Legal Limbo
A federal judge just opened the door to more climate lawsuits. In a ruling this week, Judge William Alsup said that plaintiffs can sue greenhouse-gas emitters in federal court. Thats a big reversal. So far, the courts have held that its up to the EPA and lawmakers not judges to bring polluters into line.
In this case, the cities of Oakland and San Francisco sued a bunch of oil companies for contributing to climate change, raising sea levels and damaging their waterfronts. Because federal courts had previously said they wouldnt regulate polluters, the cities were trying to move their lawsuit into the California court. If federal court wouldnt punish polluters, the lawyers figured, maybe state court would.
Alsup denied the cities motion to move to state court. But instead of bowing to precedent and punting responsibility over to the EPA, hes letting the lawsuit go to trial in federal court.
[The oil companies] got what they wanted; but they may be sorry they did, said Ken Adams, lawyer for the Center for Climate Integrity, in a statement.
https://grist.org/briefly/a-federal-judge-just-opened-the-door-to-more-climate-lawsuits/