year-old girl in the Minnetonka house where he was staying as an Airbnb guest.
Derrick Aaron Kinchen, who was in town for a wedding, has been charged with second-degree criminal sexual conduct of a victim younger than 13, according to the Hennepin County attorneys office, which announced the charges Tuesday afternoon. The alleged incident happened early Sunday morning.
Kinchen, 28, of Lansing, Mich. has been charged with criminal sexual conduct after authorities say he tried to assault a 7-year-old girl in the Minnetonka house where he was staying as an Airbnb guest. Kinchen, who was in town for a wedding, has been charged with second-degree criminal sexual conduct of a victim younger than 13, according to the Hennepin County attorneys office, which announced the charges Tuesday, Sept. 26, 2017. The alleged incident happened early Sunday morning.
About 15 minutes after Kinchen arrived home, the father walked into the parents bedroom. The lights were on, and Kinchen was lying in the bed, naked, next to his daughter, her nightgown pulled up. The father yelled at Kinchen, who grabbed his suit coat and wallet and fled.
This led the news this morning here in the Twin Cities. More at the link...
ProfessorGAC
(64,995 posts)Glad dad walked in when he did. Hope that he caught that guy before anything even worse occurred.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)That whole thing always sounded risky to me. I just wouldn't do it.
cwydro
(51,308 posts)For so many reasons.
GeorgeGist
(25,319 posts)MineralMan
(146,286 posts)Response to MineralMan (Reply #6)
Name removed Message auto-removed
uppityperson
(115,677 posts)MineralMan
(146,286 posts)and then used that opportunity to misread what I said entirely? I find that strange, somehow.
Your screen name seems to be appropriate, though.
Response to MineralMan (Reply #78)
Name removed Message auto-removed
greatauntoftriplets
(175,731 posts)MineralMan
(146,286 posts)Thanks, MIRT!
greatauntoftriplets
(175,731 posts)MineralMan
(146,286 posts)she was there.
greatauntoftriplets
(175,731 posts)treestar
(82,383 posts)Coventina
(27,101 posts)For so many reasons....
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)I'd rather stay in a cheap motel and would never rent a room to anyone I didn't know. I suppose it's a way to make a buck off a spare room, but what a risk.
Coventina
(27,101 posts)authorities.
And, yeah, strangers in my home?
Not a chance.
cwydro
(51,308 posts)A risk I'd never take.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)All risk is relative.
You can say "what a risk", but what do you estimate that risk to be?
For example, would you say that the "risk of physical injury from renting out a room on AirBnB" is greater or less than the risk of physical injury from climbing a flight of stairs?
Why, or why not?
You have an anecdote. Lots of folks have anecdotes about lots of things.
Certainly there is "a risk", but what is it? Absent an answer to that question, then how can one gauge the risk relative to anything else?
Orrex
(63,200 posts)Well played!
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)I would not rent a room to a stranger under any circumstances. As for going up and down stairs, I do that about 20 times a day, since my office is in my basement. Is there a risk in doing that? To be sure, but that risk is lessened by my care in doing so.
If I rent a room to strangers, I have little control over what the stranger does while in my home.
I cannot give you the odds, however. I merely posted a story with a link. However, I can tell you that the probability is roughly zero of such an incident happening if no room is rented to a stranger.
Major Nikon
(36,827 posts)Your odds of getting a TBI drop dramatically from 1:2,000,000 to 1:25,000,045.
Why would anyone not want to dramatically decrease their odds of such disastrous consequences?
Voltaire2
(13,008 posts)I feel much safer now.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)right now, before I go back up the stairs.
politicaljunkie41910
(3,335 posts)While I would never personally rent a room in a stranger's house, nor would I invite paying strangers into mine, I know several young women my daughter's age (36) who have used AirBnB and have no problems with it. That generation assumes many risks my generation would not have. (FTR, I'm 59). That doesn't make them bad people, just huge risk takers. I will pass this information on to them, because they also don't read the newspapers much, nor do they read DU.
I realize that others here might be willing to assume risks I wouldn't and that's their prerogative. I just happen to be of the belief that I never want to purposely put a child of mine at risk. I'm sure that father is questioning that decision to rent a room to a stranger. It would appear to me that if he had to put his 7 year old daughter in his bed where he and his wife sleep, than he had no 'spare' room. And if someone else interprets that move in a different way (i.e. that he did have a 'spare' room but perhaps he moved his daughter to be closer to her parents in the house), than it sounds like his child's safety was a concern of his, and he took a gamble and lost.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)Also in my 50's.
