Are we experiencing a slow-motion, Turkish-style coup? Or our own Arab Spring?
SUNDAY, FEB 5, 2017 07:00 AM EST
Corrupting the media, spreading chaos and subverting the rule of law it's what authoritarian regimes do best
STEVEN A. COOK
Writing recently in Tablet magazine, Lee Smith, who is an editor at the Weekly Standard, criticized what he called the Arab-ization of American politics. Smith writes frequently and eloquently about the Arab world, Israel, Turkey and Iran. In this particular piece, he was responding to the Womens March on Washington and, among other things, what has become a signature chant of the early Trump era: This is what democracy looks like!
Smith disagrees. He argues that Trump was legitimately elected president and that protest is only legitimate if the government is breaking the law or failing to fulfill its obligations to uphold the law. He thus likens the excitement on the left for the Womens March (and no doubt subsequent protests) to the misbegotten enthusiasm with which observers across the political spectrum, I should add greeted the so-called Arab Spring.
There are three problems with this argument, though Smith is correct about the almost universal romance with the Middle Eastern barricades. First, the refrain This what democracy looks like! is about the diversity of America and the demands of citizens who happen to be nonwhite, non-male and non-Christian. Second, Smith misconstrues the First Amendment of the Constitution. Third, he implies perhaps unintentionally that this new American street is not unlike the so-called Arab street and the images of chaos that it invokes. Yet the Arab street is not an analytically useful concept because it obscures the rich political environments of Middle Eastern societies in which there are peaceful, sophisticated and creative opponents of authoritarianism. That they were crushed in the aftermath of the uprisings has to do with bad luck, mistakes and the willingness of rulers in the region to use force.
All that said, Smith is onto something, though not in the way he intended. As someone who has studied authoritarianism politics in the Middle East for some time, I have to say that we have seen a number of developments over the last two weeks that looked and felt familiar. Throughout the campaign, Donald Trump and his team created a uniquely hostile environment for the members of the press covering his candidacy. This has continued during the early weeks of Trumps tenure.
more
http://www.salon.com/2017/02/05/are-we-experiencing-a-slow-motion-turkish-style-coup-or-our-own-arab-spring/
VMA131Marine
(4,138 posts)cilla4progress
(24,725 posts)Arab Spring work out?
yurbud
(39,405 posts)the status quo.
yurbud
(39,405 posts)Sunlei
(22,651 posts)Amaryllis
(9,524 posts)Nitram
(22,791 posts)Time will tell if there are any principled Republicans in Congress. But they've already blocked Trump's "investigation" into voter fraud.