Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

cbdo2007

(9,213 posts)
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 03:39 PM Feb 2012

What one musical death would have the biggest emotional impact on you?

All these musical deaths all the time, many I don't care about but sometimes I'll reflect and go to youtube and watch some videos or spend a whole evening listing to someone's music on Spotify as a rememberance of them. Got me thinking, what one musician death would have the biggest emotional impact on you?

Mine would definitely be Bob Dylan

Runners up: Dave Grohl, Paul McCartney

55 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
What one musical death would have the biggest emotional impact on you? (Original Post) cbdo2007 Feb 2012 OP
Pete Townshend dana_b Feb 2012 #1
Pat Metheny. tied with Joni Mitchell. NRaleighLiberal Feb 2012 #2
No one else sounds like Pat Metheny. Manifestor_of_Light Mar 2012 #32
Ah - ECM is from Munich Germany - I have about 300 or more ECM releases.... NRaleighLiberal Mar 2012 #39
Don McLean, Joan Baez, Emmylou Harris, Elton John RFKHumphreyObama Feb 2012 #3
Two: One is personal and wouldn't mean anything to anyone else gratuitous Feb 2012 #4
James Hetfield, AKA Papa Het. Bladian Feb 2012 #5
The Bobster graywarrior Feb 2012 #6
Agree with you, Bob Dylan or any remaining Beatle treestar Feb 2012 #7
Leo Kottke DFW Feb 2012 #8
A friend in Europe introduced me to him in 1973 -- that incredibly RICH voice... MiddleFingerMom Feb 2012 #10
Hedges was a great loss--a traffic accident for Pete's sake! DFW Feb 2012 #16
Those are beautiful! Bake Mar 2012 #41
Božo is a true artist DFW Mar 2012 #49
John Lennon. Scuba Feb 2012 #9
Carole King Pool Hall Ace Feb 2012 #11
John Williams charlie and algernon Feb 2012 #12
My two favorite guitarists in the world... pipi_k Feb 2012 #13
Exene Cervenka... Tikki Feb 2012 #14
Eddie Vedder MrCoffee Feb 2012 #15
why would anyone flame? dana_b Feb 2012 #20
That's who I was going to say. pamela Mar 2012 #34
Already happened MorningGlow Feb 2012 #17
Jim Croce zanana1 Feb 2012 #21
Paul McCartney. Arugula Latte Feb 2012 #18
Either of the Wilson sisters. HopeHoops Feb 2012 #19
Paul McCartney, James Taylor undeterred Feb 2012 #22
Mike Oldfield kentauros Feb 2012 #23
Bill Nelson? zappaman Feb 2012 #28
Thank you :) kentauros Feb 2012 #29
a great box set just came out zappaman Mar 2012 #30
Yes, I've seen that there before, kentauros Mar 2012 #31
I misread it: I thought it was musicians who'd already died. pink-o Feb 2012 #24
Mine guitar man Feb 2012 #25
Screw that! bluedigger Feb 2012 #26
John Denver oregonjen Feb 2012 #27
Mick Jagger flamingdem Mar 2012 #33
Bruce Springsteen...And the only one I've ever actually shed tears over was Joe Strummer abq e streeter Mar 2012 #35
Chuck Berry too. abq e streeter Mar 2012 #36
Ann Murray KBlagburn Mar 2012 #37
Brian Eno progressoid Mar 2012 #38
Do you mean if they were to die now, or if they died before some career high-point? Orrex Mar 2012 #40
Dave Grohl, Bruce Springsteen. n/t RiffRandell Mar 2012 #42
It already happened. John Lennon. n/t easttexaslefty Mar 2012 #43
Robert Plant LynneSin Mar 2012 #44
One has already happened: Isaac Hayes. HughBeaumont Mar 2012 #45
Dolly Parton and Willie Nelson. jobycom Mar 2012 #46
I was gonna just say Willie- digonswine Mar 2012 #50
oh yes, willie nelson shanti Mar 2012 #53
Neil Diamond hamsterjill Mar 2012 #47
Beethoven. cliffordu Mar 2012 #48
Paul McCartney & Ringo Starr WhoIsNumberNone Mar 2012 #51
there will be many shanti Mar 2012 #52
Neil Young limpyhobbler Mar 2012 #54
Leonard Cohen Evoman Mar 2012 #55
 

Manifestor_of_Light

(21,046 posts)
32. No one else sounds like Pat Metheny.
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 03:29 AM
Mar 2012

I consider WE LIVE HERE and SECRET STORY and the A MAP OF THE WORLD soundtrack to be essentials to my music library.