Things "my generation" did:
1. Smoked at a much higher rate.
2. Went out unsupervised as kids to play without our parents knowing specifically where we were.
3. Rode bikes without helmets.
4. Hitchhiked.
5. Chafed at seat belts, let alone airbags.
I could go on at length of the common risks which have been greatly reduced.
On #2 in particular, I've heard people say "Oh, there weren't as many child molesters." That's simply not true. It wasn't reported as much, and people didn't/couldn't talk about it.
That's why the Catholic Church could get away with a whole lot more child molestation going on for decades than will ever occur in AirBNB.
There is also an effect caused by the internet, that things which would only have been known to a small circle of people are distributed far and wide.
If a schoolteacher or administrator in Podunk made some stupid decision or did some stupid thing, it would be known to the parties in Podunk. Now, any dumb decision made by a teacher or administrator is fodder for the regular stream of internet outrage and public comment.
cwydro
(51,308 posts)We lived at the top of a hill.
I'd fly down the road and stop when I hit the grass at the end. (Dead end road). Usually a tumble ensued.
Of course, there were no helmets then.
Every time I asked mom about this as an adult, she collapsed into giggles.
Sigh, the good old days.
brush
(53,764 posts)to take it.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)brush
(53,764 posts)jberryhill
(62,444 posts)brush
(53,764 posts)Hassin Bin Sober
(26,324 posts)There were Jamaican gangs targeting the hotels and my sister was a witness one of their crimes. She ended up having to go in to hiding and quit the job when a detective warned them the gang was asking around about her.
People who think they are safer staying at a hotel have another think coming.
Hotels are where the thieves do their best business.
We just came back from a road trip. We stayed in a hotel off the highway. When I grabbed the suitcase my partner said "don't bother we are just going to catch some sleep and get back on the road"
No fuckin' way. Hotel parking lots and rest stops are the worst.
I had to remind my partner his sister got pick pocketed last year in a Vegas hotel before she even checked in. She stopped at the slots and got $1000 dollars lifted before she was able to put it in a safe.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)Yeah, I told my wife the same thing when it happened to me.
Hassin Bin Sober
(26,324 posts)They caught the woman. The District Attorney was going to pay air fare for my sister in law to come back to testify. I don't know what she could have testified to since I don't think she knew what hit her until surveillance tapes were checked. She ended up not having to go back.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)jberryhill
(62,444 posts)Having your children's uncle stay over at your house is statistically a much greater risk.
Most children are molested by someone known to the family.
Would you seriously have your child's teenage cousin (your brother's kid, say) sleep over at your house with your seven year old around?
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)I do know everyone in my family. I have no children, so the issue never came up. But neither of the people who would have been that child's uncle or teenaged cousin have any such proclivities. I know them well. So, yes, I'd have them sleep at my house, since I know them and their character. We're a close family.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)Because they "know their character"....
http://www.childsafeeducation.com/statistics.html
Over 90% of sexual offenders are someone the child knows and trusts a parent or other relative, teacher, camp counselor, babysitter, or family friend.
Orrex
(63,200 posts)Not excusing any part of it--just making I sure that I have the facts straight, and the article isn't entirely clear.
I would never feel comfortable offering my home as an Airbnb space, but, even so, I can't imagine letting some rando in the house where my young children live.
What a fucked up story!
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)Yikes in any case, but yikes!
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)Airbnb, though, has now banned that person from using their service, so that solves the problem.
Move along. Move along.
Nay
(12,051 posts)home?? That's mind boggling.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)Stop all calls. We have a winner.
Xolodno
(6,390 posts)It was clean and comfortable. And given it was out in the country, nice and quiet.
Of course, I would never rent "a room". Just would feel too awkward for the wife and I.
brooklynite
(94,499 posts)MineralMan
(146,286 posts)Typically you lock your room to prevent such things. I know I do.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)Or to prevent walking in on you and someone whom you've abducted?
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)while I am there, for any reason. I also use the additional locking device to keep the housekeeping staff out while I'm in the room. I'm never an abductor of anyone.
I'm not sure what the motivation for your argument is, but I'm done.
Orrex
(63,200 posts)I'll thank you to mind your own business and not worry about whom I choose to abduct, pal.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)Because, well, you never know.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)MineralMan
(146,286 posts)Really? I'm perplexed by it, frankly.
Vinca
(50,261 posts)PoindexterOglethorpe
(25,841 posts)However, I'm with you, MineralMan. I would not be willing to rent out a room in my place to a stranger. Nor would I be willing to stay in a room in a house of people I've never met.
