2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumNetanyahu's Partisan "Stink Bomb"
On Sunday's Face the Nation, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin ("Bibi" Netanyahu charged that he was "baffled" by President Obama's opposition to expansion of settlements in the Israeli Occupied Territories, a position he said was "against American values." It was not, however, the first time Prime Minister Netanyahu has either disrespected a sitting President or attempted to inject himself into U.S. domestic politics.
Partisan Bibi
This is, after all, the same Netanyahu who once bragged during a 1998 trip to Washington that he would "set this town on fire" and made a point to first visit Jerry Falwell who at the time was distributing a video accusing President Clinton of selling drugs and being an accomplice to murder. During the Obama administration he has timed the announcement of settlement expansions to coincide with Vice President Biden's visit to Israel, publicly lectured the President at the White House in front of the press and injected himself in the presidential campaign in fall 2012 by demanding that the U.S. draw a red line on Iran's nuclear program that if crossed would result in military action.
His latest comments coming less than a month before the election were criticized by Haaretz, Israel's leading English newspaper, as a "stink bomb" that failed on multiple levels. Haaretz condemned Netanyahu for playing the partisan during our election season when he
slammed the president as if he was a Tea Party brawler rather than the leader of a country with a 'special relationship' with America.
Presumptuous Bibi
Haaretz also criticized the Prime Minister for his
presumptuousness in appointing himself the arbiter of what reflects American values and what doesnt. Just try to imagine the mortified mayhem that would break out if Obama had retorted that construction in East Jerusalem that could kill off the moribund peace process is un-Jewish or un-Israeli or runs to contrary to Jewish values. Israeli politicians would hit the roof, American Jewish leaders would plotz all over the place and Fox News would stop its regular programming in order to foam at the mouth and run John Boltons inevitable call for the presidents impeachment in an endless loop.
As the White House diplomatically noted, "its American values that led this countrys unwavering support to Israel. It's American values that have led us to fight for and secure funding to strengthen Israel's security in tangible ways."
Flat Out Wrong Bibi
The biggest problem with Netanyahu's comments are that they are absolutely wrong. Netanyahu knows this, since shortly after taking office he received a letter from Secretaries of State and National Security Advisors for Presidents Carter, Reagan and Bush warning him that unilateral
expansion of settlements, would be strongly counterproductive to the goal of a negotiated solution and, if carried forward, could halt progress made by the peace process over the last two decades. Such a tragic result would threaten the security of Israel, the Palestinians, friendly Arab states, and undermine U.S. interests in the Middle East.
The point is not even debatable, since every President since the 1967 War, from President Johnson to President Obama, has expressed opposition to expansion of the settlements in the Occupied Territories. As explained by the 2001 Mitchell Report,
During the half-century of its existence, Israel has had the strong support of the United States. In international forums, the United States has at times cast the only vote on Israels behalf. Yet, even in such a close relationship there are some difficulties. Prominent among those differences is the U.S. governments long-standing opposition to the Government of Israels policies and practices regarding settlements.
American Jewish group J Street noted that Netanyahu's characterizing
the principled opposition to settlements of every US administration since 1967 the administrations of Presidents Nixon, Carter, Reagan, George H.W. Bush, Clinton, George W. Bush and Obama as being against American values gives new meaning to the word 'chutzpah.
Misguided Bibi
This latest incident, however, validates the assessment of President Clinton who dealt with Netanyahu when he was first elected following the assassination of Prime Minister Rabin and noted:
He thinks he is the superpower, and we are here to do whatever he requires.
For a leader of a small nation to make such a statement towards its principal benefactor (who not only have provided over $230 billion in aid but have paid the price in blood and economic hardship as a result of actions taken against it for their unwavering support of Israel over the years), it can only be described as a breathtaking affront not only to the President but to all Americans for which he should promptly apologize.
As Margaret Chase Smith noted during the McCarthy era, too often those who invoke "Americanism" don't have clue about what it truly means and Netanyahu foolishly proved this point. In fact, no Israeli Prime Minister has more consistently thwarted U.S., values and efforts to find peace in the Middle East. So as President Obama looks ahead to his final two years in office, he can only hope that former President Shimon Peres is right when he says "the Netanyahu government has reached the end of its path."
rateyes
(17,438 posts)Enthusiast
(50,983 posts)Scootaloo
(25,699 posts)Since 1967. Forty-seven years of this. And what, pray tell, has the US done to stop or slow this process? What pressure has been exerted? What measures have we used, taking advantage of our "special relationship" to press israel towards something less, well, war crime-y?
Not a single. Fucking. Thing.
Bennet Kelley
(142 posts)President Bush (41) denied loan guarantees because of settlement expansion.
Qutzupalotl
(14,300 posts)which seems like the next logical step. Why not? Are we not able? We seem to be playing the puppet here when we should be pulling the strings.
beemer27
(460 posts)Perhaps it is time to remind Mr. Netanyahu just how much money the US is pumping into his country and it's economy every year. This reminder would be preferably on a national news program that many people watch. And we could also remind Mr. Netanyahu that this flow of dollars could be squeezed if he keeps talking trash. We DO have a special relationship with Israel, and it IS in our interest to keep them strong, but we are not their cash-cow, and we are not their puppet to do with as they please. The building of more and more settlements on disputed land has to cease if there is ever to be peace in that region. If Mr. Netanyahu wants to dictate what the American taxpayer does, he should run for office in America.
BlueDemKev
(3,003 posts)And it's sad how the Likud Party continues to be a major force in Israeli politics. Still, the Palestinians have a lot of maturing to do as well. Continuing to elect a Hamas-led government? Sheesh.