Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

xchrom

(108,903 posts)
8. The Obama Administration Isn't Answering The Most Important Question About Attacking Syria
Sat Aug 31, 2013, 06:37 AM
Aug 2013
http://www.businessinsider.com/the-obama-administration-is-answering-the-wrong-questions-on-syria-2013-8

There was something really weird about the Obama Administration's message on Syria today: It was singularly focused on making the case that Syria really did use chemical weapons, and that our intelligence is right this time, unlike in Iraq.

I believe the Administration on this intel. But they are failing to explain why it follows that we should launch a military strike on Syria. What do they think our intervention will do to reduce human suffering in Syria or anywhere else?

Is the idea that our “limited and tailored” intervention will directly interfere with Assad’s chemical weapons capability? Do we hope that it will serve like a spanking, dissuading him from using chemical weapons again? Is the hope that a strike will discourage other wayward dictators from abusing their people, lest they get bombed too?

So far, all we're getting are variants on "something must be done."



Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/the-obama-administration-is-answering-the-wrong-questions-on-syria-2013-8#ixzz2dXf4UGNN
No Bank Failures This Weekend, I'll Wager Demeter Aug 2013 #1
Detroit seeking to borrow $350 mln, terminate swaps deal Demeter Aug 2013 #2
Swaps deal? Detroit? dkf Sep 2013 #76
They sold it to everyone they could gull Demeter Sep 2013 #77
So what do you feel about Larry Summer, swaps and Harvard? dkf Sep 2013 #78
Larry Summers is the greatest threat to our national security, bar none Demeter Sep 2013 #81
If you are saying he will be a disaster I agree. dkf Sep 2013 #82
U.S. consults oil experts as it weighs action against Syria Demeter Aug 2013 #3
Microsoft, Google Say They're Moving Forward With NSA Lawsuit Demeter Aug 2013 #4
Syria, officially the Syrian Arab Republic Demeter Aug 2013 #5
Carry on, Weekenders Demeter Aug 2013 #6
Federal Reserve: Choosing The Chairman xchrom Aug 2013 #7
Summers’ Lending Club makes money by bypassing the Equal Credit Opportunity Act Demeter Sep 2013 #85
The Obama Administration Isn't Answering The Most Important Question About Attacking Syria xchrom Aug 2013 #8
more from article DemReadingDU Aug 2013 #10
I liked andy borowitz's take on it (see friday's SMW) Demeter Aug 2013 #15
The link for anyone to read again DemReadingDU Aug 2013 #24
Developer Says $100 Million Sculpture At Hudson Yards Will Be 'New York's Eiffel Tower' xchrom Aug 2013 #9
Two new targets! Demeter Aug 2013 #13
in his case -- i'm more afraid of an attack of the Ugly. nt xchrom Aug 2013 #18
India’s Rupee Has Worst Month Since 1992 on Slowdown Concern xchrom Aug 2013 #11
Air on the G String xchrom Aug 2013 #12
I'm sending this to the budget and finance committee! Demeter Aug 2013 #14
(try to) Prevent an Attack on Syria Now (petition) Demeter Aug 2013 #16
THE BABY AND THE BAATH WATER--MODERN HISTORY OF SYRIA Demeter Aug 2013 #17
Jordi Savall plays the Celtic Viol - The Nathaniel Gow Set xchrom Aug 2013 #19
That is too marvelous, X - TY (n/t) bread_and_roses Aug 2013 #31
Cooler Spending in U.S. Signals Slow Start for Quarter: Economy xchrom Aug 2013 #20
Consumer Sentiment in U.S. Fell Less Than Forecast in August xchrom Aug 2013 #21
What Syria Teaches Us About Hyperinflation xchrom Aug 2013 #22
Why China Will Oppose Any Strike on Syria xchrom Aug 2013 #23
ANCIENT HISTORY OF SYRIA Demeter Aug 2013 #25
Destroying the roots of civilization - as in Iraq bread_and_roses Aug 2013 #32
Syria, with such stalwart history sure has descended golfguru Aug 2013 #44
Musical Interlude, reprised hamerfan Aug 2013 #26
Musical Interlude II, more on-topic hamerfan Aug 2013 #27
America Totally Discredited By Paul Craig Roberts Demeter Aug 2013 #28
Chemical Hallucinations By William Bowles Demeter Aug 2013 #29
all too true (n/t) bread_and_roses Aug 2013 #30
But, Will TRUTH make any difference in Real Time in this case? Must we always wait for History? Demeter Aug 2013 #34
6 Things To Keep In Mind As Obama Confronts Syria Demeter Aug 2013 #33
Frustrated Obama: I won't be ‘paralyzed’ on Syria Demeter Aug 2013 #35
David Koch: Attacking Syria would be 'dead wrong' Demeter Aug 2013 #36
I'm taking a break to make peach pie now Demeter Aug 2013 #37
