Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

DonViejo

(60,536 posts)
Sun Feb 16, 2014, 10:39 AM Feb 2014

The matter with Kansas now: The Tea Party, the 1 percent and delusional Democrats

Democrats believe demographics alone will defeat the Tea Party. It's a smug fantasy: Economic populism's the answer

THOMAS FRANK


It is a strange thing to say in the year 2014, as the political battle-lines grow harder and our bitter-enders ever more bitter, but there was a time when I didn’t think of my home state of Kansas as a particularly right-wing place.

It is true that the Kansas City suburb where I grew up teemed with standard-issue business-class Republicans back in the ’70s and ’80s; I had been one myself once upon a time. But I also knew that Kansas was the kind of place that valued education, that built big boring suburbs, that never did anything risky or exciting. Its politics in those days were utterly forgettable, dominated by a succession of bland Republican moderates and unambitious Democrats. We were the epitome of unremarkableness. When the notorious “Summer of Mercy” took place in 1991 — the event that marked the beginning of the state’s long march to the right — I remember reading about it from graduate school in Chicago and thinking how strange it was that Operation Rescue had chosen Wichita as the place to make its stand. After all, Kansas wasn’t in the South.

It wasn’t until several years later that I began to understand what a fascinating, upside-down extravaganza it was to see the right eat its way through the good sense of the nation. Of course, many others had written about the movement by then, largely in the key of horror and tearful deploring. But relatively few seemed to get the sheer literary potential of the nation’s big right turn, and as I surveyed the political headlines day after day, I grew more and more amazed at what was going on.

Here was a faction that had made the folkways of ordinary Americans into a kind of a cult — and yet its signature economic policies had brought catastrophic harm down on those same ordinary Americans. Here was a ruling philosophy that, thanks to its sacrosanct conception of itself as the foe of the state, could never acknowledge that it actually ruled. Here was a form of common-man-hailing populism that had raised up an economic elite the likes of which we hadn’t seen since the nineteenth century. What a spectacle it was! What a circus of delusion, deceit, devotion and disaster! Best of all, it was a movement in whose ranks I had once marched myself, which meant I had a certain innate understanding of it.

more
http://www.salon.com/2014/02/16/the_matter_with_kansas_now_the_tea_party_the_1_percent_and_delusional_democrats/
11 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

RKP5637

(67,102 posts)
1. Excellent article! One bottom line in KS was the people were too trusting and naive IMO, hence,
Sun Feb 16, 2014, 10:59 AM
Feb 2014

they were easy victims to the RW push buttons of religion and minimal taxes, all of the stuff used to influence naive low information trusting voters.

Now, IMO, generational voters have emerged, kids growing up under the RW taking on that belief structure, not all, but enough to probably continue the RW momentum in Kansas. If they keep Brownback in the next election, one can be pretty sure there will be a very long wait for any restoration of balance in Kansas.

MrsKirkley

(180 posts)
2. I've lived in Kansas all my life and I hate it.
Sun Feb 16, 2014, 11:06 AM
Feb 2014

Leaders are are so right wing they're skeptical about even an alternative to Medicaid expansion like Arkansas has. I actually met a Democrat in my county who is against single-payer health care. Then there's the embarrassing fact that Kansas is home to the Westboro Baptist Cult that pickets funerals. Unfortunately, all of my family and most of my husband's family live in Kansas (a few live in Texas). When we finally move to a blue state, we'll be leaving our family behind.

RKP5637

(67,102 posts)
3. Yep, many have that same problem, leaving family and friends behind. The difficulty is
Sun Feb 16, 2014, 11:17 AM
Feb 2014

that if one does not move on it, eventually ones get sucked into the black hole of Kansas. ... unable to escape because of life's circumstances ... illness, age, failing health of parents, relatives, friends and all of the emotional attachments.

