Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ohiosmith

(24,262 posts)
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 03:04 PM Mar 2013

If you're a vegan, and drink Guinness,....you may not want to read this!

As St. Patrick's Day creeps closer, so does the promise of corned beef and cabbage, green beer and, of course, Guinness. But some vegetarian and vegan revelers might want to reconsider that thick, creamy Irish stout -- it could contain trace amounts of fish bladders.

Smithsonian.com's Food&Think blog published on Wednesday an in-depth explanation of isinglass, a form of collagen culled from a dried swim bladder, an internal fish organ that helps regulate buoyancy in water. It's used in a process called fining -- when unwanted leftovers, like solid particles and degenerated yeast cells, are removed from the brewing process. These elements settle on their own to the bottom of a cask in a jelly-like clump, but isinglass quickens the process and makes them easier to remove.

The use of isinglass as a fining agent isn't exactly new, and it's not exactly news. While many beers and wines use gelatin instead of isinglass these days (those beverages aren't vegan, either), Guinness still uses it in much the same way it has since the mid- to late-19th century. And publications and blogs have been taking note of it for some time now.

Still, it remains largely unknown to the greater public, likely because Guinness doesn't publicize it. Isinglass is not listed as an ingredient on Guinness' website, nor is it listed on the bottle. (In the U.S., alcoholic beverages are not required to list ingredients on labels.)

Link:http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/03/14/guinness-fish-bladder_n_2878165.html?utm_hp_ref=mostpopulary

33 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
If you're a vegan, and drink Guinness,....you may not want to read this! (Original Post) ohiosmith Mar 2013 OP
Now this is just .... mean! Sekhmets Daughter Mar 2013 #1
I thought it more of a PSA! ohiosmith Mar 2013 #3
Like a tornado warning, perhaps? Sekhmets Daughter Mar 2013 #6
If you're gonna drink a lot o' Guinness, You can use all the bladder you can get pinboy3niner Mar 2013 #2
Amen that! ohiosmith Mar 2013 #4
Perfect! Sekhmets Daughter Mar 2013 #5
Awesome! Paulie Mar 2013 #12
Oh my! In_The_Wind Mar 2013 #17
That may dampen St. Patrick's Day festivities of some. Knightraven Mar 2013 #7
trying to eat some squid ...... olddots Mar 2013 #8
I'm not vegan, but I find this so disgusting that I may not be able to drink guinness again. Honeycombe8 Mar 2013 #9
Swim bladder != bladder sir pball Mar 2013 #19
Oh...well, that does sound better. Thx. I dare not read about the gelatin. nt Honeycombe8 Mar 2013 #20
Yeaah...like laws and sausages. nt sir pball Mar 2013 #22
Can't they just sell the fish bladders to the Scotts so they can make haggis? talkingmime Mar 2013 #10
There was a time when a lot of vintners Moondog Mar 2013 #11
We homebrew... Raine1967 Mar 2013 #13
I am not a vegan. In_The_Wind Mar 2013 #14
I wonder, was that icon deliberately made to look like a Guinness? nomorenomore08 Mar 2013 #15
Ask DU. It's their icon. In_The_Wind Mar 2013 #16
Dang it. Still Blue in PDX Mar 2013 #18
We shared our home with a woman who swore that Guinness was the best. In_The_Wind Mar 2013 #21
Gelatin's no better.. sir pball Mar 2013 #23
Still going to drink it! Luckly I am a big meat eater! Lady Freedom Returns Mar 2013 #24
What on earth is "Old World Style"? harmonicon Mar 2013 #26
Amen! pinboy3niner Mar 2013 #27
Not just Guinness - almost any traditional ale. harmonicon Mar 2013 #25
Very much so T_i_B Mar 2013 #32
I'm in luck. DFW Mar 2013 #28
Hey, don't knock fish juice...have you tried the Bass-O-Matic? pinboy3niner Mar 2013 #29
No, they were sold out when I tried to order one n/t DFW Mar 2013 #30
No Screech for me. In_The_Wind Mar 2013 #31
To be brutally honest...... T_i_B Mar 2013 #33

Knightraven

(268 posts)
7. That may dampen St. Patrick's Day festivities of some.
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 03:40 PM
Mar 2013

I've got to have my Guinness! It is one of my guilty pleasures.

 

olddots

(10,237 posts)
8. trying to eat some squid ......
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 04:06 PM
Mar 2013

Lisa tells me that some people have been passing bleached pig anuses off as squid .......welcome to the 21st.century
The point of drinking Guinness is to not give a shit for a while .

Honeycombe8

(37,648 posts)
9. I'm not vegan, but I find this so disgusting that I may not be able to drink guinness again.
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 04:19 PM
Mar 2013

I almost bought some yesterday!

sir pball

(4,741 posts)
19. Swim bladder != bladder
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 06:55 PM
Mar 2013

Swim bladders are organs a fish can inflate or deflate to control buoyancy. Nothing like a urinary bladder. It's less gross than where gelatin comes from..

