Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Economy
In reply to the discussion: Weekend Economists Reminisce: Black Monday October 19, 1987-2012 [View all]Demeter
(85,373 posts)6. Romney is shocked to learn how the Fed creates money By William K. Black
http://neweconomicperspectives.org/2012/10/romney-is-shocked-to-learn-how-the-fed-creates-money.html
The following passage from the transcript of Governor Romneys secretly videotaped May 17, 2012 fundraiser has not received any attention in the media. It is a fascinating passage, however, from the perspective of Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). Here is the full context of the passage:
........................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................
There is one important error in the transcription of Romneys remarks, which I confirmed by listening to the videotape. Romney quotes John Whitehead as saying were gonna have a failed Treasury option. That phrase does not make any sense. What Romney actually stated when he was quoting Whitehead was were gonna have a failed Treasury auction. Romney was endorsing Whiteheads claim that investors will stop buying Treasury bonds.
Lets begin with who Whitehead is. He was in fact the head of Goldman Sachs before joining the Reagan administration as a senior official. He was also the Chairman of the Board of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York (FRBNY). Note that Romney considers him to have been the head of the FRBNY. That demonstrates why the regional Fed banks should have no governmental function the banking interests run the regional Fed banks if Romney is correct. The regional Fed banks are the primary examiners and supervisors of the Federal Reserve System an obvious and untenable conflict of interest. Whitehead is also an old-fashioned liquidator a not very modern incarnation of President Hoovers Treasury Secretary, Andrew Mellon. Paul Krugman cites the key passage in Mellons rant.
Whitehead believes that the budget deficit and Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid are the great threats and that our nation could be forced to default on its debts. Hyper-inflation is just around the corner. He wants a firm regime of austerity. That should pose two insurmountable problems for Romney. First, Romney is on record stating that austerity would throw us into recession or depression. Second, Whitehead says that what the nation desperately needs to avoid a debt collapse is elected officials who will champion and vote for higher taxes. Romney is promising very large tax cuts (supposedly offset by ending a handful of tax deductions used primarily by the wealthy a mathematical impossibility). Naturally, Romney did not tell his wealthy donors that Whitehead was warning that Americas survival depended on them paying much higher taxes. Romney did not tell his donors or voters that he rejects both of Whiteheads primary policy recommendations despite the fact that Whitehead warns that rejection of his policies will lead to an inevitable, catastrophic U.S. economic collapse.
With the Whitehead preliminaries out of the way we can now discuss Romneys unintentional endorsement of MMT. Let us assume for purposes of analysis that Whitehead is correct that The Feds buy like 3/4 of the debt that America issues. Whitehead and Romney treat this asserted fact as proof that the U.S. is about to suffer an inability to auction debt. They imply that the Fed is buying U.S. debt issuances because the rest of the world has ceased doing so. They imply that the asserted Fed purchases of 3/4 of U.S. debt issuances must be a last gasp measure that can only briefly delay an inevitable default. Whitehead and Romney have made public these asserted facts and analytics for many months. The purported Fed last gap strategy for delaying the inevitable bond default is so crude and so large that Whitehead and Romney believe it must be on the verge of collapse. The U.S. bond markets the broadest, most efficient, and most sophisticated in the world must have reacted to this proof of an inevitable, near-term default by pricing this risk of inevitable, catastrophic default. After all, the presumed one-quarter of U.S. debt issuances still purchased by investors other than the Fed represents a massive amount of money and those investors would suffer catastrophic losses in the event of default so they have every financial incentive to demand a premium interest rate to compensate for that default risk.
We can examine Whitehead and Romneys analytics by observing the surging interest rates on U.S. debt issuances, which should be extremely high given Whiteheads claims about the near inevitability of a U.S. default. It was with the greatest trepidation that I just looked up that raging rate. The two-year U.S. note has reached the perilous yield of 0.274 and the 10-year note has skyrocketed to 1.658. Clearly, professional investors believe that we have already passed the precipice and have only delayed briefly our plunge into the bottomless pit of default by a fingernail grip on the lip of that pit.
Several other important points about MMT also arise from Whiteheads and Romneys claims about money. First, the whole the U.S. deficit is a disaster because we owe a debt to China blows up. Were now supposed to panic because we owe ourselves an extra trillion dollars.
Second, if the Fed is buying our debt, then it is not in fact debt. It is simply an accounting game. If Division A of Corporation Z sells bonds to Division B of Corporation Z there is no change in Corporation Zs debt levels. That fact should have led Whitehead and Romney to ask why Treasury was bothering to sell U.S. debt to the Fed. The Feds surplus goes to the Treasury, so the Whitehead and Romney theory cannot be that Treasury has run out of money and the Fed has a trillion dollars in extra money that it is lending to the Treasury as a last gap effort to delay the inevitable default on U.S. bonds. The Fed could simply send its hypothetical $1 trillion in extra money to the Treasury as a component of its annual distribution to the Treasury. There is also the small matter that on any accounting basis the Fed does not have remotely a trillion dollars of capital. If Whitehead and Romney think that the Fed is buying a trillion dollars in Treasury bonds how do they think the Fed got the money to buy the bonds? It is in attempting to answer this question that Whitehead and Romney began to stumble unintentionally into how money is actually often created by a nation with a sovereign currency. Their problem is that they cannot believe the truth. Indeed, they boggle at the very concept. You can see it in the transcript of Romneys meeting with his donors.
