Environment & Energy
Related: About this forumShale Gas Boom as Seen from New England (books):
FrackCheckWV
Shale Gas Boom as Seen from New England (books)
"The Real Cost of Fracking", Beacon Press, Boston (2014)
Seven (7) books on fracking (horizontal drilling with slick-water high-pressure hydraulic fracturing using silica sand)
From an Article by Katharine Whittemore, Boston Globe, May 23, 2015
Blame or thank the volcanoes. Out here in Western Massachusetts, we sit on a geological shelf called the Hartford Basin, which runs from Vermont to the Connecticut shore, and its shale is pretty lacking, for fracking, because ancient volcanic activity heated up the trapped natural gas so much, it likely cooked it off. Thats why fracking companies, in search of natural gas, dont much care for New England; in the Northeast, they love Pennsylvania, and its baked-just-right geology. In fact, the Marcellus Shale, named for a town in New York and stretching west to Ohio and south to Tennessee, is the nations biggest natural-gas producing region. How big? It holds 84 trillion cubic feet of the stuff. But the Hartford Basin? Only 3.5 billion. We arent worth the candle.
Massachusetts may not do fracking, with all the environmental concerns it stirs up, but the practice affects us nonetheless. Over the weeks I read these books, I spotted lots of Say No to the Pipeline lawn signs, courtesy of nofrackedgasinmass.org; the Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co. wants to funnel their Marcellus loot through New England, as far as Dracut. Pipeline yes or no, one fourth of US energy use now comes from natural gas. Amazing, since its been as inaccessible as the sword in the stone from Arthurian legend, writes Russell Gold, until innovations in hydraulic fracturing changed the game forever.
Gold is the senior energy reporter for the Wall Street Journal and author of The Boom: How Fracking Ignited the American Energy Revolution and Changed the World (Simon and Schuster, 2014). He issues a smart overview of the history, the process, and the players, with a charged personal twist; his parents debate whether to let Chesapeake Energy frack their Pennsylvania farmland. We think of fracking as a new technology, but theres a long comet trail of trial and error here. Just after the Civil War, an oilman named Edward Roberts invented the Roberts torpedo, cylinders filled with gunpowder that were lowered into water wells, in order to jet new seams in nearby oil-rich rock. After World War II, oilman Bob Fast added surplus napalm to the water, but this, and many like efforts after, produced too little return.
. ...
In Groundswell: The Case for Fracking (Signal, 2014), Ezra Levant comes out swinging. He calls the opposition hysterical and environmental extremists. He also says the EPA has found no proven cases of fracking-related contamination. Exactly zero. Not a single one, anywhere, ever. Its true that its hard to prove whether contaminants come from the fracking process, though rebuttals thrive in my other books. His more compelling point is that fracking is not just about the cash, its about freedom. Indeed, natural gas means that America is no longer beholden to those OPEC nations, or any other oil producers, that violate human rights. The choice is between western shale gas versus Russian Gazprom gas, Iranian ayatollah gas, or Qatari sharia gas. He adds: Its the choice between ethical energy and conflict energy.
Richard Heinberg disdains the other side, too, though hes got a better sense of humor about it in Snake Oil: How Frackings False Promise of Plenty Imperils Our Future (Post Carbon Institute, 2013). [L]et the metaphor begin! he says, and rolls out two teams, the first dubbed the Cornucopians, who think the natural gas supply could last up to a hundred years, like a horn of plenty. Their philosophy? Theres nothing to worry about, folks. Just keep driving. The Cornucopians are selling you snake oil, says Heinberg, thus his book title. But the Peakists (Heinbergs team) can prove the downward slide is already here; he crunches the stats (or maybe gives the frackonomics?), stressing that the extraction rate stopped growing in 2005, so the peak has passed. All in all, its downright dumb to keep relying on fossil fuels.
Words like dumb or hysterical never appear in this next, refreshingly dispassionate, entry. In Hydrofracking: What Everyone Needs to Know (Oxford University, 2013), Alex Prudhomme says fracking is neither all good nor all bad, though he admits that his case-against-it chapter is longer than the case-for-it one. ...
Shale Gas: The Promise and the Peril (RTI, 2012) tries to be even-handed, too, but it certainly cants toward promise over peril: Author Vikram Rao was the former chief technology officer of Halliburton, and currently directs North Carolinas Research Triangle Energy Consortium. ...
My last two books may not be carbon-neutral, but they are jargon-neutral, since theyre well-written, well-reported, and very human. Under the Surface: Fracking, Fortunes, and the Fate of the Marcellus Shale (Cornell University, 2012) is by Tom Wilber, a former newspaper reporter in upstate New York, and because an academic press published it, the book was peer reviewed. ...
Finally, to my most marvelous title, The End of Country: Dispatches from the Frack Zone (Random House, 2011). Author Seamus McGraw is both meticulous and moody...
He goes on to describe the material and psychological disturbances of living in Frackistan. The sounds of blasting, construction, the endless trucks carting in water. But more than that, its the fraying of community. ...
Katharine Whittemore is a freelance writer based in Northampton, MA. Another book that could (should) be considered is: The Real Cost of Fracking, Beacon Press, Boston, 2014. Also of prime importance is climate change as discussed for example in: This Changes Everything, Naomi Klein, Simon & Schuster, 2014.
MORE
http://www.frackcheckwv.net/