Why House Democrats May Be More United Than They Seem
Two factions of the Democratic Party in Congress are currently playing tug-of-war over the centerpieces of President Bidens legislative agenda. Moderate Democrats have balked at the proposed $3.5 trillion reconciliation budget bill, attempting to delay a vote on it in the House and insisting that the price tag will have to come down in the Senate. At the same time, House progressives have threatened to block a $1 trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill unless the reconciliation bill passes first with the current price tag intact. (The House is scheduled to vote on the infrastructure bill on Thursday.)
But its easy to blow these disagreements out of proportion. On one hand, they are certainly relevant in that they threaten to derail two potentially transformative pieces of legislation. But they do not mean that Democrats are a hopelessly or even significantly divided party. Instead, its really the narrowness of Democrats congressional majorities that makes passing big legislation difficult, as even a small number of defectors can make the difference in a bill passing or failing.
For instance, the number of House moderates who attempted to hold up the reconciliation bill last month was only nine enough to make the difference in a tight chamber, yes, but a drop in the bucket compared with the entire Democratic caucus, and plenty of moderate Democrats in the House didnt stand in the way. (The progressive dissent may be more widespread one congressman claimed that dozens of progressive votes were on the fence but its hard to know how seriously to take these threats, given that only a few representatives have gone public with them.) In addition, more stories will get written over the course of a long negotiation, which can lead to a media emphasis on the messy sausage-making process over the (often less acrimonious) outcome.
In fact, theres good reason to think that House Speaker Nancy Pelosis current Democratic caucus is the opposite of in disarray. When it comes down to brass tacks, Democrats are (so far) the most united House caucus of the last three sessions of Congress. According to FiveThirtyEights Biden Score, which measures how often individual members of Congress vote in line with Bidens position, 203 out of the Houses 223 Democrats1 have voted with Biden 100 percent of the time, and all but two have voted with him at least 90 percent of the time.
https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/why-house-democrats-may-be-more-united-than-they-seem/
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)Momma
(13 posts)When anti-authoritarian coalitions splinter, the authoritarians take over.
by IAN BASSIN SEPTEMBER 30, 2021 1:49 PM
Source: The Bulwark
A united opposition is the best way to defeat an autocrat. And a fractured opposition opens the pathway for one to attain power.
This is a precept that Americas Democratic coalition ought to have top of mind this week. Especially those parts of the coalition threatening to derail the legislation House and Senate leaders plan to bring to the floor.
Because while each wing of the governing coalition may feel that aspects of the policies they prefer are good forand even necessary fordemocracy, if they cant reach a deal, not only will they not deliver on any of those policies, but this failure will be a boon to the authoritarian forces waiting to regain power.
There are practical political reasons why the failure to pass either of the bills would help the anti-democratic forces. (The lack of legislative accomplishment is likely to hurt Democrats in 2022 and weaken President Biden in 2024.) But more important may be the psychological component. If Democrats cannot govern even with the presidency and majorities in both houses, then it would demonstrate to the American people that democracy may not be workable in our current moment. And its in situations like that when a strongman who promises that I alone can fix it becomes more attractive.
But its important to note that this lesson ought to be heeded by the full anti-authoritarian coalition. Which means not just Democrats, but pro-democracy Republicans.
Read more: [link:https://www.thebulwark.com/democracy-cannot-survive-the-fracturing-of-the-democratic-coalition/|
ancianita
(36,023 posts)It's safe -- they don't get criticized or threatened for it -- and it sells, and they've decided that good news is boring.