I might possibly be willing to rent the entire apartment or cottage through AirBnB, but not so sure.
Recently I had a brief chat with someone (a friend of a friend) who was on a cross country driving trip and declared quite firmly that she'd much rather go through AirBnB than any conventional motel/hotel. She was focussed entirely on the lower cost. I can't help but think of things like, Who's overseeing anything?
rzemanfl
(29,556 posts)It beat the hell out of staying on the floor in a school gym or hallway full of strangers.
PoindexterOglethorpe
(25,841 posts)Thank you.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)It's just a story about one incident, but an incident that convinces me, once again, that I would never consider renting a room in my house on that basis. Personally, I like staying in hotels, and prefer that to staying even with friends. It gives me more freedom and doesn't impose on anyone's hospitality. The expense is a factor, of course, but doesn't stop me from checking into a hotel.
PoindexterOglethorpe
(25,841 posts)I am like you in that I like staying in hotels. I can even prefer it to staying with relatives.
And I apologize, because I did recognize that you weren't offering a blanket condemnation of that service, merely offering up on particular reported incident.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)I figured you understood what I was saying.
Some others in the thread do not seem to have understood that I was merely describing one rather horrible incident. That alone would keep me from being an airbnb host, if I ever considered doing that in the first place.
PoindexterOglethorpe
(25,841 posts)I'm not all that crazy about letting people stay with me, even though I have a perfectly acceptable guest room. It's also my computer room and I lock the filing cabinet and remove the folders that have my bills and so on once someone is visiting. I wouldn't mind having a fully dedicated guest room, but even then I wouldn't be renting it out to strangers.
You might want to consider starting another thread, perhaps referencing this one, asking if anyone here has rented out spare rooms through AirBnB.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)here. We sleep in one. Another is my wife's office and has no bed, except for the dog bed. The third bedroom is in the basement, but there's no legal egress from the basement, so it's not used as a bedroom. We don't have overnight guests. We have two dogs and two cats, and there's pet hair pretty much everywhere. We also smoke. So, we always suggest a nice motel nearby when someone comes to town. We'll host them for meals at a nearby restaurant and are happy to show them the Twin Cities. They're welcome to visit, if they don't mind pet hair and smoke odors, but we don't invite people to spend the night.
cwydro
(51,308 posts)Completely.
byronius
(7,392 posts)'Disappearing guests', and secret cameras. It happens in motels, too, but --
A couple I met in Jackson was renting an Airbnb room and I flinched. I find all that stuff risky -- Uber, Lyft -- maybe I just don't trust people at all.
Paranoia is bad until it saves your life, I think.
Tikki
(14,556 posts)You don't know who you are picking up...even if you take their photo
and ask for ID.
Then there is, don't hitchhike because you don't know who is picking you up,
even if you take their picture and get their license plate number.
Best put the odds on your side by staying in a regulated, licensed and vetted
accommodation.
Anything can happen, but someone is apt to be looking out for you under laws and regulations and the hope of a return stay.
Tikki
Weekend Warrior
(1,301 posts)And said stranger is given somewhat private access to the daughter of the home owner, by the homeowner.
This story is horrifying on all counts.
WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)treestar
(82,383 posts)In fact aren't family members statistically more likely to be a danger? Someone you know? I don't know that this proves that it is statistically more likely to happen in this scenario.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)and his daughter, it was a horrible thing. A thing that would not have occurred had he not rented out that room through airbnb.
treestar
(82,383 posts)There would still be homicides US citizens commit, and illegal aliens could even be less likely to commit homicide, but to the person for whom an illegal alien murdered their loved one, illegal immigration is the cause. If the killer were in their country, the loved one would still be alive.
When terrible things happen, there is always some variable that can be blamed, but in the end, it is the mind of the perpetrator that brought about the terrible thing.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)not listed the residence as an airbnb location, it would not have occurred. That's my point. Why would anyone have complete strangers staying in their home, referred only by some website?
I would not do such a thing, especially if my family were in the home at the time the guest stayed. Now, I might rent my entire house out for the Superbowl or something, but I'd take the occasion to be somewhere else entirely at that time.
treestar
(82,383 posts)I had kind of thought you did it for when you and your family were out of the house. Yeah, you don't know who you are letting stay in your house. They could turn out to become a good friend, neutral or they could murder you or molest your child. So it is a big chance to take. Not worth it.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)Too much chance of coming back to find a trashed house, I'd think. Besides, I'd have to remove all the computers in the house, etc. to prevent misuse or other shenanigans.
