National Guard Commanders Rise In Revolt Against Active Army; MG Rossi Questions Guard Combat Role
http://breakingdefense.com/2014/03/national-guard-commanders-rise-in-revolt-against-active-army-mg-ross-questions-guard-combat-role/
National Guard Commanders Rise In Revolt Against Active Army; MG Rossi Questions Guard Combat Role
By Sydney J. Freedberg Jr. on March 11, 2014 at 4:42 PM
The battle between the regular Army and the National Guard, which we all knew would blow up one of these days, has blown up. At 3:30 this afternoon, the spokesman of the 54 state and territorial Guard commanders, Kentucky Adjutant General Ed Tonini, raised the standard of revolt against the active-duty leadership who had, he said, slammed their minds shut on any compromise. Meanwhile, much more quietly, and with many caveats, the regulars have broken a 13-year taboo: In an exclusive interview with Breaking Defense, Army Quadrennial Defense Review director Maj. Gen. John Rossi questioned aspects of the Guards much-lauded combat performance since 9/11.
Army leaders from Chief of Staff Ray Odierno on down have long argued that troops who train part-time cant mobilize fast enough for the short-notice, high-complexity conflicts expected in the future. But this is the first time a senior active-duty general has said, to my knowledge, that the proof of this argument is that Guard combat brigades were rarely assigned the most demanding missions in Afghanistan and Iraq.
What Rossi said is far more nuanced than the statement from Guard partisans. Maj. Gen. Tonini declared the Army leaders discussions with governors and Guard leaders have been merely for show. Retired Maj. Gen. Gus Hargett, head of the independent National Guard Association of the US, has called Odiernos remarks disparag[ing], disrespectful and simply not true. But with over 700 Guardsmen and women killed in the line of duty since 2001, putting any kind of asterisk next to the Guards wartime record is potentially inflammatory. It marks a major escalation in what Army leaders are willing to say. But they also have a point.
We have to be careful that
.we dont walk away with the wrong lessons, Rossi told me. Work hand in hand? Yes. Work side by side? Yes. Interchangeable? The answer on that is no.