Yes, the Federal Reserve just made up money by making keystrokes on a computer. Romney thinks this is unheard of and unimaginable. In reality, it is the day-to-day reality in central banks around the world. Whitehead has to know this. None of this means that the world is about to end; it in fact does augur well for our economic future. Banks created money long before computers were invented. Sovereign, freely-floating currencies are the norm in much of the world because they have proven superior. The gold standard was a superb device for producing periodic depressions...
MORE
The following passage from the transcript of Governor Romneys secretly videotaped May 17, 2012 fundraiser has not received any attention in the media. It is a fascinating passage, however, from the perspective of Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). Here is the full context of the passage:
........................................................................................................................
MALE VOICE: One comment, Governor.
MITT ROMNEY: Yes.
MALE VOICE: The debates are gonna be coming and I hope at the right moment you can turn to President Obama, look at the American people and say, If you vote to reelect President Obama youre voting to bankrupt the United States. I hope you keep that in your quiver, because thats whats gonna happen. And I think its gonna be very effective. In some (UNINTEL).
MITT ROMNEY: Yeah. Yeah. Its its interesting. Theres the former head of Goldman Sachs, John Whitehead was also the former head of the New York Federal Reserve and and I met with him and he said, As soon as the Fed stops buying all the debt that were issuing which theyve been doing. The Feds buy like 3/4 of the debt that America issues.
He said, Once once that over thats over, he said, were gonna have a failed Treasury option. Interest rates are gonna have to go up. You know, were were were living in this borrowed fantasy world where where the government keeps on borrowing money. You know, we we borrow this extra trillion a year. We wonder, Well, whos whos loaning against the Treasury? The Chinese arent loaning to us anymore. The Russians arent loaning it to us anymore. So whos giving us a trillion?
And the answer is were just making it up. The Federal Reserve is is just taking it and saying, Here, were were giving its just made up money. And and this this does not augur well for for our economic future. No. I mean I you know, some of these things are are complex enough its not easy for people to understand, but your your point of saying bankruptcy usually concentrates the money. Yeah, George?
MITT ROMNEY: Yes.
MALE VOICE: The debates are gonna be coming and I hope at the right moment you can turn to President Obama, look at the American people and say, If you vote to reelect President Obama youre voting to bankrupt the United States. I hope you keep that in your quiver, because thats whats gonna happen. And I think its gonna be very effective. In some (UNINTEL).
MITT ROMNEY: Yeah. Yeah. Its its interesting. Theres the former head of Goldman Sachs, John Whitehead was also the former head of the New York Federal Reserve and and I met with him and he said, As soon as the Fed stops buying all the debt that were issuing which theyve been doing. The Feds buy like 3/4 of the debt that America issues.
He said, Once once that over thats over, he said, were gonna have a failed Treasury option. Interest rates are gonna have to go up. You know, were were were living in this borrowed fantasy world where where the government keeps on borrowing money. You know, we we borrow this extra trillion a year. We wonder, Well, whos whos loaning against the Treasury? The Chinese arent loaning to us anymore. The Russians arent loaning it to us anymore. So whos giving us a trillion?
And the answer is were just making it up. The Federal Reserve is is just taking it and saying, Here, were were giving its just made up money. And and this this does not augur well for for our economic future. No. I mean I you know, some of these things are are complex enough its not easy for people to understand, but your your point of saying bankruptcy usually concentrates the money. Yeah, George?
....................................................................................................................
There is one important error in the transcription of Romneys remarks, which I confirmed by listening to the videotape. Romney quotes John Whitehead as saying were gonna have a failed Treasury option. That phrase does not make any sense. What Romney actually stated when he was quoting Whitehead was were gonna have a failed Treasury auction. Romney was endorsing Whiteheads claim that investors will stop buying Treasury bonds.
Lets begin with who Whitehead is. He was in fact the head of Goldman Sachs before joining the Reagan administration as a senior official. He was also the Chairman of the Board of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York (FRBNY). Note that Romney considers him to have been the head of the FRBNY. That demonstrates why the regional Fed banks should have no governmental function the banking interests run the regional Fed banks if Romney is correct. The regional Fed banks are the primary examiners and supervisors of the Federal Reserve System an obvious and untenable conflict of interest. Whitehead is also an old-fashioned liquidator a not very modern incarnation of President Hoovers Treasury Secretary, Andrew Mellon. Paul Krugman cites the key passage in Mellons rant.
Treasury secretary Andrew Mellon, according to Herbert Hoover:
Liquidate labor, liquidate stocks, liquidate the farmers, liquidate real estate. It will purge the rottenness out of the system. High costs of living and high living will come down. People will work harder, live a more moral life. Values will be adjusted, and enterprising people will pick up the wrecks from less competent people.