Mmmm! hamerfan Aug 2013 #41
Standing invitation--just RSVP--to Weekenders and Marketeers Demeter Aug 2013 #46
YOU MUST SEE THIS GREAT NEWS! Demeter Aug 2013 #38
Muslims challenging 'no fly' list win partial court victory Demeter Aug 2013 #43
TWOFER! Syrians in Ghouta Claim Saudi-Supplied Rebels Behind Chemical Attack Demeter Aug 2013 #39
Meet The Saudi Prince Who Finances the Murderous Egyptian Military, and Crushes Democracy in the Mid Demeter Aug 2013 #40
Pentagon Can’t Afford Syria Operation; Must Seek Additional Funds Demeter Aug 2013 #42
There's no doubt about it. Fuddnik Aug 2013 #45
The 1% Keep Trying to Repeal the Law--Even Nature's Law Demeter Aug 2013 #47
Employment Probably Picked Up in August: U.S. Economy Preview xchrom Sep 2013 #48
Wall Street’s Rental Bet Brings Quandary Housing Poor xchrom Sep 2013 #49
US flatters France as ‘oldest ally’ after UK vote on Syria xchrom Sep 2013 #50
Why Americans Aren't as Willing to Intervene Overseas as They Used to Be xchrom Sep 2013 #51
The Military as 'Abusive Parent': The View Toward Syria From an Exhausted Army xchrom Sep 2013 #52
The Authority to 'Declare War': A Power Barack Obama Does Not Have xchrom Sep 2013 #53
Famed designer Oscar De la Renta criticizes ‘circus’ surrounding Fashion Week xchrom Sep 2013 #54
Under $652 million project code-named ‘GENIE’ U.S. conducted 231 ‘offensive cyberoperations’: xchrom Sep 2013 #55
Syria’s Other Army: How the Hackers Wage War by Matt Buchanan Demeter Sep 2013 #56
City of the Lost In the world’s second-largest refugee camp, Syrians find that it’s not easy to flee Demeter Sep 2013 #57
Syria Intervention Plan Fueled by Oil Interests, Not Concern About Chemical Weapons Demeter Sep 2013 #58
GOD BLESS (SAVE) AMERICA SUB THREAD--LOOKING INTO VARIOUS CRYSTAL BALLS... Demeter Sep 2013 #59
AMERICAN LABOR DAY SUBTHREAD--OH, YEAH, GUESS IT SHOULD BE MENTIONED IN PASSING... Demeter Sep 2013 #60
Freedom From Jobs by ELLIOT SPERBER Demeter Sep 2013 #65
Longshore union pulls out of national AFL-CIO, citing attacks at Northwest grain terminals Demeter Sep 2013 #66
ObamaCare Staggers Toward the October 1 Finish Line (2) By Lambert Strether Demeter Sep 2013 #86
Obamacare Delay? What Obamacare Delay? Demeter Sep 2013 #95
Conflict in Syria: President Pulls Lawmakers Into Box He Made Demeter Sep 2013 #61
America's private prison companies have expanded across the globe Demeter Sep 2013 #62
Raise the (OFFICIAL) Crime Rate (COUNT THE VIOLENCE IN PRISONS) Demeter Sep 2013 #69
Google Received NSA Money, but That’s Not All By Natasha Hakimi Demeter Sep 2013 #63
WIKILEAKS RELEASE Syria: 84,067 sensitive emails from US intelligence contractor Stratfor Demeter Sep 2013 #64
The Troodos Conundrum Demeter Sep 2013 #74
Scary Thought on Labor Day Weekend: Obama's Economic Team Think They Are Doing a Good Job Demeter Sep 2013 #67
Why Wall Street Wants Larry Summers (and Why the Rest of Us Should Not) By Laurence Kotlikoff and Demeter Sep 2013 #68
San Bernardino Becomes 3rd California City to Get Bankruptcy Protection Demeter Sep 2013 #70
Wall Street’s Rental Bet Brings Quandary Housing Poor Demeter Sep 2013 #71
Income Gap Grows Wider (and Faster) Demeter Sep 2013 #72
Senate to vote on Syria resolution no later than week of September 9: Reid Demeter Sep 2013 #73
The ONION features Commentary from Assad: So, What’s It Going To Be? Demeter Sep 2013 #75
KEEPING UP WITH THE NSA SCANDAL--THERE'S JUST SO MUCH OF IT! Demeter Sep 2013 #79
AND EDWARD SNOWDEN GETS HIS OWN SUBTHREAD Demeter Sep 2013 #80
Financial Psalm No. 16 Demeter Sep 2013 #83
in honor of the funeral for seamus heaney today xchrom Sep 2013 #84
Liam O'Flynn - Eire xchrom Sep 2013 #87
MARIA PINTO LAUNCHES NEW COLLECTION ON KICKSTARTER xchrom Sep 2013 #88
SELLING FARMS SOMETIMES CALLS FOR CREATIVE DEALS xchrom Sep 2013 #89
Donal Lunny Andy Irvine Liam O'Flynn Paddy Glackin The Blacksmith xchrom Sep 2013 #90
Falling Indian factory activity adds to rupee's woes xchrom Sep 2013 #91
Regulators ease derivatives rule to avoid harming economy xchrom Sep 2013 #92
BOJ to hold policy, debate emerging market risks xchrom Sep 2013 #93
look out now -- cause i might get my belly dance on xchrom Sep 2013 #94
Whew! Just taking a break from yard work. Fuddnik Sep 2013 #96
So, we went to see Elysium Demeter Sep 2013 #97
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Economy»Weekend Economists Get Sy...»Reply #8