Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

calimary

(81,127 posts)
42. Welcome to DU, Gal Friday. I'm afraid I can't agree with you on that.
Sun Sep 30, 2012, 04:28 PM
Sep 2012

Tim Russert disappointed me greatly. As a retired broadcast journalist myself, I was acutely - and sometimes uncomfortably - aware that as the business was increasingly deregulated, the goal of presenting both sides honestly, equally, and dispassionately seemed to fade from a lot of my colleagues.

Once upon a time, no network anchor or lead correspondent would wear a campaign button favoring one party's candidate over another to a social event where many of his/her peers and newsmakers of all kinds were in attendance, and then go around flashing it sneakily to various key people. You were supposed to be objective AT ALL TIMES. Your credibility and impartiality were sacrosanct - and all you had to reinforce your own good name. You were expected to cut through the crap, not show favoritism, and make sure equal attention was paid to each side. You would not even think of loading up your talking-head panels or table of guests with a 3:1 or sometimes 4:1 ratio favoring one party over another. You would seek out the views of those who weren't getting comparable attention, and not completely suppress them. Tim Russert did all those things, and with an increasingly noticeable gleeful twinkle in his eye. As the persecution of Bill Clinton grew to a shrieking climax in the late '90's, Russert gobbled it up hungrily, using his "Meet the Press" vehicle to further the agenda and the policies and the successes of the GOP. He continued through the bush-2 years with an almost obscenely lopsided presentation favoring the bush/cheney administration, serving as one of the lead cheerleaders for the drive toward war in Iraq. There were precious few voices offered airtime or face time on "Meet the Press" AT ALL during those years. And he shilled for dubya's victories in 2000 and 2004. It was he who wore that bush/cheney campaign button into a big reception hosted by GE CEO Jack Welch, and he'd flash his jacket open to specific people to make sure they knew where his heart secretly belonged. And Jack Welch made a point of being IN the NBC Network Newsroom on Selection night and, many of us believe, did so to make sure his presence was CLEARLY felt all over the newsroom - by a room full of employees who knew painfully well which side Welch was betting on.

The way things were ramrodded through during the dubya years, and impeded during the Clinton years - was LED, at least at NBC News, by Tim Russert. He set the tone, as host and managing editor of "Meet the Press," which is still regarded as the longtime and highly-venerable news program of record on Sunday mornings. Its reputation was severely tarnished during the partisan Tim Russert years. I used to admire him, but as I watched his objectivity fade, my dislike for him and distrust of him only grew stronger.

Full disclosure, I got into the news business during the mid-70s when the FCC began to make it clear to America's radio and TV stations and networks that they better start hiring some women. I worked for some of the biggest local news stations and news departments, and at the network level at NBC News, ABC News, the RKO Radio Network, and a couple of brief bits for the Mutual Radio Network while it still existed.

Tim Russert was once a hero of mine. Unfortunately, that changed. Frankly, a LOT of those people I idolized and grew up wishing I'd someday be able to work with some of them turned out to be as guilty of bias and news malpractice as Tim Russert. Russert became a wholly-owned subsidiary of Chairman Jack Welch, of NBC's parent company, and did not do a thing that he knew would displease the big guy. Many of them were swept away into Bias-land during the Clinton years, with the pile-on and media takeover by the wrong wing and all its think tanks and propaganda campaigns and rewordings and re-meming, and the development of Pox Noise.

