Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

GopperStopper2680

(397 posts)
Mon Jul 9, 2012, 06:38 PM Jul 2012

'Bones' should go the way of the dinosaurs

I'm not a big fan of television. I pretty much agree with the old adage that it's an 'idiot box'. In fact I don't even own one. But I do have occasion to see some of it visiting friends. Some of it like Dual Survival is ok. Most of it is pretty horrendous. The show 'Bones' definitely fits into the latter category. The following is my little rant about one of the worst shows on TV.

For those of you who are still blissfully unaware of this horrible show's existence I will give you an outline (But don't expect it to be very accurate or detailed since I'm usually trying to avoid watching this.)

The show stars Emily Deschanel and David Boreanaz as Temperance 'Bones' Brennan and Seeley Booth respectively; a Forensic Anthropologist (or something) and an FBI agent. The two work to help solve crimes for the FBI (I presume) out of the back of a museum of all things. During every episode one or more sets of various human remains of unknown provenance are unearthed and studied by the protagonists. I have to say that I'm not aware of what city the story takes place in, nor will I bother to look it up-but I don't want to live anywhere in which a set of unidentified human remains is found on a daily basis. Oh, and get this: said remains usually turn out to be the result of foul play, meaning that where ever the place is that the story takes place, it has an unusually high homicide rate! How all-American!

The show involves a number of truly bad elements which make it in my opinion the dramatic equivalent of toxic waste. Hackneyed, screwball characters, tawdry, pretentious dialog, preposterously bad science, and my favorite-gobs and gobs of sickening human remains often found in bizarre and outre circumstances.

The show unabashedly showcases such earmarks of crapiness as an Brittish intern who can't relate to others without continually spouting trivia, be it apropos to the situation or not; a fantastic rapid prototyping machine that somehow wondrously casts full size articulated skeletons using visible green beams, and an absurd, magical crime reconstruction computer akin to a crystal ball which shows you precisely how a crime took place via a hologram when you input a few known parameters! The episodes often repeat some hook or central theme to such a degree that it becomes a refrain ad nauseum: One character repeated the phrase 'It's amazing!' repeatedly each scene in which he was shown.

The two major points of contention I have against the show are the Mylar thin and transparent characters and the terribly amateurish technical writing. The main characters themselves, Bones and Booth- a Forensic Anthropologist and a bureaucrat are in themselves the epitome of stereotypical in their roles: A cloistered, out-of-touch ivory tower intellectual and a hard nosed shoot-first-and-ask-questions-later badass. While Booth is a little more normal (for values of normal where these types are concerned) Brennan is of a highly intellectual bent, very bookish and ecclectic (read: weird) and seems to be disconnected from the way every day people think so such a degree as to leave you wondering if she isn't bat sh*t crazy.

Then there is the truly horrendous scientific writing. Now, everybody knows that it's not an entertainer's job to educate us, but at least having it somewhere in the right BALLPARK can't hurt, right? In one episode the show's resident mycologist whose name I don't know and won't bother to check mistook a slime mold for a fungus (it is in fact a protist-a eukaryote in its own distinct kingdom) evidently based solely on its common name. In another episode Booth seemed to suggest that carbon steel had been completely supplanted by stainless in every application; hence a dagger with a carbon steel blade must date from sometime during WWII! In yet another horrific episode we see that a small bucket full of Magnesium shavings has ignited torching a truck to the state its steel is partially molten! And on and on and on and on......

The tawdry, 2 dimensional characters, technical grade dialog and highschool science are all just great but the one thing that endears this show to me the most is the utterly sickening states in which the eponymous bones are discovered. Never do we find a nice clean skeleton simply lying in the woods somewhere (Which admittedly is rarely the case, but as you will soon see the Bones writers have a real affinity for pushing it)...No. In one episode we find a group of skeletons covered in pink, slimy things from the bottom of the ocean which turn out to be deep ocean Boneworms. (The episode made a big deal of the colorful name 'Boneating Slime Flower'). In yet another episode we find a set of remains lying in a coating of yellow jellyish stuff; the aforementioned slime mold. And in the worst one of all in my opinion we find in one episode a skeleton encased carbonite like in a giant chocolate bar! Said skeleton is discovered when a group of chocolatiers saw into the outsize bar releasing a flood of decayed glop. I couldn't touch a Hershey's bar for weeks!

Oh, one one more little nagging thing I couldn't stand about the show: Practically every episode was named 'the skeleton' something or other......Real creativity there. I guess they figured hey! It worked for Harry Potter!

All in all this is a show that I wish would hurry up and take its rightful place in the fossil bed with the other extinct horrible shows.