Liquidate labor, liquidate stocks, liquidate the farmers, liquidate real estate. It will purge the rottenness out of the system. High costs of living and high living will come down. People will work harder, live a more moral life. Values will be adjusted, and enterprising people will pick up the wrecks from less competent people.
Whitehead believes that the budget deficit and Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid are the great threats and that our nation could be forced to default on its debts. Hyper-inflation is just around the corner. He wants a firm regime of austerity. That should pose two insurmountable problems for Romney. First, Romney is on record stating that austerity would throw us into recession or depression. Second, Whitehead says that what the nation desperately needs to avoid a debt collapse is elected officials who will champion and vote for higher taxes. Romney is promising very large tax cuts (supposedly offset by ending a handful of tax deductions used primarily by the wealthy a mathematical impossibility). Naturally, Romney did not tell his wealthy donors that Whitehead was warning that Americas survival depended on them paying much higher taxes. Romney did not tell his donors or voters that he rejects both of Whiteheads primary policy recommendations despite the fact that Whitehead warns that rejection of his policies will lead to an inevitable, catastrophic U.S. economic collapse.
With the Whitehead preliminaries out of the way we can now discuss Romneys unintentional endorsement of MMT. Let us assume for purposes of analysis that Whitehead is correct that The Feds buy like 3/4 of the debt that America issues. Whitehead and Romney treat this asserted fact as proof that the U.S. is about to suffer an inability to auction debt. They imply that the Fed is buying U.S. debt issuances because the rest of the world has ceased doing so. They imply that the asserted Fed purchases of 3/4 of U.S. debt issuances must be a last gasp measure that can only briefly delay an inevitable default. Whitehead and Romney have made public these asserted facts and analytics for many months. The purported Fed last gap strategy for delaying the inevitable bond default is so crude and so large that Whitehead and Romney believe it must be on the verge of collapse. The U.S. bond markets the broadest, most efficient, and most sophisticated in the world must have reacted to this proof of an inevitable, near-term default by pricing this risk of inevitable, catastrophic default. After all, the presumed one-quarter of U.S. debt issuances still purchased by investors other than the Fed represents a massive amount of money and those investors would suffer catastrophic losses in the event of default so they have every financial incentive to demand a premium interest rate to compensate for that default risk.
We can examine Whitehead and Romneys analytics by observing the surging interest rates on U.S. debt issuances, which should be extremely high given Whiteheads claims about the near inevitability of a U.S. default. It was with the greatest trepidation that I just looked up that raging rate. The two-year U.S. note has reached the perilous yield of 0.274 and the 10-year note has skyrocketed to 1.658. Clearly, professional investors believe that we have already passed the precipice and have only delayed briefly our plunge into the bottomless pit of default by a fingernail grip on the lip of that pit.
Several other important points about MMT also arise from Whiteheads and Romneys claims about money. First, the whole the U.S. deficit is a disaster because we owe a debt to China blows up. Were now supposed to panic because we owe ourselves an extra trillion dollars.
Second, if the Fed is buying our debt, then it is not in fact debt. It is simply an accounting game. If Division A of Corporation Z sells bonds to Division B of Corporation Z there is no change in Corporation Zs debt levels. That fact should have led Whitehead and Romney to ask why Treasury was bothering to sell U.S. debt to the Fed. The Feds surplus goes to the Treasury, so the Whitehead and Romney theory cannot be that Treasury has run out of money and the Fed has a trillion dollars in extra money that it is lending to the Treasury as a last gap effort to delay the inevitable default on U.S. bonds. The Fed could simply send its hypothetical $1 trillion in extra money to the Treasury as a component of its annual distribution to the Treasury. There is also the small matter that on any accounting basis the Fed does not have remotely a trillion dollars of capital. If Whitehead and Romney think that the Fed is buying a trillion dollars in Treasury bonds how do they think the Fed got the money to buy the bonds? It is in attempting to answer this question that Whitehead and Romney began to stumble unintentionally into how money is actually often created by a nation with a sovereign currency. Their problem is that they cannot believe the truth. Indeed, they boggle at the very concept. You can see it in the transcript of Romneys meeting with his donors.
And the answer is were just making it up. The Federal Reserve is is just taking it and saying, Here, were were giving its just made up money. And and this this does not augur well for for our economic future.
Yes, the Federal Reserve just made up money by making keystrokes on a computer. Romney thinks this is unheard of and unimaginable. In reality, it is the day-to-day reality in central banks around the world. Whitehead has to know this. None of this means that the world is about to end; it in fact does augur well for our economic future. Banks created money long before computers were invented. Sovereign, freely-floating currencies are the norm in much of the world because they have proven superior. The gold standard was a superb device for producing periodic depressions...
MORE
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
71 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Pain Only Getting Worse: Spanish Population Falls, Portugal Goes For More Failed Austerity
Demeter
Oct 2012
#5
Form of Depression Is Emerging That Doctors Don't Know How to Treat ... And Its Causes Are Economic
xchrom
Oct 2012
#33
an interlude-- joni mitchell - she is a better than average chanteuse and shows it
xchrom
Oct 2012
#39
SMW is must reading at DU. I cannot possibly thank all of you enough. Each day all of you
mother earth
Oct 2012
#64