This was made possible by the dismantling of the Fairness Doctrine and Equal Time Provisions at the end of the reagan era, after "the Gipper" had spent his entire regime softening up America to the idea that government was something bad instead of something "of the people, by the people, and for the people" as an instrument for the common good. reagan got us all brainwashed into thinking regulations were bad and taxing the rich was worse, and that the poor were nothing but lazy moochers. His rightful heir, lo these many years later, is mitt wrongney, as we've seen. And as big business was unshackled from the frenzy of mergers and acquisitions - and the kind of slicky-boy ponzi schemes that wrongney himself pioneered at Bain Capital in the hedge fund heyday. By the time Clinton came along, the other shoe was forced to drop - with the restrictions on media ownership lifted. WHICH MEANT that any big conglomerate could own as many broadcast/media/cable/TV/radio properties in any one market as they wanted. No further restrictions. They crowded out all the mom and pop stations like the ones where I got my start, and sold eager CONservative legislators on the idea that more consolidated corporate ownership would ironically provide MORE consumer choices! What a crock of shit THAT was. We can all see the results of that crimping and pinching and "narrow-casting" as a handful of Goliaths can run the table because they own it all - and they have cluster managers now, one programmer or programming consultant overseeing maybe half-a-dozen stations (all playing pretty much the same damn thing, no personality DJ "clutter" and the same damn stale boring hits that you can hear on 20 other stations in the same town). When I was starting, it was ONE P.D. per station. ONE News Director per station. ONE Music Director per station. ONE Chief Engineer per station. There were also unions clearly delineating who did what. By the time I retired, the unions had been defanged, declawed, and skinned alive, and as stations merged, the layoffs of whole departments (for example, it might be 90% of the AM staff that got laid off and the FM staff would then have to double up on the work load - and for no additional pay).

Sorry - I could rant on about what happened - for many pages longer than this. I saw the mission of reporters and anchors and producers shift - from OBJECTIVELY covering the news, and getting to the bottom of the story, and asking follow-up questions at a press availability, and not gluing yourself to pre-determined questions during an interview - to not rocking the boat if it might piss off some sponsor or friend of the general manager. I saw people coming into the business who thought their job was merely to let Guy #A spout off his piece, and then Guy #B spout of his piece, and that was that and "well, we'll just have to leave it there..." RATHER THAN - "excuse me Guy #A but do you realize what you just said was NOT true?" No. They thought their job was just to show this side and that side, or read from their press releases, and then leave it at that. No analysis, no truth-digging, no fact-checking. I have heard, over and over, ad nauseam, versions of "it's not MY job as a journalist to sift through what they say or fact-check them..." THE HELL IT ISN'T!!!!!!! The result is, the falsehoods stay alive, unchallenged, unquestioned, and there's nothing added or inserted to check them in any way.

And as a result, we had a Presidential election completely STOLEN (some also argue with facts to back them up) that not only the 2000 election but the 2004 election was stolen as well. And we were ramrodded into an illegal, immoral war in Iraq - whose objectors and challengers and questioners were ignored and muzzled by the media. And that brings us back around to prominent news figures like Tim Russert. AND Tom Brokaw. AND Chris Wallace, AND Diane Sawyer, and George Stephanopulous, and Wolf Blitzer, and LEGIONS more who pay more attention to who's signing their massive paychecks and what those paymasters expect in exchange for those princely salaries. And they should be paying attention to THE NEWS. And even more critically important, THE TRUTH.

This is just what I saw, and the dots I connected, being neck-deep in it for quite awhile - maybe a quarter-century or so, give or take a few months.