As tempting as the extra cash might be, the risk just seems too high.
lindysalsagal
(20,664 posts)It's one thing if the hosts are adults. Or, if the children go to grandma when the house is rented. I recently rented a whole house for a family event. It was awsome. The hosts weren't there. But I'm a responsible guest.
ProudMNDemocrat
(16,783 posts)My husband and I have had very good experiences with Airbandb when in England and Wales 2 years ago, New Mexico this past February, and will continue to use the service in the future.
We are embarking on a trip to Australia and New Zealand in less than 2 weeks. We have a room booked via Airbandb in San Jose, California for 3 nights, close to where I once lived. We will use the service in Australia as well.
This incident was indeed unfortunate, but I doubt rampant.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)ProudMNDemocrat
(16,783 posts)Or else we would have not been recommended by friends to look into this as an alternative to staying in Hotels. The door swings both ways.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)A google search reveals those, too.
Of course, people also have many complaints about hotels. I've had a few of my own, but all were resolved and a refund given after contacting the corporate owner of the offending hotel. None of those things were criminal, though, by any means.
My OP is about risks involved in renting rooms in your own home to strangers. I've always thought that was a foolish thing to do, and would never even consider it.
chowder66
(9,067 posts)MineralMan
(146,286 posts)The search at the link above reveals some of them.
zipplewrath
(16,646 posts)You're giving someone access to your house when you run a B&B. I've stayed in my share of B&B's and I've seen some places "locked down" tight, such that you had access to very little of the house without keys. I've also been in some that left for the evening giving us relatively "free reign" of the house. In one case, the owner left for the weekend. I've never really understood the B&B concept for small houses where the separation betwix the "home" and the guest space is ill defined.
By the way, the description is very confusing and it is a bit surprising how quickly apparently the assailant ended up with the victim, in the owners bedroom, without much notice "early Sunday morning". I'm hungry for the Paul Harvey version.
mythology
(9,527 posts)Republicans talk a lot about in person voter fraud. It is a thing that happens, but in such a low frequency as to be non-existent.
Statistics show 95% of children who suffer sexual abuse know and trust their abuser. Hardly the case with a random Airbnb person.
There are plenty of reasons to dislike Airbnb. What amounts to an anecdote isn't really on the list.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)people with young children in the home might feel differently about hosting airbnb guests, I'd think.
No guests; no risk from those nonexistent guests. Why take risks that are not necessary?
Major Nikon
(36,827 posts)The same goes for pretty much any other activity you want to name.
Effectively managing risk means having at least a rough idea of what the risks actually are and if managing them is even prudent. Otherwise you wind up spending all of your time trying to manage irrational fear rather than focusing on things that are a genuine risk.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)I've had strangers in my home to fix the plumbing, inspect the heater, install appliances, and do all kinds of things. I'm aware that anyone of them, as with anyone else, has a statistical likelihood of committing a crime in my home, and also aware (and know that they are aware) that their full identity and contact information is known to the company which employs them and sends them to my home.
Would I have left my child alone in the room with any of these strangers in the house? No. But that seems more along the lines of "common sense" than anything else.
But, as noted elsewhere in the thread, people are happy to have stayover guests like aunts, uncles, cousins, in-laws, friends etc., who are definitely not "strangers" but who ARE orders of magnitude more likely to molest their children than any stranger. That's a fact.
But we aren't going to see the thread alerting us all to the very real danger of having members of your own family stay over in your house with your children, which is the scenario for most child molestations.
Major Nikon
(36,827 posts)Yes, people do drown in their bathtub. No, this doesn't mean you shouldn't take a bath, although it might be a good idea to mitigate the risk by not taking enough coke, xanax, and muscle relaxers to kill a horse.
SomethingNew
(279 posts)I think there are some very basic precautions that weren't followed here.
1) Never rent out a room if in a house with kids.
2) If you are going to host/rent a room in an occupied residence, be very careful about the people you stay with.
Personally, I'd never rent out a room in an occupied residence. Either the entire apartment/a self-contained unit or nothing. It is just weird to stay in a house with total strangers and it is asking for trouble. I find hostels weird for similar reasons but as a 6'3" young man, I am fortunate enough to not have to worry about it too much. I stayed in an airbnb last week in Spain and I'll be in one next week in Budapest so I'm obviously glad the service exists. People just need to not be stupid or lax with safety, especially when it comes to children or the elderly.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)lunatica
(53,410 posts)I've reimbursed hundreds and never heard of a single problem. This is just one story out of millions.
