Israel/Palestine
Related: About this forumFrom an Era of Refugee Millions, Only Palestinians Remain
By Andrew Roberts, WSJ 11/22/14
(snip)
As anti-Israel sentiment grows in Europeand in the U.S... calls for an immediate resolution to the Palestinian refugee problem abound. To hear some in the anti-Israel movement today, one might imagine that the Palestinian exodus was a unique occurrence in modern history, that no other people have ever been moved off what they considered to be their ancestral lands. The truth is that such movementsincluding that of the Palestinianshappened so often in the mid-1940s to early 1950s that it is surprising that the plural of the word exodusexodi?is not used in reference to this period.
For all sorts of reasons, ethnic groups were either forcibly or voluntarily moved during that troubled period, and usually in far worse circumstances and for far longer distances than the Palestinians. There were no fewer than 20 different groupsincluding the Sikhs, Muslims and Hindus of the Punjab, the Crimean Tatars, the Japanese and Korean Kuril and Sakhalin Islanders, the Soviet Chechens, Ingush and Balkarsmany in the tens or even hundreds of thousands, if not millions, who were displaced and taken to different regions.
Yet all of these refugee groups, except one, chose to try to make the best of their new environments. Most have succeeded, and some, such as the refugees who reached America in that decade, have done so triumphantly. The sole exception has been the Palestinians, who made the choice to embrace fanatical irredentism and launch two intifadasand perhaps now a thirdresulting in the deaths of thousands of Palestinians and Israelis. After Germany lost World War II in 1945, more than three million of its people were forced to leave their homes in the Sudetenland, Silesia and regions east of the Oder and Neisse riverslands that their forefathers had tilled for centuries. These refugees embarked on a 300-mile journey westward under conditions of extreme deprivation and danger with only what they could carry in suitcases.
One cant be expected to sympathize too much with people who had enthusiastically supported Adolf Hitler, but among them were children who were not responsible for the sins of their fathers. Having reached the new borders of East and West Germany, as delineated by the victorious Allies, they settled and made no irredentist claims to Poland and Czechoslovakia, the countries they had left. Today those once penniless refugee children include some of the most successful people in Germany, a country they helped make a prosperous, model democracy.
(snip)
Sadly, it has been the Arab states cynical and self-interested policy for nearly seven decades to keep the Palestinians boiling with indignation. No one can doubt that for those who have continued to live in camps intended for long-ago refugees, the founding of the state of Israel in 1948, when thousands of Palestinians fled or were expelled, was indeed a catastrophe. But many other peoples have learned to deal with equal or worse by moving onward and upward; calling them refugees several generations after their forebears upheaval would be unthinkable. The lessons of history are rarely enunciated more clearly.
Mr. Roberts is the author, most recently, of Napoleon: A Life, just out from Penguin.
http://online.wsj.com/articles/andrew-roberts-from-an-era-of-refugee-millions-only-palestinians-remain-1416613759
King_David
(14,851 posts)Or not allowed to by the Arab host countries they went to.
question everything
(47,425 posts)used the refugees to divert criticism of their own domestic policies. They have inflamed hatred and agitation around the world and I think that today's ISIL is the result.
Even now, with all the complaints about the Israeli Gaza border being restricted, you don't hear complaint about the Egyptian Gaza border on the other side.