Joan Walsh: Juan Williams stands in for Obama at Fox debate
Tuesday, Jan 17, 2012 1:00 PM UTC
The GOP celebrates MLK day by booing the black pundit as Gingrich belittles him for asking tough questions on race
By Joan Walsh
The Fox News debate began auspiciously, with moderator Bret Baier noting that it was our national holiday honoring Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Then his actual question had nothing to do with Dr. King. But those of us who feared the debate would duck racial issues worried for naught. The night climaxed with the South Carolina crowd giving Newt Gingrich a standing ovation for smacking down Foxs leading black contributor, Juan Williams, for his impertinent questions about race.
Williams asked for it, of course. What was he thinking making tough racial queries at a GOP debate in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina.? First, he asked Romney how he squared his harsh anti-immigrant rhetoric with his own familys story of moving to and then from Mexico seeking religious freedom. He asked Rick Santorum, who purports to care about poverty, what he would do about high African American poverty rates. He asked Ron Paul whether he thought the nations harsh drug laws were bad for black people. Then he made the mistake of asking Newt Gingrich about his comments that poor urban children came from communities that lacked a work ethic, and his calling Barack Obama the food stamp president.
Gingrich couldnt believe his luck. With a gleam in his eye, he thrashed Williams, and Steve Kornacki believes he may have given his candidacy one last shot with his savvy thumping of Foxs leading black commentator. It hurt to watch. If Newt gets the nomination he wont, but a Democrat can dream hell have to thank Williams at the GOP convention in Tampa, even before he thanks Callista.
Sure, Santorum took his chance to demagogue on race, telling Williams that it only took three things to stay out of poverty in America: Work, graduate from high school, and get married before you have children. He didnt allow that any residue of racism or discrimination might make it harder for African Americans to work, graduate from high school or marry. Santorum also made unfounded allegations, again, about the Obama administration forbidding certain federal programs from talking about marriage. But at least he answered Williams with some personal respect.
Read the entire piece at Salon.com
aaaaaa5a
(4,667 posts)The only reason the south is so republican today is because of a backlash against the freedom movement of the 60s.
bemildred
(90,061 posts)Plantsmantx
(20 posts)That answer didn't show any "personal respect". It's an answer full of cultural racism.
EC
(12,287 posts)are many married couples with and without children that are poor and not making it. So is argument is bull-shit. And many of those married couples have college degrees, not just High School diplomas.
Doctor_J
(36,392 posts)his self-loathing would make an excellent dissertation topic for an abnormal psych doctoral candidate.