Faculty can take their families with them and rent an Airbnb and still pay less than what a hotel room costs just for one. Students who travel together, which they often do can split the cost of an Airbnb house and it's cheaper than some hostels.
flibbitygiblets
(7,220 posts)And this one incidence is enough for so many to write it off completely? Really? That's Like saying " there was a terrorist attack in Paris, so I'll never go there ". Unfortunately I've actually heard this sentiment as well.
I've used Air bnb to stay in really nice places, in cities I'd never be able to afford, or where hotels are scarce, such as SF's North Beach neighborhood. If there are dozens of good reviews, then go for it. No, I would not take my kids, nor stay in a home that had them, mostly because they're a pain in the ass.
But to those who just write off the entire idea, you're missing out on so much that life has to offer. Most hosts gave us amazing recommendations on food, shopping, clubs...plus so cool to meet interesting local people.
atreides1
(16,072 posts)I get the entire space!
I'm on vacation, I don't want to spend my quiet time with people I don't know! Especially after spending the day with 5 granddaughters...
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)crazycatlady
(4,492 posts)ANd my experience with it was not so great. I found that for the same price as a hotel (with a private bath and free breakfast) you got a twin sized bed and a shared bathroom.
Voltaire2
(13,008 posts)And yes obviously there are risks.
Codeine
(25,586 posts)MineralMan
(146,286 posts)It's also necessary to drive at times.
Renting out a room to strangers, however, is not necessary, and I'm not willing to assume the risks involved. It's an easy decision for me.
Codeine
(25,586 posts)and you know it, MM.
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)I had never even considered such a risk before that. I always looked at airbnb as an innocuous way to make a few bucks. The incident occurred. It was in my local news. I posted it. It's not fake news. It happened.
Sensationalism was not my goal, I assure you.
Codeine
(25,586 posts)cwydro
(51,308 posts)I was a caver for years and also a scuba diver. Never a cave diver, but I dove caverns. Cave diving was too risky.
.
I've canoed in the Everglades on Nine Mile Pond surrounded by dozens of alligators. I chose to ride out at least six hurricanes when I lived in the Keys. I've done a lot of risky things.
I chose to take those risks. And yes life is risky every darn day.
Renting out my house to a stranger is a risk I choose not to take.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)The couch is fine. Mind if I have a look in the fridge?
cwydro
(51,308 posts)I have a very mean goose here. Come on over!
You'll run away screaming lol.
I carry a pool noodle around the property - only thing he's scared of.
Sunriser13
(612 posts)The visual on that made me laugh out loud. Coffee spewed everywhere.
My cats, not to mention my roommate, are looking at me like I'm crazier than even they thought they knew. (The real facts about the real level are our little secret, OK? )
Give 'em Hell!
P.S.
To whom shall I remit my invoice for the replacement keyboard and monitor, please?
cwydro
(51,308 posts)Bill him. He bills me daily Geese have a very painful bite.
Today I switched to carrying a tennis racquet. I had to restring the clothesline, which left me vulnerable. He's a sneaky mofo.
So far so good.
Sunriser13
(612 posts)But now I'm hearing ...
Swoosh!
Sproing!
Honk! Honk! Honk... until the sound fades into the distance...
cwydro
(51,308 posts)He's a teenager, so I'm using the racquet only defensively, not offensively. It's just hormones lol.
Hoping he'll mellow.
NRaleighLiberal
(60,014 posts)And we've had some real horror stories at hotels and motels.
Anything is possible with anything....
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)I'm sure that many people enjoy their stays. My post is about being an airbnb host while you and your family occupy the home when guests stay. A little research, though, shows that not all airbnb guests report "very good to great results." It's a mixed bag, I guess.
NRaleighLiberal
(60,014 posts)nini
(16,672 posts)That doesn't excuse what the guy did but the parents should not have left a kid around someone they do not know like that either.
They're right up there with the idiots who leave loaded guns around.
Poor kid
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)prepared to attack the parents and homeowners in this situation, really.
nini
(16,672 posts)The guy was with the girl unattended. Case closed
MineralMan
(146,286 posts)was supposed to be in the guest bedroom. The father found the guest in the parent's bedroom, naked, with his daughter. Time lapse was 15 minutes, according to the article.
What happened during that time is not described in the article. Certainly the parent did not intend for that guest to go into their bedroom where the daughter was sleeping, I'm sure.
So, I don't know the details that would explain exactly what happened. I'm guessing that the newspaper doesn't either. I imagine the police do, though, and that they'll be revealed during any trial that takes place.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)It's so sad so many kids are at risk.