I keep hoping clean guitar will come back in style in rock and roll.

Pat stole his licks from Howard Roberts and Wes Montgomery. I was turned onto him when he made Crystal Silence and others on that swedish label ECM.

Bladian

(475 posts)
5. James Hetfield, AKA Papa Het.
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 05:01 PM
Feb 2012

I'm a youngun, so Metallica is one of my favorite bands (if not my favorite). I'd be depressed as hell if he kicked the bucket.

treestar

(82,383 posts)
7. Agree with you, Bob Dylan or any remaining Beatle
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 05:06 PM
Feb 2012

would be major. Any of the Rolling Stones - surprised how many of them made it this far.

DFW

(54,328 posts)
8. Leo Kottke
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 05:22 PM
Feb 2012

I can't believe he'll be 67 this year. I saw him for the first time 40 years ago in Philadelphia when he was 27.

His genius and creative imagination (and humor!) know no limits. I hope they pass to someone else if he ever
departs this world.


The 12 string guitar hasn't been, and will never be the same after him.

MiddleFingerMom

(25,163 posts)
10. A friend in Europe introduced me to him in 1973 -- that incredibly RICH voice...
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 05:41 PM
Feb 2012

.
.
.
... had me convinced that he was 67 years old back then. When I finally saw a picture
of him, I was like "What... is this from the 1940's?"
.
.
.
Michael Hedges (taken away from us over a decade ago) was up in his league. After
touring with Hedges, Kottke described him thusly, "The guy has an octopus for a left hand."
.
.
.
rofl
.
.
.


.
.
.
.
.

DFW

(54,328 posts)
16. Hedges was a great loss--a traffic accident for Pete's sake!
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 06:18 PM
Feb 2012

I never saw Hedges live.

My brother turned me onto Kottke at Christmas, 1971. he got me the Armadillo album, and I was mesmerized.

I said that CAN'T be one guy doing that. Then I saw him in 1972. He was touring with the Mahavishnu Orchestra.
EVERYBODY else there was going to see John McLoughlin. I was there to see Kottke. I just stared and was
hypnotized. He really WAS doing that. It got to the point that when I started working and could afford it,
I sought out Božo Podunavac, the guy who made Kottke's 12 string guitars, and blew 10% of my first year's
gross salary on a hand-made 12 string guitar (which I still have). I never came close to Kottke's proficiency,
but got good enough to tour on my own for a while in Europe, doing solo concerts, folk festivals, stuff like that.
Until my top brass reminded me that I did have a day job with a few responsibilities attached, none of which involved exposing myself to the German public under my real name doing folk concerts LOL!! Well, crap, how was I supposed to know?

Božo remains a friend to this day. He is in his 80s now, and his English STILL sucks (my Serbian is even worse,
but we manage between the two). He never learned to play the guitar himself, but MAN could he build them!

Here is a matching pair he made for me in 1999-2000:
[IMG][/IMG]

So Kottke got to claim the 12 string virtuoso title for the 20th century all for himself. Ah, it's just as well.
I was never going to catch up to him anyway.

Bake

(21,977 posts)
41. Those are beautiful!
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 12:07 PM
Mar 2012

OK, I'm a pearl addict. Not recovering, just an addict. Hell, I'm a banjo player!



Bake

DFW

(54,328 posts)
49. Božo is a true artist
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 05:03 PM
Mar 2012

His instruments also sound as beautiful as they look. He always made sure every detail was perfect.

here are a couple of close-ups from the 12-string:
[IMG][/IMG]

[IMG][/IMG]

Typical of many artists, he had no idea of the true worth of his work. Back in the 1970s, he
used to charge $2800 for a cutaway 12-string guitar, full inlay. It took him $2000 for the
material and nine months to build one. I told him he was working for something like $1.37
an hour, but all he saw was an $800 profit, with no regard to time and expense. I told him
he was crazy to work for so little, and after about 35 years, I think he has finally figured it out.

