Religion
Related: About this forumAll Religion is Local
by Aryeh Cohen
Monday, May 26th, 2014
This is a guest post by Sarah Imhoff, Assistant Professor of Jewish Studies and Religious Studies at Indiana University, Bloomington.
In a whirlwind day of traveling this week, Ive been in the United States, Turkey, and Israel. On the train in New Jersey, I noticed one house where American flags sprouted on the porch like rows of overgrown plants fighting for the sun. In Turkey, I got stuck walking on the sidewalk behind this vendor: Turkish flag vendor
And because of the snails pace line for passport control at Ben Gurion airport, I stared at up an enormous wall painting of an Israeli flag for two hours. While there is plenty to say about the comparative politics of patriotism, I thought about social interactions of church and state. As a scholar of religion, I seem to see it everywhere.
These three nationsthe US, Turkey, and Israelhave three very different articulations of the relationship between church and state. The United States has constitutional commitment to freedom of religious expression, and simultaneously refusal of federal establishment of religion. Turkey has a different sort of separation: its laicite, a style of secularism most frequently associated with France, excludes religious practice and discourse from the space of government. And Israel is a Jewish state. And each of these arrangements turns out to be far more complicated and contested than a single sentence about it can suggest.
As this months SCOTUS ruling on Town of Greece v. Galloway. reminded us, there is a long tradition of legislative prayer practice in the United States. Were the people of the town of Greece, NY allowed to start their meetings with a prayer, as long as they didnt intentionally exclude any religions? The court ruled 5-4 that the town wasnt violating the constitution with its prayer, but the justices on both sides of the issue offered locally based reasoning in their decisions. The most affecting moment of Elana Kagans dissent was her hypothetical story about a Muslim woman coming to the town council to ask for a building permit. Wouldnt she feel coerced into municipally-sanctioned Christianity when the chaplain opened the meeting and said Let us pray? In his opinion holding for Greece, Clarence Thomas explained that he thinks the establishment clause pertains only to the federal government, and so wouldnt necessarily or automatically apply to states, or a town such as Greece. Both justices, despite their vastly different takes, appealed to local context to explain their legal reasoning about religion.
http://jewschool.com/2014/05/26/32240/all-religion-is-local/
pinto
(106,886 posts)It's based on topography, elevations, biomass, etc. On the flip side are targeted species at risk, noted on the same map by region.
There are probably similar maps in a religious framework. I assume there are many. It's so fluid they must change constantly. Or get updated at times.
The topographical map is going on my wall.