A Complete Guide to 'Hipster Racism'
by Lindy West
People benefit from racismhell, I benefit from it every dayand things that benefit powerful people don't just suddenly get "fixed" and disappear because Halle Berry won an Oscar or whatever. Modern racism lives in entrenched de facto inequalities, in coded language about "work ethic" and"states' rights," in silent negative spaces like absence and invisibility, and in Newt Gingrich's hair. And in irony.
-snip-
So racism went underground. Sure, you can't say racist things anymore but you can pretend to say them! Which, it turns out, is pretty much the exact same thing. There are a couple of strains of "ironic racism" making the rounds right now, and a couple of typical defenses.
1. "Tee-Hee, Aren't I Adorable?" This category includes things like wide-eyed acoustic covers of hip-hop songs, suburban white girls flashing gang signs, and this Tweet from Zooey Deschanel: "Haha. RT @Sarabareilles: Home from tour and first things first: New Girl episodes I missed. #thuglife." See, it's hilarious, because we aren't thugswe are darling girls, and real thugs are black people who do crime! Oh, hey, can I call you back? I need to sew more ric-rac on my apron. I hope a black person didn't get into my ric-rac Kaboodle and steal all of it! JK, LOL. RIP, Whitney.
read: http://m.jezebel.com/5905291/a-complete-guide-to-hipster-racism
muriel_volestrangler
(101,301 posts)She says "race is one of the least complicated issues that there is, because it's made up". And then proceeds to say the retweet by Zooey Deschanel of Sara Bareilles' tweet is 'ironic racism' because it mentions the word 'thug'. It's only the author who claims that means "real thugs are black people who do crime". And, if race it made up, then "wide-eyed acoustic covers of hip-hop songs" is not racism either. It's just music.
Similarly, if race is made up, then 'recreational slumming' is not racism. The author is saying that any boundaries are completely arbitrary and unjustified, but then insists that people never break them.
I suspect they wanted to write about Lesley Arfin, found another Jezebel blogger had done so already, and had to desperately pad it out to make it seem as if they had an original point.
limpyhobbler
(8,244 posts)When people are trying to be sensitive about race but they don't know what to say, they usually go with, "Well, race is a complicated issue." Except, no, it's not. Race is one of the least complicated issues that there is, because it's made up. It's arbitrary. It's as complicated as goddamn Santa Claus. Oh, that guy's mom was half-black, which makes his skin slightly more pigmented than mine, which therefore means that he's inherently 12.5% lazier than me? Science! Um, no. What's actually complicated is our country's relationship with race, and our utter ineptitude at talking about it. We suck. I mean, I work on it every day, and I'm still a total fuck-up. But this new scheme someone came up withwhere we prove we're not racist by acting as casually racist as possible? Not our best, white people. Not our best.
Makes sense to me. Race is just as complicated as Santa Claus because it is made up. Invented. No biological basis. Race is a social construct. But just because race is invented it doesn't necessarily mean that none of those examples could be racist. I don't know whether all of them are necessarily, but that's a different question.
I'm not bothered by the informal tone of this article or the fact that it is apparently unedited. It's just some blog post.
Zooey Deschanel and Sara Bareilles tagging their messages with #thuglife... That's racist. For the exact reason given in the article.
Not everyone can detect it. Takes practice. Opinions may vary.
muriel_volestrangler
(101,301 posts)especially in the light of race being made up and arbitrary. What connection has 'thuglife' to racism? The article claims that it says thugs are black people. But it doesn't say that, at all. What it does say is that watching a sitcom is not 'thuglife'. So the explanation in the article fails. So, what's your explanation of why it's racist?
Lydia Leftcoast
(48,217 posts)(because all African-Americans are criminals, according to right-wing mythology )
Example of use: "I moved to the suburbs because all kinds of welfare mothers, gangbangers, and thugs moved into my neighborhood."
Translation: "I moved to the suburbs because some upwardly mobile African-Americans moved into my neighborhood."
muriel_volestrangler
(101,301 posts)You can't take one word as the sole evidence for its context being racist, when non-racist people use the word as well, with a meaning that has nothing to do with race.
limpyhobbler
(8,244 posts)To me it is part of black culture that describes and asks questions about how to survive in a difficult environment.
It is associated with Tupac Shakur. Hopefully that's a fair description.
Zooey D & Sara B weren't talking about republicans. They were talking about black people.
If anything Zooey D & Sara B were making fun of themselves for engaging in behavior that is so safe and stereo-typically suburban and white.
They are making fun of themselves for having such an easy life in comparison to thuglife where every day is a struggle for survival. But by invoking #thuglife as a comedic foil to contrast with their own safe bourgeois existence, they end up reinforcing the stereotype of black people as thugs, while also reinforcing the stereotype of white girls as having easy lives where their biggest problem is catching up with their soap operas.
But the overall point of the article was about the trend toward increasing use of ironic racism, and different common patterns it takes. That Zooey D thing was only one example of many in the article.
There are also a bunch of good examples through the link in post #6 below. thanks
independentpiney
(1,510 posts)the removal of privilege (hell, even just the *identification* of privilege) so often gets whined at as "reverse racism" or some such absurd thing. When someone points out to a privileged person that they've been enjoying the fruits of something they did not in any way earn, that doesn't mean that this unfortunate privileged person is now experiencing "discrimination." I'm sorry to be breaking this to those of you who didn't get that, but there you go.
bettydavis
(93 posts)I LOVED it. Check this too for more...
http://www.racialicious.com/2012/05/02/a-historical-guide-to-hipster-racism/
limpyhobbler
(8,244 posts)That was very good. Welcome to DU.
Can I Come Home
(32 posts)are the first four words of any incredibly racist statement.
Nolimit
(142 posts)I've a black friend so I feel I can say....
Amster Dan
(89 posts)Father Mulcahy on M*A*S*H, replying to Radar O'Reilly's anti-Catholic grandma.
flamingdem
(39,313 posts)and that people benefit from racism. Besides that as a cause there is a more basic tribal/group/family current there that is human and can be played with reflexively to some extent.
I think everyone should visit Cuba and other very mixed multi-racial nations. While they have their own brand of racism, the race relations are so different it helps to get some perspective on race in the USA. It's easier to see race in the USA as the historical construct it is. I think those societies in some areas are much more relaxed than in the USA and this is shown by the politically incorrect (by US standards) racial joking that goes on.