Pool Hall Ace

(5,849 posts)
11. Carole King
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 05:45 PM
Feb 2012

Of the musicians who have already died, I would say John Lennon and Laura Nyro have had the biggest emotional impact on me.

pipi_k

(21,020 posts)
13. My two favorite guitarists in the world...
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 06:09 PM
Feb 2012

Carlos Santana or Jimmy Page.

Yeah. I would be majorly bummed...



MorningGlow

(15,758 posts)
17. Already happened
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 06:22 PM
Feb 2012

George Harrison. I learned how to play the guitar because I wanted to play his music and Beatles music. He got me interested in Eastern religions and all things Indian. I owe him so much.

zanana1

(6,106 posts)
21. Jim Croce
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 08:21 PM
Feb 2012

I was heartbroken when he died in a plane crash. He was a warm, clever composer and musician.

kentauros

(29,414 posts)
29. Thank you :)
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 11:23 PM
Feb 2012

I kind of grew up with Bebop Deluxe. I haven't bought that much of what Nelson has done over the years, but I haven't been disappointed with his output either. I'd love to be able to go to one of his Nelsonica events

I really figured practically no one here would have heard of Bill Nelson, other than the senator, which this one most assuredly is not

kentauros

(29,414 posts)
31. Yes, I've seen that there before,
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 12:37 AM
Mar 2012

and yes, I want to get it. Another thing to put on the list of wants and/or needs

pink-o

(4,056 posts)
24. I misread it: I thought it was musicians who'd already died.
Wed Feb 29, 2012, 08:54 PM
Feb 2012

So now that I understand it, my answer would be Ray Davies. Luckily, he's in amazing health, which is more than you can say for Dave his brother, who had a stroke a few years ago and can't play anymore The drugs caught up to him, finally.

But my original answer would have been Freddie Mercury. I miss him to this day, 21 years later.


(Edited, because when I read it over, it sounded like I was saying Ray had died. Yoikes!! He's Welsh, so here's hoping for a long, Celtic life!!!!)

abq e streeter

(7,658 posts)
35. Bruce Springsteen...And the only one I've ever actually shed tears over was Joe Strummer
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 04:01 AM
Mar 2012

Dylan probably equal to Springsteen now that I think about it

HughBeaumont

(24,461 posts)
45. One has already happened: Isaac Hayes.
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 01:41 PM
Mar 2012

I've been listening to The Isaac Hayes Movement since I was 3 years old. He had such a great and soulful voice, never engaged in a large amount of gymnastics. The arrangements . . . his rendition of "Something" by the Beatles is nothing short of phenomenal and I listen to it quite often to this day. I was depressed for days after I heard of his passing; I had tickets to see him on Valentines Day 2 years before he died.

The next one that will have some impact is Mike Oldfield. I've been listening to Tubular Bells for 25 years and Ommadawn for around 10. Just got around to buying Hergest Ridge and Incantations.

digonswine

(1,485 posts)
50. I was gonna just say Willie-
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 07:56 PM
Mar 2012

I think only a small portion of folks even know a tiny bit of what he has done. He also has a great place in that magical phase of early childhood memory for me.

Even many of his remakes are great.

hamsterjill

(15,220 posts)
47. Neil Diamond
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 04:36 PM
Mar 2012

If you've not seen him in concert, you are missing one of the best shows ever.

He has most of the same band members together from years before, and I've never been disappointed in the 8 or 9 times that I've seen him.

WhoIsNumberNone

(7,875 posts)
51. Paul McCartney & Ringo Starr
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 08:09 PM
Mar 2012

When the last Beatle is gone the world will be a different place.

Also Ozzy Osbourne and Lemmy are two I've grown up with. Don't know how emotional I'd get about either of them, but it would still be a significant event.

shanti

(21,675 posts)
52. there will be many
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 09:12 PM
Mar 2012

but i'll have to say neil young and elton john (oops, that's two!) they will soon be coming in thick and fast due to the high numbers of boomers

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»What one musical death wo...