Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
History of Feminism
Related: About this forumWhat Women are Learning from The Learning Channel
http://www.the-broad-side.com/what-women-are-learning-from-the-learning-channel
...
The show isnt just another Say Yes to the Dress where women are convinced that spending thousands on a big fancy gown is the most important thing in their lives. Its a show that glamorizes the submissive role that women take in a culture that views them only as wives and mothers. For example, most women who are Travelers quit school when theyre very young to help mothers raise the often large numbers of children their mothers had. One such woman left school when she was 11-years-old just to help clean the house and care for her nine brothers and sisters. At 17 she was marrying her soon-to-be husband after only a three month engagement. Another 16-year-old girl, eager to find a husband, was engaged in a grabbing ritual, a custom popular in the culture, where young men corner women, and despite repeatedly saying no the boys roughly attempt to force the girls to kiss them. The girl was asked if she felt in danger at all, and she said no of course not its just how things are done.
...
As I watched this horrific ritual unfold, I was tormented with ads for other TLC shows that were just as atrocious. Sister Wives tries to make polygamy in Mormon faiths look mainstream. With millions being spent on recruitment in advertising from the Mormon Church, one would think they wouldnt want to highlight the more controversial side of a faith. I suppose the family is attempting to make polygamy appear acceptable as the husbands bounce around among their harems of wives. It certainly serves as a stark contrast from news reports of young girls removed by authorities after they were forced into polygamous marriages and molested by older men.
During a screening of the documentary Miss Representation, I saw footage of Toddlers and Tiaras, where children, often under five-years-old, are made up, spray tanned, and sequined from top to bottom in attempts to prove that they are the fairest of them all. The cameras follow stage moms and their little girls who are often times sobbing as they refuse to spend hours having their hair and makeup put on. Fake eyelashes glued to them, hair pulled up and ratted to be the biggest, and little girls taught to do sexy dances to entice the judges into thinking theyre adorable and grown-up. The focus isnt on playing with your friends, taking ballet classes, learning how to ride a bike, or read and write; its about who is the cutest and sexiest four-year-old. Not disturbed by the idea of a sexy four-year-old? Watch Toddlers and Tiaras on The Learning Channel.
One of the more successful shows on TLC is the long running series What Not to Wear. A simple show where family and friends of women call in and request their schleppy gal pal get a make-over. The only episode I ever had the misfortune of watching featured a stylist who was at work when the host and camera crew came into her shop. Never mind the inappropriateness of humiliating a woman in her workplace, where women have to work hard enough to garner respect, this woman was so upset she fled to a back room where she was overheard sobbing by the cameras. It took hours for the host and the womans sister to convince her that thousands of dollars in free clothing was the reason to sign over her dignity. What an outstanding thing for women to learn! It isnt how smart you are, how hard you work, or how good a job you do personally or professionally, its all about what you wear. Why dont we see SpikeTV making over some plumber with jeans falling off his ass? When can I expect What Not to Wear to have an episode where Pawn Stars Chumlee is made to look like 007?
...
...
The show isnt just another Say Yes to the Dress where women are convinced that spending thousands on a big fancy gown is the most important thing in their lives. Its a show that glamorizes the submissive role that women take in a culture that views them only as wives and mothers. For example, most women who are Travelers quit school when theyre very young to help mothers raise the often large numbers of children their mothers had. One such woman left school when she was 11-years-old just to help clean the house and care for her nine brothers and sisters. At 17 she was marrying her soon-to-be husband after only a three month engagement. Another 16-year-old girl, eager to find a husband, was engaged in a grabbing ritual, a custom popular in the culture, where young men corner women, and despite repeatedly saying no the boys roughly attempt to force the girls to kiss them. The girl was asked if she felt in danger at all, and she said no of course not its just how things are done.
...
As I watched this horrific ritual unfold, I was tormented with ads for other TLC shows that were just as atrocious. Sister Wives tries to make polygamy in Mormon faiths look mainstream. With millions being spent on recruitment in advertising from the Mormon Church, one would think they wouldnt want to highlight the more controversial side of a faith. I suppose the family is attempting to make polygamy appear acceptable as the husbands bounce around among their harems of wives. It certainly serves as a stark contrast from news reports of young girls removed by authorities after they were forced into polygamous marriages and molested by older men.
During a screening of the documentary Miss Representation, I saw footage of Toddlers and Tiaras, where children, often under five-years-old, are made up, spray tanned, and sequined from top to bottom in attempts to prove that they are the fairest of them all. The cameras follow stage moms and their little girls who are often times sobbing as they refuse to spend hours having their hair and makeup put on. Fake eyelashes glued to them, hair pulled up and ratted to be the biggest, and little girls taught to do sexy dances to entice the judges into thinking theyre adorable and grown-up. The focus isnt on playing with your friends, taking ballet classes, learning how to ride a bike, or read and write; its about who is the cutest and sexiest four-year-old. Not disturbed by the idea of a sexy four-year-old? Watch Toddlers and Tiaras on The Learning Channel.
One of the more successful shows on TLC is the long running series What Not to Wear. A simple show where family and friends of women call in and request their schleppy gal pal get a make-over. The only episode I ever had the misfortune of watching featured a stylist who was at work when the host and camera crew came into her shop. Never mind the inappropriateness of humiliating a woman in her workplace, where women have to work hard enough to garner respect, this woman was so upset she fled to a back room where she was overheard sobbing by the cameras. It took hours for the host and the womans sister to convince her that thousands of dollars in free clothing was the reason to sign over her dignity. What an outstanding thing for women to learn! It isnt how smart you are, how hard you work, or how good a job you do personally or professionally, its all about what you wear. Why dont we see SpikeTV making over some plumber with jeans falling off his ass? When can I expect What Not to Wear to have an episode where Pawn Stars Chumlee is made to look like 007?
...
I hope more and more women are using this kind of programming as an opportunity to talk to their female friends and relatives about "What Not to Watch", and why.
That's the one good thing about these shows. Knowledgeable people can use them as excellent teachable moments.
InfoView thread info, including edit history
TrashPut this thread in your Trash Can (My DU » Trash Can)
BookmarkAdd this thread to your Bookmarks (My DU » Bookmarks)
3 replies, 1493 views
ShareGet links to this post and/or share on social media
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
ReplyReply to this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
Rec (13)
ReplyReply to this post
3 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
What Women are Learning from The Learning Channel (Original Post)
redqueen
Aug 2012
OP
The author of the piece is apparently unaware that "reality" shows are entirely scripted.
PSPS
Aug 2012
#1
time magazine had an article on polygamy and mainstreaming it. i went on an hour rant
seabeyond
Aug 2012
#3
PSPS
(13,588 posts)1. The author of the piece is apparently unaware that "reality" shows are entirely scripted.
pansypoo53219
(20,969 posts)2. i REFUSE to watch TLC.
NEVER AGAIN. and then i only watched trading places.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)3. time magazine had an article on polygamy and mainstreaming it. i went on an hour rant
with my two boys, before they read the article, lol.
then on the other side, we have hbo. purposeful effort to make gratuitous full frontal nudity a norm. purposely to eliminate that line. now granted, there is no male full frontal nudity that they all want us to relax about. it is only full frontal women nudity that we are suppose to accept as the norm.
i have never watched TLC. i do not watch tv.