Gregory has got to be replaced. FarPoint Sep 2012 #1
I stopped watching it before Tim Russert died. proud2BlibKansan Sep 2012 #37
If Timmy had lived... FarPoint Sep 2012 #58
Probably so. proud2BlibKansan Sep 2012 #59
I stopped watching MTP too around the same time. dmr Sep 2012 #70
Gregory liberalmike27 Oct 2012 #92
i only watch when it's 'fair and balanced'. ellenfl Oct 2012 #104
i thought he'd be better than timmy. wrong. eom ellenfl Oct 2012 #102
I just quit This Week w/ Jorge Popadopalous after….. 12AngryBorneoWildmen Oct 2012 #90
The right wing guests (which is ALL the guests) would boycott BlueStreak Oct 2012 #105
Meet the Press uses GOP Talking Points? BootinUp Sep 2012 #2
He is no Tim R awake Sep 2012 #3
He's not even Luke R. JeffHead Sep 2012 #5
Timmy sucked ass too. Warren Stupidity Sep 2012 #6
Don't blaspheme Gal Friday Sep 2012 #10
The best at what? BootinUp Sep 2012 #12
The best Seedersandleechers Sep 2012 #30
Wasn't Timmy hand picked by that Jack Welch jag-off? Hassin Bin Sober Sep 2012 #48
We could go in a few rude directions with this one! ... eom Kolesar Oct 2012 #76
Yes, at cheering for Bush, he was truly the best. proud2BlibKansan Sep 2012 #38
Russert SUCKED!!!!!! Submariner Sep 2012 #41
Welcome to DU, Gal Friday. I'm afraid I can't agree with you on that. calimary Sep 2012 #42
Calimary Iwillnevergiveup Sep 2012 #51
Wow what a fantastic post tularetom Sep 2012 #57
Thank you for this informative post. nt Doremus Sep 2012 #60
Very interesting treestar Sep 2012 #63
Great post! Le Taz Hot Sep 2012 #65
thank you for that brilliant post LittleGirl Oct 2012 #79
Well said! I've been an avid "newswatcher" since the 1960s... OldDem2012 Oct 2012 #80
wonderful post, thank you ! nt steve2470 Oct 2012 #83
Fascinating post calimary... horseshoecrab Oct 2012 #84
Very, very enlightening...and very much the impression I had at the time. maddiemom Oct 2012 #89
Very informative post! and well written! Thanks for taking the time to inform. nt AnotherMother4Peace Oct 2012 #93
Just Going to Say liberalmike27 Oct 2012 #96
Hear, Hear. Smickey Oct 2012 #100
Great post. speedoo Oct 2012 #109
Thank you for your first person sharing. Delphinus Oct 2012 #113
hardly SemperEadem Sep 2012 #56
Have to forgive you because you are new. You should use the sarcasm emoticon. rhett o rick Sep 2012 #62
"Tim Russert was the best." Spitfire of ATJ Oct 2012 #74
Russert was very good at making people claim that he was an actual journalist Orrex Oct 2012 #75
If you mean the "best" at supporting GOP positions... OldDem2012 Oct 2012 #78
sry emilyg RandiFan1290 Oct 2012 #81
I agree with that amuse bouche Sep 2012 #35
There was that show where Cheney was on, telling one lie after another, and Russert just SAT THERE. proud2BlibKansan Sep 2012 #39
Russert was far worse a tool, to put it charitably since he is deceased. nt MADem Sep 2012 #45
Did Plouffe not call him on that? classof56 Sep 2012 #4
I am glad its football season! SCVDem Sep 2012 #7
How do we contact NBC to demand a correction out of him? SoapBox Sep 2012 #8
Here: Zoeisright Sep 2012 #14
Thanks for link nt Progressive dog Sep 2012 #23
Yes! Thank you! SoapBox Sep 2012 #28
Thank you so much Sekhmets Daughter Sep 2012 #32
Thanks lillypaddle Sep 2012 #46
A new host is in order... cheriemedium59 Sep 2012 #9
oh he is back and badder then ever -Gregory ask him about Jack?? lunasun Sep 2012 #22
Stopped watching that show a long time ago. Its a wate of time. Except if Rachel is on. JoePhilly Sep 2012 #11
David YOU NEED TO GO AND GET REPLACED BY RACHAEL MEADOW Denise21 Sep 2012 #13
No, we need a person who represents NO ONE, just reports and moderates without editorializing! George II Oct 2012 #88
They should return to the original format. ieoeja Oct 2012 #91
