Michael Tomasky: Beirut Barracks vs. Benghazi
Beirut Barracks vs. Benghazi
POLITICS 05.09.14
Michael Tomasky
Republicans are trying to criminalize a tragedywholly unprecedented, even after 241 Marines died because of a massive U.S. intelligence failure.
One of the most maddening things about this Benghazi nonsense is the way Republicans have gotten a lot of Americans to go along with the idea that 10 investigations of something is normal; that as long as theres one unanswered question, one area where the administrations position is ambiguous or where its cooperation has been anything other than the immediate handing over of any conceivably related document, we still need to get to the bottom of matters.
People believe this becausefirst of all, partisans in heat believe it because they want to pin some kind of blame on Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton. But even some people who arent diehard partisans believe it because, well, it seems to make sense. Thats what we do. We get to the bottom of things.
Thats what we do, that is, when it comes to the law. When theres a question of legal guilt or innocence, of course we want all the facts needed to make the proper legal determination. But what about when there is no question of legal guilt or innocence, and its just a political matter? Of course we still want to know what happened, but in these cases its not chiefly to determine guilt or innocence, since there is none; its to get an honest accounting of what happened to try to ensure it doesnt happen again.
Im trying to explain as calmly as I can here, to readers with no allegiance to either party, why what the Republicans are doing with Benghazi is so out of bounds. They are turning a political situation into a legal case. Theyre trying to impose the standards of the courtroom onto a place where they clearly dont belong. Its an awful, poisonous precedent, especially given that the incident in question was a tragedy. Using a national tragedy, the kind of event that used to unite Americans, to turn a political matter into a legal one is just a shocking thing to do, wholly outside the American tradition.
more
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/05/09/beirut-barracks-vs-benghazi.html