Would you like cake or pie? And what flavor?

[IrishEyes]

Personally, I like a chocolate cake with raspberry filling. I can be talked into most kinds of cake except cheesecake and red velvet cake.

I'm a little more picky when it comes to pie. I don't like cherry, apple and blueberry pie. I like pumpkin and key lime pie.

[samnsara]

1. anything as long a its not mincemeat

[MontanaMama]

2. Pie.

Peach, raspberry, lemon meringue or banana cream.

[FM123]

3. I love Key Lime Pie!

(best part of living in FL)

[Anon-C]

4. Key lime cheesecake!

[hlthe2b]

5. I will likely be craving chocolate cake as I breathe my last....LOL

And boy, it will be a good one (at least in my fantasies): rich chocolate caramel hazelnut truffle comes to mind.

[IrishEyes]

7. I like every word in that cake description.

Eating that cake before I shuffle off this mortal coil would be a good way to go.

[lkinwi]

6. Warmed blueberry pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

Chocolate or banana cream pie will do just fine also.

[KT2000]

8. PIE!!!!!

blackberry and rhubarb pies are my fave.

[smirkymonkey]

35. Not a huge pie fan, but I LOVE rhubarb pie.

Or rhubarb anything for that matter.

[Bantamfancier]

9. Angel food cake

and blackberry pie.

[TeapotInATempest]

10. Both?

Although I actually prefer cake, I'm like pumpkin, pecan, blueberry, key lime, lemon meringue or coconut cream pie. I have never liked peach.

My favorite cake of all is yellow, with strawberry and banana filling and whipped cream frosting. Heaven.

For Christmas, I make a pistachio cardamom cake with vanilla bean cream cheese frosting which is sooo tasty (can't take credit - I found the recipe online somewhere several years ago, although I changed the frosting from buttercream to cream cheese) and I regularly make a Spanish Almond cake, which is not terribly cake-like since it uses almond flour instead of wheat flour.

I cut the sugar in almost every dessert recipe by about a third, since I really dislike sugar being the dominant flavor over all the other lovely ingredients.

[IrishEyes]

11. Both is definitely an option.

Pistachio cardamom cake sounds delicious.

[KY_EnviroGuy]

12. Pecan pie. Pecan flavor.

.............

[Cousin Dupree]

13. Pie. Peach, strawberry/rhubarb, boysenberry, chocolate, cherry, any kind of berry.

[Polly Hennessey]

14. Well, this is easy.

All pies and all cakes. Never turn down either. That includes Mincemeat with Hard Sauce.

[csziggy]

15. I am craving chocolate cake

I've been on a low carb diet for several months - it's working, I am almost down to my (interim) target weight, but damn I miss real chocolate baked goods!

My weight had to get down for a surgery - fusion on the L5 vertebrae in my back. I've told my husband that after the surgery he is to buy me a "Death by Chocolate Cake" from the local bakery as my reward for surviving yet another damn surgery. Then I will go back to restricted carbs and as soon as I can exercise I will be putting in miles of walking, either around our farm or in the gym.

[IrishEyes]

16. I hope your surgery goes well.

It is nice to think about your reward when it is over. I hope it is delicious.

[csziggy]

18. Me, too - thank you!

I'm glad I've lost the weight and now I am motivated to keep losing. Gone from 287 to 230 since October 2017 and hope to get down below 200 by the end of the year.

[fNord]

17. Yes......

And, well yes.

[Honeycombe8]

19. Italian cream cake with thick frosting. Mmmm.

I can take or leave pie. But my favorite is probably lemon meringue. No...cherry pie. No...blackberry pie.

I'm more of a candy person, though.

[area51]

20. Spice cake.

[Phentex]

22. Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

maybe this is what I need to satisfy my craving. I love spice cake!

[Phentex]

21. I've been on a cinnamon coffee cake kick...

I made one and it was super sweet. May try again with a lot less sugar.

[red dog 1]

23. Cake or Pie, as long as it's chocolate.

San Francisco's "Just Deserts" bakery used to make the best chocolate sour cream cupcakes in the world.

They are now headquartered in Fairfield, CA, and now sell their cakes all over the USA.

[Flaleftist]

24. Chocolate chocolate cake with extra chocolate, pecan pie

[lilactime]

25. Spice cake w/caramel frosting and pecan pie.

Also love yellow cake w/buttercream frosting or chocolate cake with chocolate frosting.

My other fave pie is French apple...pie with frosting, what's not to like??

[stonecutter357]

26. Original Black Forest Cake .

[TygrBright]

27. Boston Cream Pie. To have AND to eat. n/t

[smirkymonkey]

36. But Boston Cream Pie is really a cake.

Either way, it's still good!

[elfin]

28. White layer cake with lemon filling and fluffy white boiled frosting with

coconut on top. Just on one half for those who hated coconut in our family.

The birthday cake my Mom made just for me. Now need to buy the Pepperidge Farm version in the freezer aisle.

Pie - again with my Mom's chocolate cream pie. She held it over my head like a Damocles Sword until I ate that damn succotash of goddamn turnips and peas.

Always caved. Now carb-conscious geezer yours truly only indulges on my birthday while sending up gratitude for such sweet memories.

[IrishEyes]

40. A cake or pie made by mom is always good.

[50 Shades Of Blue]

29. Mmmm... pie. Literally eating a piece of pecan pie right now!

Not picky about pie except I hate rhubarb. I'm pickier about frosting than I am about cake.

[IrishEyes]

39. Pecan pie is yummy.

I hope you enjoyed it.

[msdogi]

30. Peach pie

O'Henry peaches, dry farmed, grown by a lovely Ukranian lady in Sebastopol. perfection

[MissMillie]

31. Pie: peach Cake: chocolate w/ mocha frosting

either one will do w/ a cup of hot dark roast coffee.

[ailsagirl]

32. ....

pie:
lemon meringue
rhubarb
peach

cake:
white cake w/vanilla frosting (from Safeway)
carrot cake
chocolate cake ($100 Chocolate Cake)
lemon cake

Pretty dull, I know

[JuJuYoshida]

33. Coconut Cream Pie for this gal!

[IrishEyes]

38. That looks really good.

[yellowdogintexas]

44. Coconut Cream Pie is my downfall!!!

If we are at a restaurant known for its pies, I can resist anything but coconut cream.

I also like cherry and peach (pie or cobbler), buttermilk, chess and chocolate fudge

If I am not at home and have to choose between pie or cake, I will take the pie.
I bake a lot and am very good with cakes, breads and cookies. Pies not so much, so I do not bake them very often. Therefore they are a great treat if having dinner out

[dameatball]

34. Depends on what time and what meal. I do like a coconut custard pie with coffee for breakfast.

Spice cake with caramel I could roll in it.... But not for breakfast.

[smirkymonkey]

37. I like cake, but it has to be homemade w/ homemade frosting.

My favorite is a dark chocolate cake w/ either whipped cream or buttercream frosting and I also like raspberry filling. I love fruit in cakes.

[ProudLib72]

41. A friend of my mom's made a chocolate cake once that was more candy bar than cake

She used something like a dozen Snickers bars and a dozen Hershey bars in the batter. Anyway, when it came out it was soooooo dense! And chocolaty!

I LOVE CHOCOLATE!!

[rurallib]

42. Pizza pie - italian sausage, pepperoni, onions, green olives

extra sauce and cheese

[WSSlover]

43. I like both cake and pie,

as long as they're both chocolate (which is my favorite flavor.)!