14 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
'Bones' should go the way of the dinosaurs (Original Post) GopperStopper2680 Jul 2012 OP
amazing how you don't watch this 'crappy' show yet Viva_La_Revolution Jul 2012 #1
And writes such a long post about it? TreasonousBastard Jul 2012 #2
HAHA GopperStopper2680 Jul 2012 #4
maybe they were trying to get you to leave. nt Viva_La_Revolution Jul 2012 #7
I bet you're a regular laugh riot Goblinmonger Jul 2012 #12
Doesn't even have a TV. Iggo Jul 2012 #13
Absolutely horrendous! Behind the Aegis Jul 2012 #3
Your rant certainly has mine beaten in terms of long windedness. GopperStopper2680 Jul 2012 #5
I hope you see no more either; it's wasted on you. Behind the Aegis Jul 2012 #8
It's wasted on me? GopperStopper2680 Jul 2012 #9
Oh and one more little niggling thing... GopperStopper2680 Jul 2012 #6
If you think Bones is bad romana Jul 2012 #10
I'll take your word for it N/T GopperStopper2680 Jul 2012 #11
Nay say all you want, I love that show..... Little Star Jul 2012 #14
 

GopperStopper2680

(397 posts)
4. HAHA
Tue Jul 10, 2012, 07:20 PM
Jul 2012

Yes I thought an argument like that might come up. As it happens I had to sit there watching an entire damned season of it while my friend watched it on Netflix. It was that or go home. It's hard to tune that kind of crap out completely. Hopefully I won't be watching any MORE of it. I notice 'crappy' is in quotations so it must be your thing. Well if you want to watch that 'crappy' show be my guest but for me I hope I've seen as much as I'll ever see of it.

Behind the Aegis

(53,921 posts)
3. Absolutely horrendous!
Tue Jul 10, 2012, 03:46 AM
Jul 2012

Those words describe your "review" of the show Bones! Yours is one the worst written rants I have ever seen on this site, despite the addition of 10-cent words, presumably to make your rant seem more intelligent. You admit to barely watching television and not even owning one, yet you have been able to single out one of the worst television shows on tv out of thousands of shows currently on the air. Yeah, OK. Then you go on to say your rant may not be accurate because you avoid the show. Wow! That's like "reviewers" who panned Brokeback Mountain, but never actually saw it. Truly insightful. (Do I really need to insert the rolling eyes again?) But, you were correct; you weren't at all accurate.

From the information in your post, I have deduced you saw the following episodes from season six: The Body in the Bounty, The Shallow in the Deep, The Babe in the Bar, and The Twisted Bones in the Melted Truck". Please note the titles, because I am going to refer to them again with my coup de grâce.

You are surprised a show where a forensic anthropologist and a FBI agent (at least you got the two main characters professions correct), team up to solve murders, and they...gasp....show gruesome dead bodies and not "pristine" skeletal remains?! The horrors! I mean, it's totally like a show, let's say, Dual Survival showing two people utilizing survival skills in strange, exotic settings. A fucking total mystery as to how that would even be a premise!

You don't know what city in which the show takes place? The shots of the Jefferson Memorial, the Washington Monument, and the White House didn't give it away? Several characters mention the city, there are scenes with maps, and of course, there are the 'stock shots' of the aforementioned landmarks. Here's a hint: it takes place in the capital city of the United States of America. Don't peek....


(The answer: Washington, D.C.)



Your remark about "One character repeated the phrase 'It's amazing!' repeatedly each scene in which he was shown." used to demonstrate your piss-poor observation, "The episodes often repeat some hook or central theme to such a degree that it becomes a refrain ad nauseum..." fails to mention the character is a guest star (David Alan Grier playing "Professor Bunsen Jude "The Science Dude"&quot and that was his "catch phrase" for the children's show for which he was a host. He was there to try to entice Dr. Brennan to allow his show to filmed in the lab (episode 4, season 6; The Body and the Bounty).

As for the scientific issues, one of the producers is Kathy Reichs, a forensic anthropologist, whom is the inspiration for the series based on her books and actual cases. The so-called technical glitch (about the slime mold), which seems to chap your ass, was part of the discovery process. Dr. Jack Hodigins, the character you couldn't be bothered to "look up", is not a mycologist (fungus), which is why he mis-identified the slime mold. He is, however, an entomologist (bugs), botanist (plants) and mineralogist (minerals, earth (dirt)). I won't bother to dissect your other inaccurate "scientific" knowledge.

The tawdry, 2 dimensional characters, technical grade dialog and highschool science are all just great but the one thing that endears this show to me the most is the utterly sickening states in which the eponymous bones are discovered. Never do we find a nice clean skeleton simply lying in the woods somewhere (Which admittedly is rarely the case, but as you will soon see the Bones writers have a real affinity for pushing it)...No.


Yes, because so many murders and decaying bodies produce a "nice clean skeleton simply lying in the woods somewhere." LMFAO!

I did promise a coup de grâce, and here it is...

Oh, one one more little nagging thing I couldn't stand about the show: Practically every episode was named 'the skeleton' something or other......Real creativity there. I guess they figured hey! It worked for Harry Potter!