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swim_bladder
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gelatin

 

talkingmime

(2,173 posts)
10. Can't they just sell the fish bladders to the Scotts so they can make haggis?
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 04:19 PM
Mar 2013

I know, it's sheep, but still.

Edit:

On the album, Cleese says "Fuck your sales".

Moondog

(4,833 posts)
11. There was a time when a lot of vintners
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 04:22 PM
Mar 2013

used isinglass as a fining agent.

I did a little amateur wine making back in the mid 70s, and it was pretty much the gold standard for fining at that time. I have no idea if that is still the case.

Raine1967

(11,589 posts)
13. We homebrew...
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 05:24 PM
Mar 2013

My Husband brews a few stout recipes and one of them (I believe) is as good as Guinness, we even have the same sort of tap used to pour it.

That said, I know he does use chitosan (which uses things like shrimp and crustacean shells) as a clarifier, and has used isinglass -- that is fairly common when making beer. It's essentially a natural clarifier.

I can see I can understand vegans not wanted to drink this, but as far a vegitarians, the isinglass as well as the Chitosan do not stay in the beer when the final product is done. It acts like a magnet, as the article mentions for the unwanted blerg. It does indeed settle to the bottom and -- if one is brewing properly, it never enters the final product.

Something else interesting -- Most ciders are advertised as vegetarian -- they use these products to give a nice clear look to the final product. He makes a wonderful cider too -- We just finished a corny keg of a nice dry cider made from Maryland apples.

I think a lot of people would be surprised to find how many breweries use either isinglass or chitosan.

Alternatively -- Chitosan has been used as a rapid blood clotter. It is also known to be used as a way to block fat in the intestine.

As far as the fish bladder, On days like today, I agree, I can use all the bladder I can get!

Sláinte!

Raine

In_The_Wind

(72,300 posts)
16. Ask DU. It's their icon.
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 06:33 PM
Mar 2013

I don't care for green beer.[img][/img]

It isn't a day for champagne. [img][/img]

What I really want is a scotch mist.

Still Blue in PDX

(1,999 posts)
18. Dang it.
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 06:49 PM
Mar 2013

I'm not vegan, but I'm vegetarian, and I find that just . . .

icky and disturbing, because I really like Guinness. Liked it, that is. Thanks for the heads up, so to speak.

In_The_Wind

(72,300 posts)
21. We shared our home with a woman who swore that Guinness was the best.
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 09:03 PM
Mar 2013

She would hate to read ohiosmith's OP.


Maybe I should send her a link by email.

sir pball

(4,741 posts)
23. Gelatin's no better..
Sun Mar 17, 2013, 11:14 PM
Mar 2013

Actually probably worse, I've seen fish bladders, and I've seen what they make gelatin from, and trust me...the latter is preferable.

pinboy3niner

(53,339 posts)
27. Amen!
Mon Mar 18, 2013, 02:46 AM
Mar 2013

And it sure beats eating pig anus "squid" (#8). "Is it just me, Marge, or does this calamari taste like pigshit to you, too?"

harmonicon

(12,008 posts)
25. Not just Guinness - almost any traditional ale.
Mon Mar 18, 2013, 02:30 AM
Mar 2013

It's incredibly common in England, and I assume Ireland as well. I would imagine it's not mentioned by them not because there's some scandal, but because it's taken for granted. Besides, it's not exactly an ingredient - it's not really a part of the brewing process per-se, but more to do with how the beer is stored and served.

T_i_B

(14,737 posts)
32. Very much so
Mon Mar 18, 2013, 08:23 AM
Mar 2013

To be perfectly honest, I'd much rather drink beer made with Isinglass over beer that's been filtered. My understanding is that Isinglass is used to ensure that beer is clear and not cloudy.

There are a few UK breweries such as Moor doing beer that is unfined, and naturally cloudy.

If you want vegan beer then Marble Brewery of Manchester are excellent. And their pub, the Marble Arch in Manchester is brilliant as well. http://www.marblebeers.com/

DFW

(54,330 posts)
28. I'm in luck.
Mon Mar 18, 2013, 03:23 AM
Mar 2013

I'm not vegan and I don't drink Guinness.

I once had a friend from Newfoundland who drank something called Newfoundland Screech. As the bottles didn't screech, and neither did he, I wondered why it was called that. He admitted he didn't know. I asked what was in it. He said he thought it was "rum mixed with fish juice."

I don't drink Newfoundland Screech, either.

T_i_B

(14,737 posts)
33. To be brutally honest......
Mon Mar 18, 2013, 08:28 AM
Mar 2013

......there are many many better stouts out there then Guinness.

I was drinking Summer Wine Mokko on Saturday for instance, that's a milk stout that's miles better then Guinness.

And rather then go for the Diageo marketing division's suggestion to toast St Patrick last night I chose Fyne Ales Sanda Black IPA. Yes it's neither Irish nor a Stout but it is a very nice beer.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»If you're a vegan, and dr...