Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Coke ad hits the right note
Gil Smart at Smart Remarks:
But it was the Coke ad that got everyone buzzing, the multilingual performance of America the Beautiful set to images of what America looks like these days multicultural, multiracial, brown and black and white.
I thought it was a nice ad, making the point that you dont have to be from America to love America. Thats not necessarily going to make me run out and buy Coke, though I might if its on sale.
But apparently a whole bunch of people did rush out to buy soda in the wake of the ad though they made a point of sneering at Coke and buying Pepsi instead.
Nanoseconds after the ad appeared, the virtual airwaves were polluted with the stench of xenophobia. Speak English or go home was one reaction on Cokes Facebook page. Wrote one twit on Twitter: How dare you sing America in different languages. (Expletive) Coca Cola. That's so disrespectful.
Tweeted another: Looks like I'm now a Pepsi person.
I bet Pepsi is thrilled.
But do we really have to do this?
Multilingualism, multiculturalism is apparently still offensive to some people who see it in terms of a choice.
It isnt a choice. Its a fact.
It exists. Its here. Its what America looks like in 2014 and beyond, and if we spent as much time acclimating ourselves to the reality of multiculturalism as we did complaining about it or, ludicrously, trying to stymie it, America would be an even more beautiful place.
Its always been a xenophobic place, of course. I like to remind right-wingers of Irish ancestry that, once upon a time, real Americans sought to put their grandparents back on the boat and return them to sender.
The idea of the ad was that it was all inclusive: You dont have to be from America or even in America to think America beautiful, you dont have to speak the (still) predominant language, you dont have to meet some criteria to admire this countrys natural beauty, its values, the things its supposed to represent.
But here was Glenn Beck popping his head out of the gopher hole to call the ad divisive.
Divisive? How? By reminding culturally besieged white people that they no longer rule the roost as they once did?
Beck, like several other conservative commentators, seemed to think the ad had something to do with the immigration debate. Rush Limbaugh wondered aloud if the Republican Party itself was behind the ad, to pave the way for immigration reform.
Apparently, then, you are only entitled to think America beautiful, and to sing about it, if you sing in the right language, if your customs and habits reflect the right culture, if you promise to melt into the melting pot rather than trying to preserve your old traditions or language.
Youre only entitled to sing it, to feel it, if you agree to cede continued cultural control to those who feel it slipping from their grasp.
Nonsense.
I dont see why so many people persist in this doomed rear-guard cultural action. Were not turning back the clock; the browning of America is here and it will continue. Its not something to be resented and resisted, its something to be accepted as fact. Because it is fact.
I thought it was a nice ad, making the point that you dont have to be from America to love America. Thats not necessarily going to make me run out and buy Coke, though I might if its on sale.
But apparently a whole bunch of people did rush out to buy soda in the wake of the ad though they made a point of sneering at Coke and buying Pepsi instead.
Nanoseconds after the ad appeared, the virtual airwaves were polluted with the stench of xenophobia. Speak English or go home was one reaction on Cokes Facebook page. Wrote one twit on Twitter: How dare you sing America in different languages. (Expletive) Coca Cola. That's so disrespectful.
Tweeted another: Looks like I'm now a Pepsi person.
I bet Pepsi is thrilled.
But do we really have to do this?
Multilingualism, multiculturalism is apparently still offensive to some people who see it in terms of a choice.
It isnt a choice. Its a fact.
It exists. Its here. Its what America looks like in 2014 and beyond, and if we spent as much time acclimating ourselves to the reality of multiculturalism as we did complaining about it or, ludicrously, trying to stymie it, America would be an even more beautiful place.
Its always been a xenophobic place, of course. I like to remind right-wingers of Irish ancestry that, once upon a time, real Americans sought to put their grandparents back on the boat and return them to sender.
The idea of the ad was that it was all inclusive: You dont have to be from America or even in America to think America beautiful, you dont have to speak the (still) predominant language, you dont have to meet some criteria to admire this countrys natural beauty, its values, the things its supposed to represent.
But here was Glenn Beck popping his head out of the gopher hole to call the ad divisive.
Divisive? How? By reminding culturally besieged white people that they no longer rule the roost as they once did?
Beck, like several other conservative commentators, seemed to think the ad had something to do with the immigration debate. Rush Limbaugh wondered aloud if the Republican Party itself was behind the ad, to pave the way for immigration reform.
Apparently, then, you are only entitled to think America beautiful, and to sing about it, if you sing in the right language, if your customs and habits reflect the right culture, if you promise to melt into the melting pot rather than trying to preserve your old traditions or language.
Youre only entitled to sing it, to feel it, if you agree to cede continued cultural control to those who feel it slipping from their grasp.
Nonsense.
I dont see why so many people persist in this doomed rear-guard cultural action. Were not turning back the clock; the browning of America is here and it will continue. Its not something to be resented and resisted, its something to be accepted as fact. Because it is fact.
InfoView thread info, including edit history
TrashPut this thread in your Trash Can (My DU » Trash Can)
BookmarkAdd this thread to your Bookmarks (My DU » Bookmarks)
2 replies, 807 views
ShareGet links to this post and/or share on social media
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
ReplyReply to this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
Rec (1)
ReplyReply to this post
2 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Coke ad hits the right note (Original Post)
Bgno64
Feb 2014
OP
Downwinder
(12,869 posts)1. Back to the food fight.
Are they going to stop eating black-eyed peas, melons, okra, tacos, Chinese, etc? How about spaghetti and pizza?
Thought we had buried the freedom fries.
oldandhappy
(6,719 posts)2. ha ha Beck knows about divisive.
He has contributed a lot to our present divisiveness.