If Brownback is reelected IMO that will be a significant benchmark of Kansas into the foreseeable future of Kansas. It's all very sad, because there are/were some great things about Kansas and some very pleasant and kind people. Some in Kansas still just don't seem to get what is going on in that state. Just in the past few years Kansas has changed so much.

As one person on DU once said, and I find it rather correct, some in Kansas still think they're voting for Eisenhower type republicans.

MuseRider

(34,104 posts)
4. I don't have time at the moment
Sun Feb 16, 2014, 01:21 PM
Feb 2014

to read this but I will bookmark for future reading.

I believe that a good part of this is the fault of Democrats and Democrats alone. Abandoned by the national party Dems were left to fend for themselves against the money machine called the Koch brothers who have been stirring the John Birch Society stuff from Wichita all along, slowly but surely. It was impossible to compete, especially in the more rural areas. It takes a ton of money to spend the time to go to small town to small town yet that is what it would take. Then, after being clobbered, they decided that there was nothing to the West of Manhattan. Good move Then came all the quisling, cowardly stances of oh yes, they will pay just let them do it (that way we do not have to take a position and be held accountable ala our current challenger to Brownback). Kathleen Sibelius was elected because she was running against crazy, obviously crazy and she stood up to it. Since she left crazy has become the norm. We are full of crazy.

My guess is Brownback, although the people do not care for what he is doing, will win. Davis is a coward and nobody will want to vote for that. Are we even going to know what he actually stands for? We will know what he tells us but so far he seems willing to sell out anything in hopes of avoiding a fight.

If Davis should win he will be faced with a legislature that will kill anything he might try to do so he will most likely bargain much like Obama has done and we then head at full speed over the final edge of the cliff into complete RWTeabag control.

Seriously, his response to this latest bill of discrimination was that it was a distraction from the important issues of the economy and education. I would think that his team should be fired and he should hide his head as a person without dignity or compassion. Whatever. Had he gotten in front of it like the decent people in this state and across the country did he could have been a populist hero. Great political decision Dems, just fucking great.

When LGBT issues have to be dealt with by going to the Republicans you know things are screwed up in this state. Now that most of the Republican moderates were ousted (again the Koch brothers) we are left with very few legislators who will actually help.

What is happening here is the result of a long term plan by men with nothing but money and bad intentions for anyone who cherishes freedom and the American Dream. They are a well oiled machine but had been held back by the Democrats and the moderate Republicans. Because both of those groups were cast aside by their national parties they lacked the money to compete against the well oiled machine. Kansas was a testing ground. Now it is going out to every state and little by little they are going to win some, already have, and this country will get worse. We have to elect national leaders with the guts to throw in against this or we are done. This bipartisan bull is no longer bipartisan it is give it all away to the crazy people because who knows what they will do if we don't?

Just my Sunday sermon, sorry if it has nothing to do with the article, I will read it later.

Sign me as totally bummed, irritated and tired in Kansas

RKP5637

(67,102 posts)
5. Excellent summary! And the gravest mistake Americans can make is thinking this is limited
Sun Feb 16, 2014, 01:43 PM
Feb 2014

to just Kansas. As you said, Kansas was just the testing ground.

Kansas was a testing ground. Now it is going out to every state and little by little they are going to win some, already have, and this country will get worse. We have to elect national leaders with the guts to throw in against this or we are done. This bipartisan bull is no longer bipartisan it is give it all away to the crazy people because who knows what they will do if we don't?

MuseRider

(34,104 posts)
7. Thanks!
Mon Feb 17, 2014, 11:02 AM
Feb 2014

You know what bothers me the most about this? If this was happening anywhere else people would read it and take it to heart. Because it is in Kansas that this happened there is almost no way to get anyone to even read about it.

I don't quite understand that.

Seems important no matter where it happened.

What's the matter with the rest of the country?

