It's a Disgrace to Celebrate George H.W. Bush on World AIDS Day
Just after midnight on December 1, World AIDS Day, I learned that President George Herbert Walker Bush had died. And I was dismayed not just that the hagiography afforded dead presidents would overshadow Bushs own appalling legacy on AIDS, but that his death would eclipse the tens of millions of lives we should be remembering today.
When I teach AIDS history, I always show a clip of ACT UPs October 11, 1992, ashes action at the White House, in which brave activists took the cremated bodies of loved ones who had died of AIDS and hurled them onto Bushs lawn. (If youve never seen it, I dare you to watch without crying).
The ashes action is brilliant not just for how raw it was but also for how it held a powerful man to account without civility. (ACT UP had also gone to Bushs vacation home in Maine, and they hounded him up until the night he lost reelection, when they marched the dead body of Mark Fisher to his campaign headquarters.) For in lifeand, sadly, in the first obits, in deathBush dangerously hid the vast nature of American violence beneath the seductive cloak of civility, that opiate of mass media that gets journalists and readers to let violence go unremarked.
https://www.thenation.com/article/george-hw-bush-world-aids-day-obit/
But at a presidential debate with Bill Clinton and Ross Perot the day after the ashes action, journalist John Mashek asked Bush:
Mr. President, yesterday tens of thousands of people paraded past the White House to demonstrate about their concern about the disease, AIDS. A celebrated member of your commission, Magic Johnson, quit, saying there was too much inaction. Where is this widespread feeling coming from that your administration is not doing enough about AIDS?
Looking annoyed, Bush listed what his administration was doing before saying, seemingly irritated, I cant tell you where its coming from. I am very much concerned about AIDS. And I believe we have the best researchers in the world at NIH working on the problem. But then he added:
Its one of the few diseases where behavior matters. And I once called on somebody, Well, change your behavior! If the behavior youre using is prone to cause AIDs, change the behavior! Next thing I know, one of these ACT UP groups is saying, Bush ought to change his behavior! You cant talk about it rationally!