Correct - there used to be a "round table" (rectangular of course!).. George II Oct 2012 #97
KKKarl Rove's dance partner distorts the record to benefit republicans? Blue Idaho Sep 2012 #15
lol BootinUp Sep 2012 #17
does anyone still watch MTP? underthematrix Sep 2012 #16
More people watch Mass for Shut Ins..... WCGreen Sep 2012 #18
original article by THinkProgress, not the repackaged story at this link OKNancy Sep 2012 #19
Thanks for the link, OKNancy.. the comments Cha Sep 2012 #40
Dave! You ignorant slut... /nt Festivito Sep 2012 #20
Funny! SoapBox Sep 2012 #29
NBC = mainstream media whores, they don't care one bit about truth just1voice Sep 2012 #21
Normal people don't watch MTP (NT) The Wizard Sep 2012 #24
Thanks! I LOVE reaffirmation Plucketeer Sep 2012 #34
I was taking a short siesta and it came on like a bad dream. TahitiNut Sep 2012 #49
screw dances with rove madokie Sep 2012 #25
My brain has seizures if someone in my house has him on the TV. graywarrior Sep 2012 #26
Oh how I miss the days when journalists peddled truth instead of narratives. LonePirate Sep 2012 #27
Forgive me for my senior moment. left on green only Sep 2012 #31
What can you expect from a RW shill? nt valerief Sep 2012 #33
Press the Meat sucks. longship Sep 2012 #36
Good old left leaning media!! SaveAmerica Sep 2012 #43
Silly media whore. JNelson6563 Sep 2012 #44
David Gregory is in full-out fallatio of the GOP, giving Ralph Reed the deluxe treatment. TahitiNut Sep 2012 #47
Gregory is a media whore Jakes Progress Sep 2012 #50
I can't stomach more than 10 minutes of Meet the Press ElboRuum Sep 2012 #52
This guy only has to prepare for one hour a week aint_no_life_nowhere Sep 2012 #53
Gregory is a GOP tool and always has been. McCamy Taylor Sep 2012 #54
How did Ploufe respond? I've heard Obama say close to, if not exactly, what Gregory claimed. SleeplessinSoCal Sep 2012 #55
When has President Obama claimed Al Qaeda is defeated? .99center Sep 2012 #64
I've been trying to find a link, but can't. SleeplessinSoCal Oct 2012 #114
gregory is a disaster, He can be replaced by a ham sandwich. NYtoBush-Drop Dead Sep 2012 #61
Dick Gregory and Karl Rove. Repeat until you puke: freshwest Sep 2012 #66
David Gregory is a tool. tibbir Sep 2012 #67
MC Rove and Gregory Dancing Together Timbuk3 Sep 2012 #68
Sorry Timbuk3 Sep 2012 #69
As the top commenter wrote of this on YouTube: Chiyo-chichi Oct 2012 #82
David Gregory is BE10sCoach Oct 2012 #71
Well He Has To Get Invited To All Those Fancy Parties YOHABLO Oct 2012 #72
IDK why but CheapShotArtist Oct 2012 #73
STOP WATCHING THE BOBBLEHEAD SHOWS Iggy Oct 2012 #77
Yep. We deserve better and until that day I cannot support it. nt raouldukelives Oct 2012 #94
Duke!! Iggy Oct 2012 #112
David Gregory OLDMDDEM Oct 2012 #85
All I can say is YUCK David Gregory what a tool. occupymybrain Oct 2012 #86
David Gregory does too much news and issue "creation" - he's HORRIBLE and highly subjective! George II Oct 2012 #87
We need to take back the "Public Airwaves!" 6 corporations own 90% of media! Dustlawyer Oct 2012 #95
This is a surprise? Doctor_J Oct 2012 #98
Why is an overpaid Republican Toady allowed to moderate and spin this show? Berlum Oct 2012 #99
David Gregory = hack FlyByNight Oct 2012 #101
Meet the Press has gone into the crapper since I was kid,,,,,,,, benld74 Oct 2012 #103
The comment I made on this issue yesterday green917 Oct 2012 #106
well done. Nt speedoo Oct 2012 #108
Well said. Smickey Oct 2012 #110
Kicked and recommended. Uncle Joe Oct 2012 #107
We need to petition this and get him to do a retraction! Kteachums Oct 2012 #111
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»‘Meet The Press’ host cau...»Reply #42