RKP5637

(67,102 posts)
8. TPTB have turned Kansas into a joke. None take Kansas seriously, and it's become
Mon Feb 17, 2014, 12:31 PM
Feb 2014

fodder for all types of jokes. Then, there's the Phelps family, Operation Rescue, the murder of George Tiller and the dismantlement of abortion services, the attacks on Planned Parenthood, all of the trashing of LGBT, irrational laws, the dumping on poor people, the health care issues and on and on. And the attempt to destroy what was a fine educational system, the initial de-funding of Arts, the list gets endless. TPTB have managed to turn Kansas into a disaster zone. And, the Brownback administration attack on the high school girl that made a comment about him. So IMO most think of Kansas as a joke, the land of crazies.

I find it all quite sad, and there are a lot of good people in Kansas that seem powerless to do anything, and the National Democrats have written Kansas off as a lost cause.

I don't know, I just don't know, but I think of Kansas as a bad omen, a sign of what can happen to any state. Kansas should be watched very carefully. I think most Americans have no idea of the amount of money behind what is happening to Kansas, that it's an orchestrated takeover of the state by a highly funded and well oiled machine.

Jamaal510

(10,893 posts)
6. I agree.
Sun Feb 16, 2014, 02:37 PM
Feb 2014

It's wishful thinking to believe that changing demographics alone will necessarily be the GOP's downfall. The reason why I think so is because of this: what makes everyone so sure that these demographic changes will continue like this far into the future? There is no reason why the pattern of these demographic shifts can't change and possibly go in a different direction.

The 2nd point I want to add is that despite our numbers, many people on the Left make the dumb mistake of sitting out elections (especially midterms). With 2010 for example, this allows the extremists on the Right a much better chance to get in there to tweak the election laws to their advantage. Their base may be smaller, but unlike ours, is reliable enough to show up to the polls for every election. We are in a country where voting is still free and (mostly) fairly accessible, and both major parties are about as far apart as they've ever been in history. There is very little reason why turnout should not be near 100% when ultimately, it is still us who shape our government. It is everyone's duty to become informed and civically engaged.

calimary

(81,197 posts)
10. Totally. The worst offenders are on OUR side.
Mon Feb 17, 2014, 02:18 PM
Feb 2014

Sitting this one out because they didn't have a candidate perfect enough. So they're probably not gonna vote for Hillary either because she comes up less than perfect, so their answer is to thoughtfully stand aside and make way for the bad guys to pull through? Sorry. I do NOT get it. And I WON'T do it. And that way we win - HOW???????? Next time? How many next times do we concede without even trying because we simply must be absolute purists?

How'd that vote for ralph nader work out for ya in 2000? Did it send a message?

Yep, sent a message alright. We got eight years of bush/cheney. THERE'S yer message. We sat it out in 2010, too. Nobody perfect enough. Meh, no use. So why even bother trying? Now we're stuck with the tea baggers who had enough momentum to start gaining ground. And they used our apathy and laziness and lack of determination to gain a foothold that they won't easily give up. We actually had a shot at nipping that tea bagger "phenomenon" in the bud - and we passed. So now we have jerks like ted cruz to put up with for however long he can manipulate his incumbency. Thanks a whole heap, sit-it-out'ers! Was it worth it?

Every time I hear one of those "we've gotta SEND a MESSAGE!!!!" mewlers at election time, I just want to throw up. The only message you send - by voting for an offshoot with ZERO chance of winning and thereby splitting our total vote take, or sitting it out because nobody was perfect enough for you - is a big fat juicy valentine from the bad guys that reads- "hey THANKS for the nice win, CHUMPS!!!!"

Machiavelli, where are you when WE need you???????

 

JRLeft

(7,010 posts)
11. He's right the democrats are the main culprit. The reason places like Kansas are so right wing now
Mon Feb 17, 2014, 06:04 PM
Feb 2014

is because the democrats sold out to Wall St. and corporate America in the 80's. And over decades as the right moved further right, the democratic party moved further right.

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»The matter with Kansas no...