I mentioned above the episodes which I could discern you watched were titled: The Body in the Bounty, The Shallow in the Deep, The Babe in the Bar, and The Twisted Bones in the Melted Truck". Notice anything? Not a single one contains the word "skeleton." Oooops! As a matter of fact, in 142 episodes, the word skeleton never appears in the title! This, of course, leads to the obvious irony of your OP title, "'Bones' should go the way of the dinosaurs" and your closing remark, "All in all this is a show that I wish would hurry up and take its rightful place in the fossil bed with the other extinct horrible shows" How to word this irony?! How shall I do it?! I know...."Real creativity there. I guess they figured hey! It worked for Harry Potter!" That works!

"Bones" is an interesting, non-typical show. It has a multi-racial cast. Has one of the only openly bisexual characters on TV. Has one of the only openly atheist characters on TV. Introduces a fun cast of eccentric people. Has a number of scientific, artistic, and historical references, which are usually "spot on." I could give a more detailed review, but I think I have made my point.

You don't like the show; cool. You're entitled to your opinion. I will part with another old adage for you....

"Write what you know."

You clearly did not.
 

GopperStopper2680

(397 posts)
5. Your rant certainly has mine beaten in terms of long windedness.
Tue Jul 10, 2012, 07:22 PM
Jul 2012

If you were hoping to change my opinion of the show or something you failed miserably. Sorry to undercut all that hard work you did. I guess you're another one that thinks this show is great. I expected various plebians would would attack like this. Well more power to you. As for me I hope I see no more of it.

Behind the Aegis

(53,921 posts)
8. I hope you see no more either; it's wasted on you.
Tue Jul 10, 2012, 09:39 PM
Jul 2012

I was long-winded? I also had no desire to change your opinion of the show, you were quite clear, even though you gave your thesaurus a real workout.

 

GopperStopper2680

(397 posts)
9. It's wasted on me?
Wed Jul 11, 2012, 03:30 PM
Jul 2012

That's a riot. Look, here's the deal: bad writing is bad writing no matter what you call it. I mean I can take a piece of tin and cover it in gold leaf-that doesn't make it anything but tin. To say that this showis wasted on me is like saying brass is wasted on a man that can afford gold. Why would I drink frozen grape juice when I can have wine? I don't think the guy drinking Chianti thinks Welch's is wasted on him. The guy selling Welch's might, but he's really just salving his own ego because he's been trumped. I can and do do a lot better where my entertainment is concerned.

If you think the show is so great, feel free to keep watching. Here's a bit of advice for you though-maybe YOU can do better than bones.

Seriously though this is all in the spirit of fun. That's what people do at DU-they voice their opinions and from time to time they get on each other's cases. No harm feelings or anything seriously. It's no reflection on you that I think the show is crappy. It's just a thing.

But seriously I'm moving on. I'm kind of astonished that this means so much to you that you posted yet another reply to this but hey; this site is all about debate. You're here to make your voice heard.

Enjoy the show.

Oh, and if you're interested here's a disgusting little fun fact about the yellow crap that was covering that one dead guy (or what was left of him) in that one really nasty episode-They eat that crud down in mexico. They fry it up and call it Caca De Luna. (Moon sh*t more or less.)

Anyway no hard feelings.

 

GopperStopper2680

(397 posts)
6. Oh and one more little niggling thing...
Tue Jul 10, 2012, 07:42 PM
Jul 2012

As I said, I tried to AVOID all the gross, hairy details of the story. I wasn't watching it as such. I didn't WANT to watch it which explains my not knowing where the show takes place. Other people might be some kinds of experts on the show...that's great. It makes you an expert on a crappy show. Bravo! I know bad writing when I see it, period. So anybody else out there that likes the show, enjoy. But please note that I'm not the only one that hates it. A lot of notable reviewers hate it also. It's bad writing, period. So no amount of explaining, crying, whining, or apologetics is going to change my mind. But then again you're welcome of course to post any kind of tirade you want. After all we're all friends here and this site is pretty much a forum for people to speak out. So be my guest. And cheers.

romana

(765 posts)
10. If you think Bones is bad
Wed Jul 11, 2012, 04:21 PM
Jul 2012

You should check out "Rizzoli & Isles." The writing on that show makes "Bones" look like Shakespeare. I honestly don't know how anyone who writes for R&I is allowed to keep their SWG card.

Little Star

(17,055 posts)
14. Nay say all you want, I love that show.....
Fri Jul 13, 2012, 01:59 PM
Jul 2012

Last edited Fri Jul 13, 2012, 02:41 PM - Edit history (1)

I loved the book, I loved the movie and I love the show.

And I'm pissed that they canceled the spin off "The Finder".

I happen to really like most police procedurals.

Personally, I just like to be entertained and that show entertains me.

There's room on TV for all of us to have things we like to watch. Besides it's easy to just change the channel or turn off the tube if need be.

Edit to add:

Cloo TV will be replaying the movie more than once, this month, Here: http://www.cloo.com/schedule/?q=The+Bone+Collector

And here is a clip of the movie for anyone who might be interested: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0145681/



Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»TV Chat»'Bones' should go the way...